Great game. i always thought the wild west was rich pickings for shooters but have been consistently been disappointed for a number of reasons. COJ had no bullshit, it was short, fun as hell, and interesting to boot. For that reason, i'll probably play it many times, which is more than i can say for many other shooters.
Great article btw. i appreciated that you took the game seriously and gave it the praise it deserves, while pointing out that it could be even more interesting. i have to agree that the pace of the game didn't lend itself to going to find the collectables. i would often get to the end of a level and be a bit disappointed that i only picked up the obvious stuff cause i had been guns blazing for the last 20 mins. not that it really detracted from the game, just that i liked reading the info.