Siren was released only for PS3 and Amnesia only for PC. Even though I always imagine the PC's audience to be the biggest there is, this narrows it down for people who could play these two today.
Where is any Silent Hill up to and including 4?
Also, maybe this is because I first played it when I was 12 and am therefore biased, but I always was creeped out by Resident Evil 3 the most in comparison to its other entries. Am I alone with this?
Although I've also played Resident Evil when I was 9 or something. At the same age, I also watched (a German, therefore censored free TV version of) Nightmare on Elmstreet. A part where Freddy's tongue extended towards a woman through I think a hatch. Laughed my ass off. And Halloween. And Hellraiser. Hellraiser 1 even before, but that gave me nightmares until I hit puberty.
But the only game that really gave me nightmares (beginning at the age of around 4) was Friday, the 13th on the C64. These deaths. That screen. PTSD for life.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VPx2OTcatJ8