Liking the Wrong Thing on Facebook Can Get You Fired

WMDogma

New member
Jul 28, 2009
1,374
0
0
Liking the Wrong Thing on Facebook Can Get You Fired

[img_inline src="http://cdn.themis-media.com/media/global/images/library/deriv/54/54743.jpg"]
A judge in Virginia makes using social media a little more complicated.

You know that awkward moment on Facebook where you find out your boss is a huge fan of the Yankees, and you just clicked the "Like" button on the Red Sox page? Those moments might get a little more tense, as a recent case involving a sheriff who fired employees over supposedly liking an opponent's Facebook page ended with a federal judge ruling that liking a Facebook page doesn't qualify for First Amendment protection.

The story goes like this: During the 2009 elections, Sheriff B.J. Roberts of Hampton, Virginia supposedly learned that a handful of his employees were supporting one of his opponents, Jim Adams, by clicking the "like" button on Adam's Facebook page as well as attending a barbeque fundraiser. In response, Roberts called a department meeting, advising the staff to get on the "long train" with him rather than give their support to someone else, and then after winning re-election, Roberts canned several employees, including those who supported Adams.

The workers believed that their Facebook "Like" was the reason behind why they got axed, and sued Roberts for violating their First Amendment Rights under the not-so-unreasonable belief that a Facebook "Like" is protected by free speech and they were unlawfully terminated. Unfortunately, U.S. District Judge Raymond Jackson disagreed, and stated that while Facebook Posts could be considered protected speech, the simple act of "liking" a page isn't enough to count since you don't actually make any written statements when you do so.

"Simply liking a Facebook page is insufficient," Judge Jackson said in his ruling. "It is not the kind of substantive statement that has previously warranted constitutional protection. "

So what does this all mean? Well, that's what legal scholars across the country are trying to figure out while the dismissed workers file an appeal. In the meanwhile though, you might want to be a little more conscious about what you do on Facebook until it all gets settled. Or just be like me, and stick to playing games.

Source: io9 [http://www.courthousenews.com/2012/05/02/46183.htm]

Permalink
 

Fappy

\[T]/
Jan 4, 2010
12,010
0
41
Country
United States
That is absolute bullshit. Freedom of Speech protects far more than "written statements". If motorcyclists can make the case for not wearing a helmet = freedom of expression than I have no idea why expressing that you agree with something, even if it is as simple as a Facebook "like", can't also share the same protection. Its hilarious how hypocritical and stupid our system really is.
 

Sis

New member
Apr 2, 2012
122
0
0
And that is why you never make a facebook using your real name.
 

OniaPL

New member
Nov 9, 2010
1,057
0
0
Sis said:
And that is why you never make a facebook using your real name.
And that is why you don't use facebook at all.

Seriously, there has never been anything as useless as Facebook.
 

Vault Citizen

New member
May 8, 2008
1,703
0
0
I find facebook useful for chatting with some friends and as a place to pool news updates that I'm interested in but if I ever getc a job at a place that interested in my facebook page I'm just going to delete the thing. They can't use something against me that isn't there.
 

Frostbite3789

New member
Jul 12, 2010
1,778
0
0
OniaPL said:
Sis said:
And that is why you never make a facebook using your real name.
And that is why you don't use facebook at all.

Seriously, there has never been anything as useless as Facebook.
Yeah, my form of social networking (a video game forum) is better than yours!
 

samsonguy920

New member
Mar 24, 2009
2,921
0
0
Would you expect a Senator or Representative to hang onto staff who give a Facebook like to their political opponents? No.
This was a pure sign of disrespect for the person they were working for and zero support. Sheriff BJ Roberts has to expect full support from his deputies when things hit the fan, and this juvenile bit on Facebook showed they have zero support for the guy. It isn't just about bruised feelings. The Sheriff's Department is law enforcement, responsible for the same risks the Police go through. If you don't have strong support from your deputies or officers, then you are liable to be left out in the cold and killed during any action.
As far as I am concerned, those people would have been better off quitting their jobs, giving their vote to the opposing guy, and then see if he wins and hires them back into the department. Otherwise they basically just stabbed their boss in the back.
 

OniaPL

New member
Nov 9, 2010
1,057
0
0
Frostbite3789 said:
OniaPL said:
Sis said:
And that is why you never make a facebook using your real name.
And that is why you don't use facebook at all.

Seriously, there has never been anything as useless as Facebook.
Yeah, my form of social networking (a video game forum) is better than yours!
I don't understand why you would use a video game forum either.
Do people really need some sort of internet service that provides "social networking"?
I suppose I'll just never get it. For all I care you can have your bookfaces and tweeters and whatever, but don't push it on me. I'm sick of all the websites wanting me to register or login with a facebook account >.>
 

Richardplex

New member
Jun 22, 2011
1,731
0
0
OniaPL said:
Sis said:
And that is why you never make a facebook using your real name.
And that is why you don't use facebook at all.

Seriously, there has never been anything as useless as Facebook.
It's not like tons of people use it to talk and stay in contact with people whom otherwise they may of never spoken to again. Nope, definitely the most useless thing ever conceived.
 

OniaPL

New member
Nov 9, 2010
1,057
0
0
Richardplex said:
OniaPL said:
Sis said:
And that is why you never make a facebook using your real name.
And that is why you don't use facebook at all.

Seriously, there has never been anything as useless as Facebook.
It's not like tons of people use it to talk and stay in contact with people whom otherwise they may of never spoken to again. Nope, definitely the most useless thing ever conceived.
But if Facebook is the only means for you to have contact with the person, what's the point? She/he is nothing more than a random acquintance that you don't give a flying fuck about. If the person would mean something to you, surely you would find another way than Facebook, or at least meet at some point.
 

Qitz

New member
Mar 6, 2011
1,276
0
0
Well, shoulda set their shit to Private then.

Still pretty dumb though, but then I don't know if liking something on Facebook does constitute the Right to Free Speech verbatim but wouldn't it consist of stating an opinion which firing someone over is usually frowned upon?
 

Lunar Templar

New member
Sep 20, 2009
8,225
0
0
wow ...

just wow

that's some bull shit right there, some one should not be fired for 'liking' something on face book, or anywhere really, i hope the people fired get their apple and the guy that fired them gets canned for being a childish prick
 

Richardplex

New member
Jun 22, 2011
1,731
0
0
OniaPL said:
Richardplex said:
OniaPL said:
Sis said:
And that is why you never make a facebook using your real name.
And that is why you don't use facebook at all.

Seriously, there has never been anything as useless as Facebook.
It's not like tons of people use it to talk and stay in contact with people whom otherwise they may of never spoken to again. Nope, definitely the most useless thing ever conceived.
But if Facebook is the only means for you to have contact with the person, what's the point? She/he is nothing more than a random acquintance that you don't give a flying fuck about. If the person would mean something to you, surely you would find another way than Facebook, or at least meet at some point.
So instead of one perfectly functional way of keeping in contact, I'm supposed to use another equally functional way of doing so because the first way is somehow? I have friends I keep in contact only through steam, same argument; do I suddenly not give a flying fuck about them, despite the fact that steam is a worse way of keeping in contact if you don't play games with them? And how exactly am I supposed to meet at some point with someone whom I can't contact? I can use FB to contact someone arranging to meet them for example. It also lets everyone at my uni doing the same degree keep in contact, discuss and help each other, et cetera.

Your argument is incredibly arbitrary, and amounts to "FB is terrible, ergo every friend you have on FB isn't a real friend". This may apply to people who have 960 friends, but for a lot of people it's incredibly helpful.
 

OniaPL

New member
Nov 9, 2010
1,057
0
0
Richardplex said:
Use facebook if that's what you want, I just fail to see how it would be the only way to contact the person or how some people can't seem to keep track of their friends without it.

I just can't see the value of the service from my perspective, and my annoyance towards it comes from how it's everywhere nowadays.
 

Fr]anc[is

New member
May 13, 2010
1,893
0
0
Don't use your real name, don't let your boss see or access your profile, and don't 'like' random shit because nobody gives a fuck what you thumbs up. Simple.
 

dagens24

New member
Mar 20, 2004
879
0
0
The shitty thing is that stuff like this ruins things for the rest of the U.S.; it makes the entire country look like a big joke to outsiders.
 

Richardplex

New member
Jun 22, 2011
1,731
0
0
OniaPL said:
Richardplex said:
Use facebook if that's what you want, I just fail to see how it would be the only way to contact the person or how some people can't seem to keep track of their friends without it.

I just can't see the value of the service from my perspective, and my annoyance towards it comes from how it's everywhere nowadays.
Well, if I have someone on FB, why use another system? Better to have everyone on FB than everyone through 5 different ways of communication. It's a convenient service that a lot of people use, making it an incredibly convenient way of staying in contact. I for example have no use for my phone; I'm either at my computer, doing exercise, or at a uni lecture, thus there is no situation where I'd pick the thing up. I'm not trying to make you use it; if you can keep in contact with everyone you want to without it, more power to you. Just that facebook is far from useless.

The fact that you can like everything under the sun outside of FB can get annoying though, and it is rather worthless.