Overwatch 2; The Electric Boogaloo

FakeSympathy

Elite Member
Legacy
Jun 8, 2015
3,505
3,234
118
Seattle, WA
Country
US
So I am gonna structure my review a bit different this time; I am gonna start with a perfect score of 100, and take off 5 points each time the game pisses me off. That’s right, this game has 20 chances for me to find at least some salvageable parts about the game. The game will also have a chance of earning the lost points, but it would have to be pretty significant.

So before you can evne play the game, you gotta have phone number for “extra security. That’s already the first offense. Way to enforce giving out personal info there, Acti-Blizz! The irony is hilarious. (-5)

So as soon as the game boots up, you are placed in a queue of about “40000 players” ahead of you. It’s not that long. Obviously folks at Acti-Blizz didn’t anticipate such back-up! /s That’s already one thing that annoys me (-5). We’re off to a fine start. Acti-Blizz as of writing this post is blaming it on a DDOS attack. Yep, they are saying “We got hacked, lol!” instead of actually admitting their piss-poor management. Off with more points! (-5) Yeah, it will get resolved eventually, but it’s amazing how under prepared they were. WTF. And the attempt for connection is affecting my network as a whole. I really can’t do anything else on my pc. So that’s another 5 points off! (-5) We haven’t even gon into the game yet but it already lost 20 points. Fantastic

Probably two weeks later when you finally get in, the game shoves itself in your face with all the typical live-service bullshit. “Buy our premium battle pass!” “Upgrade your experience with battle pass”, etc. That automatically earns another few points off! (-5)

And the first OW game was sacrificed for this game. Even if you had physical copy, it would just automatically boot up the second game. The first game is now completely lost! I won’t pretend OW didn’t have any issues, but at least it had its charms. And now its all gone. (-5) And Acti-Blizz just created thousands, if not millions, of disc wastes around the world. BAD Acti-Blizz, BAD! More points off with you for contributing to real-world problem! EXTRA points off, in fact! (-10)

Since the game advertised about its singleplayer campaign elements, I decided to check them out first. After all, the game has been building its world and characters with the animated shorts and comics. They had the alright idea in the first game with those operation events, and I was hoping they would expand on that. Finally, I can explore the world in-game, right?

NOPE. The campaign is not included at launch, which is pure bullshit. This is something I just don’t understand. I mean they saw what happened with Halo Infinite right? Why release the multiplayer portion first? I really wanted to get to know the world of Overwatch better, and now I have to wait probably 3+ months until I see the first bit of story content. This one earns extra points deducted from me. One for teasing me with the campaign in the first place and another for not having it in the first place (-10)

Now let’s move on to the main controversy with the game, the f2p live-service element. Let me preface by saying f2p model can work well. Games like Destiny 2, League of Legends, and Apex Legends manages keep their playerbase alive and healthy. However, it’s what’s in the game that makes players keep coming back. And just like halo infinite management, this game offers too little to justify the free price tag. And technically it’s not even free since they are gonna condition the players to pay for the cosmetic using the FOMO tactics. Because EVERYTHING that’s doesn’t affect gameplay, is locked behind paywall That’s another (-5) for me. And if you are truly new, as in someone who never played the first game, you will have contents suchs as a new hero actually locked behind the premium battle pass. So that’s another -5 for contradiction on “cosmetic items only” statement when it comes to the MTX. Also, fucking $5 for a gold doomfist skin? REALLY? (-5)

And they have the audacity to have separate currency for the league skins. Some of these league skins do look amazing, but it's also crazy you have to shill out more money to get them. Just No (-5)

Challenges can be completed to earn the currency for shop stuff, but first of all they are weekly and second they only give so little meaning you have to grind. And each of them were made to be grindy individually. To put it in the perspective, If you complete 11 weekly challenges the max you’ll earn is 60 coins. And a single legendary skin costs 1900 coins. This means you have to grind for 8 months FOR A SINGLE SKIN. FUCK THAT (-5). This is made worse when you find out premium battle pass only costs 1000 coins. You heard that right. A single legendary skin is almost double the price of a premium battle pass. (-5) Holy fucking shit, they didn’t just take a page from Halo Infinite, they wrote an entire sequel to it! All this to not point get people to buy the premium pass, but also to have them purchase the in-game currency as well (-5)

Gameplay…. Oh my god, the gameplay. As it was announced, they reduced the matches to be 5v5 instead of 6v6. While this is fine for a casual match, custom match, or even arcade, it seriously fucks up the team comp in competitive. No matter how well you think the team will be, there always will be that one extra position you wish could’ve been there. It just feels like one of those games where it was meant to be 6v6, and they are forcing two less players. So far, no one can figure out how to re-build the team around this fact (can’t blame anyone though), and I’m willing to bet it will take a long time until they do. That’s another (-5). And let’s not forget how this is gonna affect the OWL. I do not care about OWL enough to affect this review, but now each team has to figure out what to do with the extra member in the team. Do they need to force closing the contract with the extra member? Do they need to keep them as a reserve at lower pay?

Since this is a competitive multiplayer, I expected a fair amount of negativity. But dear god, the toxicity is worse than the first game. Al I did was ask if Solder 76 was good for defending, and I got a slew of slurs both in chat and on voice. Yes, I can always mute them, but that’s like plugging my ears and going “Alalalalalahaha, can’t hear you!”. It doesn’t fix the core problem. (-5)

Arcade mode feels pointless. In the first game it at least had the purpose of giving out lootboxes. Here, there are no lootboxes, so it only gives extra xp, with no rewards towards the currency. And they aren’t really that fun either. All the gamemodes feel like those experimental games that no one really wants to play (-5)

As for the heroes, they are all hit-and-miss. There are some reworks that feels great, while others feel unnecessary. Since they all seem to balance each other out, no points deducted here. Although the overall design of some heroes does look kinda bad

Maps are okay I guess. I mean there are the old maps from the first game, but not all of them have been transferred here. I wonder why? I only assume it’s either due to not really working on 5v5 setting, or they are being held hostage at the future battle pass. There are total of 25 maps, where 4 are themed-version of the original maps, 15 are the original, and only 6 are new maps. Really, this does not feel like OW2. (-5)

Graphics are fine, and that’s the problem here; It’s nearly identical to that of the first game. It tricks you into thinking there are improvements with new character designs and lighting effects, but if you take a close look you’ll realize how lazy they are in terms of graphics. Is this also because the game is f2p? Has the resources improving graphics been moved for more live service bullshit? (-5)

So yeah, -10/100. Fuck this game. Actually, don’t fuck it. It really is not worth your time nor attention. Treat it like an STD; The only one getting fucked over is you. Unless you are REALLY into competitive hero-shooter, and willing to ignore all of is problems, this game really has no redeeming values.
 
Last edited:

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,449
5,706
118
Australia
I think they are getting DDOS because other BattleNet stuff isn’t working either; my friends can’t update their BNet client because of the same thing. Also two-factor authentication is a great idea but their implementation is pants on head stupid especially since they already have an existing 2FA app for BNet itself that Overwatch could easily have been added to.

A pox upon them.
 

FakeSympathy

Elite Member
Legacy
Jun 8, 2015
3,505
3,234
118
Seattle, WA
Country
US
I think they are getting DDOS because other BattleNet stuff isn’t working either; my friends can’t update their BNet client because of the same thing. Also two-factor authentication is a great idea but their implementation is pants on head stupid especially since they already have an existing 2FA app for BNet itself that Overwatch could easily have been added to.

A pox upon them.
Like, we are supposed to trust these guys with our personal info when they weren't even prepared for a DDOS attack? Just feel like after managing multiplayer games of different scales for years, they should at least be decent at stopping these attacks
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrawlMan

meiam

Elite Member
Dec 9, 2010
3,600
1,825
118
I'm guessing they see killing OW1 as killing 2 bird with one stone, they forced everyone to OW2 and in a couple of year will release OW1 classic for more bucks.

As for toxicity, F2P game have this problem where toxicity is extreme until you play a bit, because all the toxic trash constantly get kicked and make new account so they always play at low elo, this being the release all those people (mostly tbh) are playing at the same level as everyone. If you're somehow inclined to play more, it'll get better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrawlMan

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,449
5,706
118
Australia
Like, we are supposed to trust these guys with our personal info when they weren't even prepared for a DDOS attack? Just feel like after managing multiplayer games of different scales for years, they should at least be decent at stopping these attacks
DDOS is different from penetration attacks designed to steal information. DDOS are highly visible and disruptive and usually about proving a point or registering dislike and a desire to stop a service from working.

Penetration hacking attacks tend to aim for the opposite by being invisible; causing as little disruption as possible so people don’t realise they’re happening until the deed is long done. Get in, get the data, get out.
 
Last edited:

Catfood220

Elite Member
Legacy
Dec 21, 2010
2,114
374
88
I did think about downloading Overwatch 2 as I liked Overwatch. Then I saw that it needed my phone number so I could play and I just kind of went "naaah, you're ok" and changed my mind.
 

Samtemdo8

Elite Member
Legacy
Apr 25, 2020
1,510
611
118
Country
Private
Meanwhile Wrath of the Lich King Classic server's launch went without any hitches.

Even Asmongold enjoyed the initial launch



Its like the Overwatch team is now being handled by idiot monkeys and Wrath Classic's team is composed of competent human beings
 

FakeSympathy

Elite Member
Legacy
Jun 8, 2015
3,505
3,234
118
Seattle, WA
Country
US
So the OW subreddit has re-enabled posts again (was shut down for like a day due to too many complaints on login issues). And they are absolutely tearing the game to shreds. Some of the noteworthy posts I've seen;
  • The end-game victory pose screen has been kept the same, so now it just looks like one person is missing
  • Removal of "on fire" state and after game report.
  • Ovewatch 1 physical disc now being used as a coaster or a pizza cutter
  • The fact that OW2 was in development for 3.5 years
  • Some UI elements are mis-aligned, "layered", or look low-effort
  • More bashing of the microtransactions
  • Some people Still can't get in
 

CriticalGaming

Elite Member
Legacy
Dec 28, 2017
11,253
5,691
118
So the OW subreddit has re-enabled posts again (was shut down for like a day due to too many complaints on login issues). And they are absolutely tearing the game to shreds. Some of the noteworthy posts I've seen;
  • The end-game victory pose screen has been kept the same, so now it just looks like one person is missing
  • Removal of "on fire" state and after game report.
  • Ovewatch 1 physical disc now being used as a coaster or a pizza cutter
  • The fact that OW2 was in development for 3.5 years
  • Some UI elements are mis-aligned, "layered", or look low-effort
  • More bashing of the microtransactions
  • Some people Still can't get in
Yep that checks out, and showcases the lack of talent left at Blizzard. Not to mention anyone with any talent has to make sure it's the most mundane shit put into a video game or they might offend someone for showing off a character's butt a little too hard.
 

Samtemdo8

Elite Member
Legacy
Apr 25, 2020
1,510
611
118
Country
Private
Yep that checks out, and showcases the lack of talent left at Blizzard. Not to mention anyone with any talent has to make sure it's the most mundane shit put into a video game or they might offend someone for showing off a character's butt a little too hard.
I guess they have put their "best developers" in their new mobile divisions.

It won't surprise me if Warcraft Arclight Rumble turns out to be a decent and well optimized game for mobile
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
29,499
12,265
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
Ovewatch 1 physical disc now being used as a coaster or a pizza cutter
This is exactly why digital only/online only simps can suck it. You think you have control and ownership of your copy, but it's only as long as the publisher or developed wants it to be.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: FakeSympathy

Samtemdo8

Elite Member
Legacy
Apr 25, 2020
1,510
611
118
Country
Private
This is exactly why digital only/online only simps can suck it. You think you have control and ownership of your copy, but it's only as long as the publisher or developed wants it to be.
This guy can go fuck himself for hoping games go all digital

 
  • Like
Reactions: BrawlMan

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,449
5,706
118
Australia
This is exactly why digital only/online only simps can suck it. You think you have control and ownership of your copy, but it's only as long as the publisher or developed wants it to be.
With a game like Overwatch, physical or digital is academic since it requires servers for its only play mode. All that has to happen is those servers go off and running around crowing about having a disc will do you sod all good.
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
29,499
12,265
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
With a game like Overwatch, physical or digital is academic since it requires servers for its only play mode. All that has to happen is those servers go off and running around crowing about having a disc will do you sod all good.
Hence why I have the online only in the backslash.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FakeSympathy

FakeSympathy

Elite Member
Legacy
Jun 8, 2015
3,505
3,234
118
Seattle, WA
Country
US
With a game like Overwatch, physical or digital is academic since it requires servers for its only play mode. All that has to happen is those servers go off and running around crowing about having a disc will do you sod all good.
It truly is sad that we come to this point. I mean with games like classic halo there are ways to host a LAN party even after the official servers go down.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrawlMan

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,449
5,706
118
Australia
It truly is sad that we come to this point. I mean with games like classic halo there are ways to host a LAN party even after the official servers go down.
Ah yes, dedicated servers. The wonders of a bygone age. Fuck, I remember AVP2 came with software that let you run a dedicated server so you didn’t need P2P matchmaking.

I blame XBox Live for their demise.
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
29,499
12,265
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
This guy can go fuck himself for hoping games go all digital

It's IGN, they'll say anything for the attention and try come off as profound. I didn't even know that video existed and is from 2012. The only good reviewer on the site is the fighting game guy. He's actually polite, efficient, and knows what the fuck he's talking about!