Kameburger said:
how F-ing cool would it be to see, Superman and Dooms day slug it out for a 90 minutes, just destroying all of earth as collateral damage.
That's exactly what we got with him vs Zod. Personally, that fight was boring as hell. There were no personal stakes in it. I don't know how to describe it, but for all their building leveling, there was never a sign that either of them was in danger, taking any damage, or even fatiguing. It wasn't some epic clash between 2 titans. It was guys running around with sledge hammers breaking things. I hate drawing the "marvel does it better" comparison, but I rewatched the original spiderman, and the final fight between he and goblin was pretty good. We not only saw spiderman taking a beating, but we saw him being beaten, and the toll it was taking on him. We saw his costume being damaged, him being fatigued, and near the point of utter defeat. It wasn't until Goblin threatened Mary Jane that we saw Parker "dig deep," and personally, I was thinking "Aw yeah! Now his actions carry weight."
It's because we saw the ass whipping that he had taken before, that him suddenly getting a second wind was so exciting. Superman vs Zod was:
- I just knocked you through a building.
- Okay, now I'll knock you through a building.
- Well played. Now I'll drag you face first down a building.
- Excellent. Now I'll spin you around by your cape and slam you into the ground.
- Cool. Should we take this fight into outer space and destroy a satellite?
- Sounds like fun. Meet you there.
We finally ended up to the place the Superman v Zod ended, and if you looked at them, there is no way in hell you would think "man! those 2 just destroyed a city throwing each other through buildings." As far as you knew, their fight must have just been starting because they bought looked "fresh," not a hair out of place, or even a piece of debris on their costume. To me, that is not an exciting fight. And watching Superman do the same thing all over with Doomsday sounds terribly boring.
Also on the Marvel front, we saw Captain America getting worn down in the fight with the aliens. We saw Loki stab Thor, and then later when Thor assembled with the others, we saw him clutching at his side. We see Iron Man's armor taking damage, and him struggling when overwhelmed. In those cases you feel as though there is something at stake. There is tension. Never once in Man of Steel did I feel as though "Oh man! Zod is really doing a number on him. I wonder what he'll have to do in order to survive this." It was like a war of attrition, where each of them had infinite lives.