AboveUp Reviews: Assassin's Creed Brotherhood

AboveUp

New member
May 21, 2008
1,382
0
0

At this point, I'm sure most of you are aware of my feelings towards the Assassin's Creed series. The first game was moderately entertaining, but mostly so because of the story rather than the gameplay. The second one improved in that field, and gave us one of the most fully realized gaming character in the gaming world with Ezio Auditore. How does Brotherhood fare up to the amazing game that was Brotherhood? We've still got our Animus, so we'll just have to sync in and discover that right now.

Assassin's Creed Brotherhood isn't an Assassin's Creed 3 kind of game. Right from the start, it's pretty obvious that we're dealing with Assassin's Creed 2.5, rather than a full-fledged sequel. considering the caliber of the second Creed title, this doesn't immediately mean that it's a rehash, or just a crappy more of the same kind of game. Some serious attempts at improving the formula have been made, even if a lot of the changes amounted to some small tweaking and simple fine-tuning.

Just like Assassin's Creed 2, Brotherhood picks up at the precise point where the last game left off. If this is going to be a trend in the series, then I highly approve of it. No time-skips, just one whole narrative only broken up by how the game plays itself. Well, that and the location that you'll be jumping into the Animus from.


Screenshots don't do it justice, but the portrayal of Rome is simply beautiful.

This time we follow Desmond as he relives Ezio's fights against the Borgia in Rome. Yes, there's only one city this time around, but I'm not complaining. Rome is huge, and very well realized. Because of the attention to detail and the sheer size of the place, free-running, scaling buildings, rooftopping, and just generally messing around is like playing a dream in Brotherhood. I wouldn't mind if the rest of the Assassin's Creed titles would focus on one city instead of giving us several. Rome felt like it came alive, and I really loved the game for this reason alone.

Following Ezio's fight against the Borgias, it's not too surprising that the scope of Assassin's Creed Brotherhood is much smaller, and that we see him change a lot less than we did in the previous title. Not too shocking a thing, considering the fact that Ezio aged 22 years in Assassin's Creed 2. It'd be hard to pull off the same thing twice with the same character. Still, his journey remains an interesting one, and it's very exciting to see Ezio taking on Cesare Borgia from 1499 to 1507.


Lust for power, corruption of faith, and incest. Nothing makes for a better story.

The fighting system in the game has been tweaked even further than the second instalment, and once again, they managed to improve it. One of the biggest changes is that after a single kill, every consecutive hit is an instant kill. It both fails and succeeds at what it was made to do. The idea behind it was that it'd stop people from waiting for chances to do a counter move and instead move forward and attack immediately. That way, fights would have a much higher pace than in the previous titles. Instead, it just ensures you block and wait for a chance to counter so you can get straight to the instant kills. Despite that, it still speeds up fighting and makes it much more enjoyable. It also makes it even easier than it was before, but I really did't think that was much of a problem.

Having secondary goals while playing through memories is another minor change added within the game. Simply completing a memory no longer lets you fully sync them. Instead the game will give you an extra goal to complete in every mission before giving you a 100% synchronization rate. Most of the secondary goals are easy, like playing through a memory without losing too much health, only killing your target and nobody else, or not being detected during the entire memory. Personally I found the harder goals the ones where you were supposed to play through the memory within a time limit. To make matters worse, you would have to do this during the large Prince of Persia-style tomb levels. As glad as I am that these have returned, I wasn't too fond of their secondary missions.



Ezio's brought some friends this time.

If you're a completionist, you might like to know that the search for flags has been made slightly easier by Art vendors selling maps with the locations of flags and feather this time around. Yes, flags and feather collectables are still around. I doubt they'll ever get rid of them. Since there are maps for them this time around, I didn't mind collecting them half as much as I did during the first and second game. Although some of the flags are in areas only accessible during certain memories, and they're not marked on the map. If you're going to let us have maps with locations, give us all of the locations. This just felt frustrating.

Assassin's Creed Brotherhood is just about everything you'd expect from an Assassin's Creed 2.5. It's nothing new. Nothing groundbreaking. And yes, it's more of the same. But with that good a game as its base, that is not a bad thing at all.

Well, except the ending. Again.

At this point, I think I'll just play the next Assassin's Creed game up until the final mission and then just turn it off.


Previous reviews
Super Punch-Out (SNES) [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.190783-AboveUp-reviews-Super-Punch-Out]
The Dishwasher Dead Samurai (XBLA) [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.132533-AboveUp-reviews-The-Dishwasher-Dead-Samurai]
Bowser's Inside Story (NDS) [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.197971-AboveUp-reviews-Mario-Luigi-Bowsers-Inside-Story]
The A-Team movie [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.203780-AboveUp-reviews-The-A-Team-movie]
Rune Factory 1 (NDS) [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.283511-AboveUp-Reviews-Rune-Factory-1]
Desktop Dungeons (Freeware, PC/Mac) [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.284918-AboveUp-Reviews-Desktop-Dungeons-Freeware-PC-Mac]
Assassin's Creed 2 (360 version) [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.302445-AboveUp-Reviews-Assassins-Creed-2]
Dragon Age 2 (360 version) [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.308028-AboveUp-Reviews-Dragon-Age-2]

Overviews
This Reminds Me of a Puzzle - Professor Layton [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.252585-A-view-from-Above-This-Reminds-Me-of-a-Puzzle-A-Professor-Layton-Overview]

Shiny link to other good stuff:
Shiny Good Stuff [http://remyvanruiten.com/]
 

AboveUp

New member
May 21, 2008
1,382
0
0
artanis_neravar said:
AboveUp said:
So you didn't like the ending?
Every ending so far has made me cringe. Ubisoft need to find a balance in the satisfation of the ending event, and pulling players in with a cliffhanger. Mass Effect 2 got it right, Assassin's Creed 2 and Brotherhood not so much.

Although Brotherhood's ending was slightly better than Assassin Creed 2's ending, especially in terms of the ending within the Animus, the problems outside of of it, with the very Metal Gear Solid-esque addition during the credits sequence... No. They really need to stop doing this.
 

NinjaDeathSlap

Leaf on the wind
Feb 20, 2011
4,474
0
0
artanis_neravar said:
AboveUp said:
So you didn't like the ending?
Yeah, I thought the Brotherhood ending was great. Maybe he's getting a little annoyed about how they keep teasing us with cryptic messages from 'the ones who came before' but never actually give us any solid answers. That's supposed to change in Revelations though.
 

NinjaDeathSlap

Leaf on the wind
Feb 20, 2011
4,474
0
0
AboveUp said:
artanis_neravar said:
AboveUp said:
So you didn't like the ending?
Every ending so far has made me cringe. BioWare need to find a balance in the satisfation of the ending event, and pulling players in with a cliffhanger. Mass Effect 2 got it right, Assassin's Creed 2 and Brotherhood not so much.

Although Brotherhood's ending was slightly better than Assassin Creed 2's ending, especially in terms of the ending within the Animus, the problems outside of of it, with the very Metal Gear Solid-esque addition during the credits sequence... No. They really need to stop doing this.
Um, Assassin's Creed is made by Ubisoft. Bioware have nothing to do with it.
 

artanis_neravar

New member
Apr 18, 2011
2,560
0
0
AboveUp said:
artanis_neravar said:
AboveUp said:
So you didn't like the ending?
Every ending so far has made me cringe. BioWare need to find a balance in the satisfation of the ending event, and pulling players in with a cliffhanger. Mass Effect 2 got it right, Assassin's Creed 2 and Brotherhood not so much.

Although Brotherhood's ending was slightly better than Assassin Creed 2's ending, especially in terms of the ending within the Animus, the problems outside of of it, with the very Metal Gear Solid-esque addition during the credits sequence... No. They really need to stop doing this.
um....Assassins Creed isn't Bioware, it's Ubisoft. Also you can't really start the next game on a cliff hanger, and if you try to end the game after the cliff hanger it's going to leave the player with even more of an unfinished feeling. (not trying to argue, just pointing out my thoughts on the subject.)
 

AboveUp

New member
May 21, 2008
1,382
0
0
NinjaDeathSlap said:
AboveUp said:
artanis_neravar said:
AboveUp said:
So you didn't like the ending?
Every ending so far has made me cringe. BioWare need to find a balance in the satisfation of the ending event, and pulling players in with a cliffhanger. Mass Effect 2 got it right, Assassin's Creed 2 and Brotherhood not so much.

Although Brotherhood's ending was slightly better than Assassin Creed 2's ending, especially in terms of the ending within the Animus, the problems outside of of it, with the very Metal Gear Solid-esque addition during the credits sequence... No. They really need to stop doing this.
Um, Assassin's Creed is made by Ubisoft. Bioware have nothing to do with it.
Crap, you're right, I must've had BioWare in my mind after responding to a previous comment on my Dragon Age 2 review. Which also talked of flaws in story telling. At at least AC:B is nowhere near as flawed. Stupid of me, heading to fix that now.
 

AboveUp

New member
May 21, 2008
1,382
0
0
NinjaDeathSlap said:
artanis_neravar said:
AboveUp said:
So you didn't like the ending?
Yeah, I thought the Brotherhood ending was great. Maybe he's getting a little annoyed about how they keep teasing us with cryptic messages from 'the ones who came before' but never actually give us any solid answers. That's supposed to change in Revelations though.
It's more the massively awkward digital and futuristic representation of God and religion at the end of every Assassins Creed title that I have a problem with. It feels incredibly out of place in every game they've used it in.
 

Mr. 47

New member
May 25, 2011
435
0
0
I liked it just because it gave me a 'win game now' button in the crossbow. Everything else was Assassin Creed 2 with a puffier suit and a few ninjas at your command. I didn't like Rome as the cities in AE 2. To much countryside and fapping about on a horse.