OK, lets do this thing:
Forbidden Desert: Co-ops generally suck, and Forbidden Island is the worst example of the worst kind. A sequel to that crap? No thanks
Suburbia: Cool stuff. Played it a couple of times, it's a fun hex-buying game with a good chunk of strategy and table-talk to it.
Pathfinder: No interest in RPGs, the group I've seen play it....I generally want to avoid them. So that's a negative vote for just the people who I see play it.
Hanabi: Skipping here since I haven't played the others in the middle. Fun game, far too easy to accidentally cheat. Been played to death by most people I know, myself included. Don't think it's going to age well at all.
This was a weird year of board gaming for me. Pretty much everything new I played was actually a year or 2 old, and I just discovered it now. I'll have to check out the games I didn't really recognize on there, see how they play.