BioWare: Gamers Prefer a Manly Shepard

Therumancer

Citation Needed
Nov 28, 2007
9,909
0
0
My main Shepard I converted from ME 1 was a female character, I've also played a dude a few times. So far I've only beaten the second game once (beat the first one multiple times though) partially because it's so shooter-centric and that isn't quite my thing.

I played Infiltrator, and my playthrough was pretty much Paragon, including freeing Grunt, but having never read any of the novels it struck me as being foolish to destroy the captured Reaper Tech outright, especially seeing as the mind controlling aspects of the thing are known at this point and can probably be dealt with.

My thoughts on the subject are that in war you use whatever you have. What's more since The Reapers guided technological development in a certain direction to make their genocide cycle easier to control, pulling out things they couldn't have accounted for like using their own weapons and tech against them is probably a good idea. The destruction of Sovreign and the failure of The Collectors would not logically be anything they could have predicted. Such are my thoughts. If we're *SUPPOSED* to know more about what is going on, then they shouldn't put it in a novel exclusively, and put it in the game instead.

I do get the whole Paragon/Renegade points thing, and how the creators are defining certain actions. I kind of disagreed with them as to what desician should be what given what you know at the time. Besides, I can swallow the Renegade points because just because something might be immoral in the short term doesn't mean it's the wrong move overall.

Occasionally Bioware agrees with me here, in "Dragon Age: Origins" the more evil seeming of the dwarf lords (the prince) in Orzimmar is actually the better choice as a ruler in the long run and brings success and prosperity, where under the leadership of the more good seeming leader things don't exactly turn out well for them. Of course in that case both of them were corrupt jerks in their own way. Typically you know more about their overall moral outlook if you played the Dwarf origins.
 

kahlzun

New member
Sep 9, 2009
492
0
0
I upgraded all my ship except for one of the useless things, I forget what it was.
I rolled a fem-shep in ME1, and imported it into ME2. Ironically, she ended up looking a lot like Julia Gillard, which makes the game mildly disturbing to play now.

My favourite squaddies in ME1 were Wrex and Garrus.
My favourtie squaddies in ME2 were Legion and Grunt.

All my crew died, but all my squaddies lived.
Illusive man is not the happy.

My love interest was Liara in ME1,
and i tried to keep that one alive in ME2, but was somewhat unrequited, even with LotSB.
 

Dr. Paine

New member
Oct 26, 2009
1,134
0
0
Mimsofthedawg said:
unoleian said:
I prefer Hale's voice acting. And I'm not saying that to be different. I truly do. It feels....weird playing male Shepard now. It's just not the same :-/

Fully upgraded the ship, lost that amazing Professor on my first finish. Second finish cost me Tali.

I just can't seem to get everyone out alive. I'm still working on that one.
I'm gonna be getting Mass Effect 2 for the PS3 when it comes out, but I have one "major" question. Normally I try to "create myself"; ie - make a character that I think would reflect me if I lived in that situation (and in effect, my actions in game reflect my actions I think I'd take if I was put in that situation). However, as a guy, that normally means I play exclusively as a guy. However, with ME, is there a significant difference when playing as a girl? If so, what is that difference and, besides the voice acting, do you have a preference (and why)?
Romance options and some slight dialogue shifts (the only instance I can think of is in Omega, when you're going to find Archangel, a batarian mentions 'stripper's quarters are in the back', and triggers a very entertaining Renegade interrupt, but only if you're Femshep), but in terms of combat/everything else, there is absolutely no difference.

Superior voice acting aside, I just like playing as a girl more. No issue with playing as a guy, but if I've got the choice...
 

RatRace123

Elite Member
Dec 1, 2009
6,651
0
41
I've been reading a few of these and I think it's cool to see people giving their Shepards backstories and developing their personalities outside of the game, now I feel a bit less like a nerd for doing it too.
I picked the default earthborn/sole survivor, soldier male Shepard, I even kept the name John.
I know it seems like I sort of copped out, but I tried to think how he would act, or what I thought was most dramatic. I also thought of the sole survivor aspect, especially in that one sidequest where you meet up with Tombs.
I had my Shepard use his Spectre status to kill the scientist, denying himself closure on the whole ordeal, but keeping Tombs alive and helping him. I didn't forget that Cerberus was heavily involved in the Thresher Maw attack either, so in the sequel my Shepard never trusted Cerberus or The Illusive Man. Very very satisfying telling him to fuck off at the end.
I'm kind of interested to see if they'll ever give you closure for your origin, probably not since it's extremely minor, but I denied my Shepard closure in Mass Effect 1; I want to see if he'll ever get it. Tombs did say that he would kill me if he saw me, so maybe he'll try to make good on that promise in 3.
 

teutonicman

New member
Mar 30, 2009
2,565
0
0
The only ship upgrades I made sure I had were the ones necessary for crew survival(shields, armour, and thanix cannons). OH! increased planet scanning. That was usually the first upgrade, even before weapons and what not.
 

mjc0961

YOU'RE a pie chart.
Nov 30, 2009
3,847
0
0
Andy Chalk said:
As for me, I fully upgraded my ship, the whole crew loved me (even the surly one in the basement), we all came out of the Big Thrilla in one piece and let's just say I'm probably not on the Illusive Man's Christmas card list anymore. How did you do?
For my main playthrough, pretty much exactly the same as you did.

Also it still astounds me how many people say they prefer female Shepard because of the voice acting. I have played male Shepard and I have played female Shepard, and I have to say that Jennifer Hale sounds bored as fuck throughout the entirety of both ME1 and ME2. It's a shame really, because I know she can do better than that (Metal Gear Solid 4 for example). Give me a male Shepard voiced by Mark Meer to play as any day, at least he sounds like he wants to be there.
 

AstylahAthrys

New member
Apr 7, 2010
1,317
0
0
Personally, I hate the male Shepard compared to the female one. I can't stand the male one's voice and I can't even play as him. Ugh.
 

Dr. Paine

New member
Oct 26, 2009
1,134
0
0
mjc0961 said:
Andy Chalk said:
As for me, I fully upgraded my ship, the whole crew loved me (even the surly one in the basement), we all came out of the Big Thrilla in one piece and let's just say I'm probably not on the Illusive Man's Christmas card list anymore. How did you do?
For my main playthrough, pretty much exactly the same as you did.

Also it still astounds me how many people say they prefer female Shepard because of the voice acting. I have played male Shepard and I have played female Shepard, and I have to say that Jennifer Hale sounds bored as fuck throughout the entirety of both ME1 and ME2. It's a shame really, because I know she can do better than that (Metal Gear Solid 4 for example). Give me a male Shepard voiced by Mark Meer to play as any day, at least he sounds like he wants to be there.
See, I've found male Shep to have a very bored sounding voice, which is part of the reason I might never do/will take forever in doing a male run.
 

loc978

New member
Sep 18, 2010
4,900
0
0
FemShep all the way.

and... on the only playthrough I've ever completed, I fully upgraded my ship and everyone survived the suicide mission... which wasn't all that hard, really. Just a simple matter of knowing what skills fit what tasks... and I made the Paragon choice at the end.
 

Jodan

New member
Mar 18, 2009
379
0
0
i chose the female sheppard because i didnt want to look at a mans bum for 60 hours
plus femshep was hot and had very nice voice acting
 

Addendum_Forthcoming

Queen of the Edit
Feb 4, 2009
3,647
0
0
I think of that 83% of players a large number of them looked at the options and just said 'meh' ... having played both games with their various endings and variable accoutrement I can safely say Hale's voice is perfect for a commander Shepherd.

It's everything you'd expect a officer's voice to be. Clear, concise, right tone and pitch so it carries yet most importantly it inspires calm and control.

After having played both I won't touch a Male shepherd character in ME3 <.<
 

Brutal Peanut

This is so freakin aweso-BLARGH!
Oct 15, 2010
1,770
0
0
badgersprite said:
Distorted Stu said:
I prefered the female character, if you ask me the voice acting was soooo much better. She just looked ugly as fuck.. (plays a great ***** themed character though)
Huh. I made mine pretty hot, actually. Thank you, character customisation. ^ ^
Agreed. I really spent time on my female shepard, and even my husband said,
"Wooo, look at that. Will you make my female character? I wouldn't mind looking at that the entire time." lol

The female character creator options are 10x's better in Mass Effect, then the male options. Though I'm picky and hardly settle for what I am given, if I am allowed a great character creator! =D
 

FollowUp

New member
Mar 25, 2010
179
0
0
First time I played through I was a middle of the road, male Shepard, because I don't cross generds when I play games. But I lost Archangel, Jack, Samara, and Thane. That made me sad.
 

soren7550

Overly Proud New Yorker
Dec 18, 2008
5,477
0
0
Every playthrough has gone like this:
Played as an imported FemShep, was almost 100% Paragon, fully upgraded the ship (save for the scar remover thing) and most everything else, everyone was loyal, stayed loyal to Kai-Kai, and I never lost a squadmate. Ship crew, not so much. (only lost them the first playthrough. Every playthrough after that I saved 'em all)

Also destroyed the Collector base. One is because Cerberus & TIM can go suck it, and two is because I know that should TIM get his hands on the base, horrible things will happen.
 

McNinja

New member
Sep 21, 2008
1,510
0
0
unoleian said:
I prefer Hale's voice acting. And I'm not saying that to be different. I truly do. It feels....weird playing male Shepard now. It's just not the same :-/

Fully upgraded the ship, lost that amazing Professor on my first finish. Second finish cost me Tali.

I just can't seem to get everyone out alive. I'm still working on that one.
Protip: Mordin on the escort. Tali on the pipe.

After my third playthrough, I was able to get all of the upgrades and all of my teammates alive after the mission where the stuff happens at the end.

In other news: ten percent of mass Effect 2 players are retarded for leaving the Krogan.
 

Dr. Paine

New member
Oct 26, 2009
1,134
0
0
Father Time said:
Wasn't Shepard in the first game a male? (hasn't played Mass Effect).

If that's the case then I'm not surprised, if I played the first game I would've made him a male in the second game for the sake of continuity.
No. Canonically, there is no real set gender for Shepard, but the default male is what's used on box art/promotion. In both games, you can play as male or female.
 

FollowUp

New member
Mar 25, 2010
179
0
0
Chatney said:
Outrageous and most preposterous. Shepard is a woman, end of story. Come on. Men are boring, inferior and would most certainly never ever be responsible for saving the galaxy.
What made you so angry? The point of character customization is there IS no canon, it's all based on your own preference and your own experience.

"Men are boring and inferior." Sheesh.
 

_Cake_

New member
Apr 5, 2009
921
0
0
I haven't ever played a male Shepard(lady Shepard was manly enough ;p), never played a soldier, always completely upgraded my ship, didn't lose a crew member (not even that chick who just takes your messages and stuff)... but "Archangel" was my favorite crew member. You got me there.
 

Branches

A Flawed Logical Conundrum
Oct 30, 2008
130
0
0
yes. I like Man shepard. However, I also perfer a better voice actor as Shepard, because the one whos him now has very few emotive qualities other than rage and sarcasm.