What does this even mean? I have no idea what "calling someone out" for owning a cd of source code entails.ffronw said:and others called him out for owning it.
I'm guessing people suspected he'd acquired it by dubious means. How do you just get hold of something like that, anyway?Jadak said:What does this even mean? I have no idea what "calling someone out" for owning a cd of source code entails.ffronw said:and others called him out for owning it.
Most likely "you stole that". Because shoot first and ask questions later.Jadak said:What does this even mean? I have no idea what "calling someone out" for owning a cd of source code entails.ffronw said:and others called him out for owning it.
Honestly, I'm way more interested in the story of how it got to him than anything else. How did it get out of Blizzard's possession in the first place? Disgruntled employee? Corporate espionage? Did someone leave it on a bus? What did the person who had it before do with it? And why put it in some grab bag of Blizzard stuff they sold on eBay?Thaluikhain said:I'm guessing people suspected he'd acquired it by dubious means. How do you just get hold of something like that, anyway?Jadak said:What does this even mean? I have no idea what "calling someone out" for owning a cd of source code entails.ffronw said:and others called him out for owning it.
Strictly speaking, no. This is an odd case where the actual value of the disk is hard to define in any objective sense. There's no par value or sales price for it, and while aficionados might have paid a very pretty penny for it, let's be honest aficionados are almost defined by the fact that they're willing to pay well over fair price for things related to the subject they're passionate about. Consequentially we're limited to the near platitude that the fair price of the disk is what the seller is willing to part with it for and the buyer is willing to pay for it.MC1980 said:You get shortchanged with a pile of crap they had leftover in storage, an oversized coupon and get to waste a couple of days on a mediocre event? Doesn't feel like he got paid what he was worth at all.Killerologist said:See? Look what happens to honest/nice people Ethics is a good thing, despite what the Kardashians say....
For a single item, aficionados define the fair market price for an item. The one who is willing to pay the most is the one who gets it: that's fair.Asita said:Strictly speaking, no. This is an odd case where the actual value of the disk is hard to define in any objective sense. There's no par value or sales price for it, and while aficionados might have paid a very pretty penny for it, let's be honest aficionados are almost defined by the fact that they're willing to pay well over fair price for things related to the subject they're passionate about.
I would say too that late 90s Blizzard more than likely didn't keep track of IP material nearly as well or as vehemently as today's Blizz. Probably because it was a different industry. So stuff like this showing up in a totally innocent nature is highly likely, even if said company is still in existence.MC1980 said:Now you might think that that sequence of events is farfetched. You'd be right somewhat, but that doesn't change the fact that similar sequence of events have happened several times already. Most famously, the discovery of the Nintendo Playstation prototype, which a guy got alongside a box of porcelain plates he took from his office that was closing down. There's quite the precedent for such happenstance.
I suppose that is accurate to the extent that it follows the aforementioned rule. My intended point was that by non-aficionado standards, aficionados are wont to overpay. It's more or less auction philosophy. Highest bid technically sets the fair value, but the price they set is usually above what most others would be willing to pay for it.Seanchaidh said:For a single item, aficionados define the fair market price for an item. The one who is willing to pay the most is the one who gets it: that's fair.Asita said:Strictly speaking, no. This is an odd case where the actual value of the disk is hard to define in any objective sense. There's no par value or sales price for it, and while aficionados might have paid a very pretty penny for it, let's be honest aficionados are almost defined by the fact that they're willing to pay well over fair price for things related to the subject they're passionate about.
Worth is a relative term.MC1980 said:You get shortchanged with a pile of crap they had leftover in storage, an oversized coupon and get to waste a couple of days on a mediocre event? Doesn't feel like he got paid what he was worth at all.