I have never played Madden, though that might have something to do with the fact that I live in the UK, and Fifa is the go-to sports game over here (only played Fifa 2010, as I got it for free with my replacement 360).
Never played Goat Simulator. Haven't even been tempted to try it out. It just looks like something that would be fun for a good 5 minutes.
Never played Harvest Moon. Hell, im not even sure what platform that is even on. (Note: Nintendo stuff, apparently)
I have played Mario Party, and I love that game with friends, but is a shame that I own a whole 0 Nintendo consoles. Best I can do is the Raynor Party mod for StarCraft 2.
I have played Bejeweled, because everyone in the world who has touched a platform capable of playing games has played Bejeweled or a Bejeweled-like game. Kinda fun, though I do find the match 3 game in Huniepop to be a little more fun. [small]not just because of the naked ladies, I promise[/small]
I have played Peggle, though, I never really saw the appeal of it. I hear that people go crazy for it, though.
I have honestly never actually played Farming/Truck/Train/Goat/Any simulator, ever. Well, aside from Surgeon, but that doesn't really count, right?
The Sims, oh, I remember you. Haven't touched 4, but I did play Sims 1 and the Sims 2(Xbox) pretty extensively. I did enjoy The Sims, but damn, do they go crazy for expansion packs. I mean, daaaaaaamn.