CardinalPiggles said:
I liked Matt Smith as the Doctor too, I just thought that the stories he was lumbered with were either over-complicated, incredibly heavy-handed or horribly internally inconsistent. And far too many of them were solved with the Doctor delivering a speech about how totes awesome humanity was. I would have loved to have seen what Russell T. Davies would have done with Matt Smith. Compare Blink, with Russell T. telling Moffatt no, and the Time of Angels, where they just completely abandoned and undermined the idea of them. Or Angels Take Manhattan where the Statue of frigging Liberty was an Angel. So not one person in New York was looking out their window? And every picture of the Statue of Liberty was an Angel? Great when restrained, has a tendency to ruin things when allowed to do what he wants. This is not to say, by a long stretch, that I don't still love the show. It's just that since Moffatt took over there's always something in each episode that jars slightly and throws it off. I guess it's unfair to compare him to Lucas, he is better than that, it's just the best example I can think of.