I wish I didn't love sports games like FIFA, as none of my nerdy, sports hating friends want to ever play it when they come over or online.
Also, I get REALLY easily addicted by sports games, regardless of quality I always end up sucked in. Notable examples include Speed ball for PS1 and...
Mass Effect 2 wasn't RPG -ey enough.
Resident Evil 4 had Ashley.
Half Life 2's hovercraft section was a bit crap.
Super metroid and Goldeneye have both aged really poorly.
Hogs of War for PS1... nope, I can't think of anything.