How is 'white people have no culture' related to 'white people have a monoculture'?
You realise we just stop replying because you have made some incredible claims that aren't related to the topic. We realise that chasing goal posts around a field is utterly pointless and you haven't bothered to engaged in the argument. We were on Whoopi Goldberg and in two short steps we are talking about monoculture. Through some vapid tenuous links that are more about you being angry and trying to press an 'I WIN' button
Also, where was you're comeback or whatever for my last comment. Failing your own criteria huh? Anyway, sometimes things don't need a reply. It's okay
Here's what I'll say about Whoopi. I understand that she didn't mean what she said. I think that she got confused in her statement. What she was saying wasn't mutually exclusive. But she did need to answer questions. Because her statement goes against everything we have been taught about WW2. And strays far to close to conspiracy theory. It's like when Peterson came out with his 'Forced Monogamy' concept. He needed to answer questions about what that means. At least Whoopi isnt a troll trying to score pollical points like JP is
Because it's a hyperbolic exaggerated position to say they have no culture the implication being no culture that matters or is worth while often spouted by people who claim White people just steal from every other culture and have never contributed anything worthwhile to the world.
The only person chasing goal posts is me trying to get an answer as to why what Whoopi Goldberg said is wrong fundamentally while also people are pushing that the opposite of her position that Jewish people aren't like as other white people and are uniquely 'different' also is evil.
So yes people do say this shit commonly enough for it to get noticed.
So how is it related to the Whoopi Goldberg thing? Well because White people monoculture
American actor's wiki page : 'He is of Irish, German and Swedish descent' Me: 'Ah, so he's white.'
Because I figured it wouldn't embed and I can't trust the normal gaggle people who will no doubt reply to click and link and read what was actually said, I learned my lesson last time and spent pages arguing having to quote directly from the article they claimed to have read to point out where they were wrong until they admitted to having not read it.
You've made two conflicting claims, that the woke view is that white people have no culture and that white people are a monoculture. And neither of them are actually the "woke view".
The "woke" view is that there is no such thing as white culture because predominantly "white" countries have their own distinct cultures. We're also still arguing over who is and isn't white for Christ's sake, how can there be a shared culture? The regressives are the ones who believe there is an overarching "white" culture. As a "white" guy who's grandfather, who has the same skin colour as me but was decidedly not considered white when he went to England to find work, I absolutely agree that there is no such thing as "white culture". Germans have a different culture to me. French have a different culture to me.
Except the conflict is in woke world.
Was Whoopi wrong or right?
Because therefore it makes the other side wrong or right in doing so.
It's hypocritical for people to be defending those who raved at Whoopi while also trying to condemn people who said basically the opposite of her.
Also no the woke view is all white culture is the same, sorry I don't make the rules for woke world. The actually progressive view is that all countries have their own cultures etc but that doesn't fit into the lovely woke world "progressive stack" model of balancing out inequalities because white people are the oppressors in said model.