Coming Up With Topic Titles is Hard: Saya No Uta

Hurray Forums

New member
Jun 4, 2008
397
0
0
[HEADING=1]
Saya No Uta​
[/HEADING]



So I felt like doing a review but I'm too lazy to review Ever17 at the moment so you get this instead. Trying to review that without spoiling anything is the equivalent of trying to do math without using any numbers. This is a lot easier to review since it can be summarized in one picture, and the game is even nice enough to include that picture for me(it's the only nice thing it ever did).

Wait a second, if babies come from having sex, and my parents had me that means...Oh god...

There ya go. Review over. If you want your face to look like that then get this game right now.
Or continue reading. Ha ha ha, I already insulted my review so if you insult it again it wouldn't be near as funny. Take that would be trolls!(and people with good taste in reviews)
[HEADING=2]Story[/HEADING]

Saya No Uta is a game about a guy named Fumonori with the second worst medical condition in the history of anything ever after Naoto's little "monsters from another dimension keep ripping their way out of my skull" problem in FLCL. Everything he sees, touches, hears, smell, or tastes is horrifying. People are oozing, abominable lumps of flesh, everything is covered in gore, speech is an incomprehensible gargle, and everything smells like rotten eggs or poop. Because if something smells bad it is ALWAYS one of those things. Needless to say this has made even simple things like going to lunch with friends pure torture and he's almost completely cut himself off from society as a result. The only reason he simply doesn't kill himself is because a story that started with the main character offing themselves wouldn't sell very well he has one bright spot in his miserable life. The knowledge that someday humanity will clone dinosaurs and he'll be able to ride it to work and train it to eat that smelly guy in the office who always stealing his pens. Oh, and a cute, innocent, orphaned little girl named Saya who's currently living with him. For some reason Saya appears completely normal to him, an oasis of normality in a world that's gone horribly wrong. They work together to find a cure for his illness and he learns a valuable lesson on enjoying the beauty found in everyday lif-HAHAHAHAHAHAHA, no. Things turn ugly faster than something that turns ugly extremely quickly.

Yes, Saya No Uta is a horror game. And not the "shock" horror that relies on stuff jumping at the screen IN 3D! and showing you your gas bill or the creeping dread "Oh crap oh crap there's a bee in the room, I know it's in here, I can hear the buzzing noise, it's getting closer and closer, please someone save me, oh wait, it's just a fly. Hehe for a second there I was really scar-ARGGGHHHH I'VE BEEN STUNG" kind of horror.
The main character's house. Seriously. In retrospect my old house's mold problem wasn't so bad and I needed to stop complaining like a little bitch.
Instead it focuses on horror of the "sick and wrong" variety that makes you wonder what you've done to deserve having such thoughts inflicted upon you and why someone was thinking about them at all in the first place. Gore, while present, isn't really the point, and most of the mystery surrounding is largely removed. Saya No Uta achieves horror by examining the deranged, insane characters up close and personally while letting the player see things from their perspective. Other, relatively normal characters do feature as the perspective occasionally, mostly to provide exposition and to give a sense of reality and weight to what would otherwise be an experience so surreal as to largely lack any meaning. Oh crap, I went like a whole paragraph without a pathetic attempt at humor where the only joy to be derived from reading it is to have a laugh at my expense. Okay, what does a cat say when you step on it's tail? Meowch. Oh don't worry, that's not the joke, I'm not that pathetic, the real joke is that you wasted your time reading it and there's no way for you to punish me for making such a terrible joke by beating me within an inch of my life like I deserve.
[HEADING=2]Characters[/HEADING]
There's a horrifying abomination that threatens the very existence of humanity itself? No problem, I've got a shotgun.
There's 5 characters of note, none of them particularly deep, partially because the game is pretty short by visual novel standards. However they are all characterized well enough to serve their intended purpose. We feel sorry for characters we're meant to feel sorry for, characters that are supposed to disgust us totally do, blah blah blah. I would of preferred a bit more time with them but for the length it runs it does very well, and hey if they were good enough to catch my interest enough that I actually wanted to see more they're already better than 90% of the characters in existence so good job game developer people(showing disdain for the majority makes me classy and superior right?). Probably the best thing they did is keep the "evil" characters from turning into that supervillian "I'm being a dick and I know I'm being a dick but I'm going to keep being a dick because I find it hilarious and good is dumb" type of evil. They remain understandable/relatable and their actions vaguely resemble normal human behavior, which just makes them all the more disturbing.


[HEADING=2]Technical Stuffs[/HEADING]
Okay, I really only included this section since I'm copying the formatting from a previous review because I'm lazy. There's not a lot to talk about really. Features are pretty much as bare bones as it gets, though with the aforementioned length and the lack of enough choices to make the story difficult to navigate it's not really an issue. The art style is very "love it or hate it" as far as I can tell from internet comments, I personally thought it was fitting with the tone of the story and at least it's something ever so slightly different in an ocean of anime art styles that are terribly generic. Seriously, it's a cartoon people, you can go crazy on the visuals. I wasn't all that impressed with the music, it was fitting enough but it didn't really enhance the experience for me. However I've been informed by multiple elitist pricks music aficionados that my taste in music is shit and I'm less of a human being for it so feel free to ignore that sentiment and instead mock me for having an opinion that is wrong.




[HEADING=2]Sexual Content[/HEADING]



It's generally not a good sign when your game starts with a screen like this. If I was going to investigate a game company I'm totally choosing the one that includes reassurance that they haven't committed any crimes. TVtropes taught me all about suspiciously specific denials...
Oh dear, because it wouldn't be a visual novel without porn. I'm just going to come right out and say it, these are the best sex scenes in any of the games I've ever played. Don't get me wrong, they're still painfully unsexy/unromantic, however at least it's intentional for once and serves a point beyond "1. Include sex scenes in game 2.???? 3. Profit!". That point is to solve the overpopulation problem by ruining sex for everyone. Someone get these guy's a Nobel Prize because they succeeded spectacularly. It starts off with pedophelia and pretty much goes downhill from there. In Saya No Uta, even the tentacle monsters aren't safe from being horribly raped.







[HEADING=2]Summary[/HEADING]
I don't exactly consider myself a pansy when it comes to horror, in fact I find most horror rather boring, so I find it pretty rare and remarkable for a work to actually provoke any sort of response. The games unique, doesn't pull any punches, and if nothing else it should keep you interested enough to finish the whole thing even if you don't find it at all scary. However the best(worst?)thing about it is that in the middle of all the depravity it somehow manages to be beautiful.
Oh context, you can be a real bitch sometimes.
 

NeutralDrow

New member
Mar 23, 2009
9,097
0
0
You do add a bit to my desire to play this game, which I've already heard is good. Unfortunately, that's contingent on my ever suddenly becoming enamored of any kind of horror, much less one like this.

Also...

So I felt like doing a review but I'm too lazy to review Ever17 at the moment so you get this instead. Trying to review that without spoiling anything is the equivalent of trying to do math without using any numbers.
Irony!
 

FredTheUndead

New member
Aug 13, 2010
303
0
0
I have yet to play Saya personally (actually if I were to pick up a Nitro+ title it would probably be Chaos;Head or Demonbane first, unless you count Fate Zero), but the art is fucking fantastic. Saya and Fuminori are a hideous slitherbeast and an insane cannibal serial killer respectively, but the view Fuminori has of the world contrasted with the images of Saya herself creates a mesmerizing view in every shot I've seen.
 

Gigano

Whose Eyes Are Those Eyes?
Oct 15, 2009
2,281
0
0
... I suppose I'll have to familiarize myself really well with the skip button[footnote]It does have one... right?[/footnote] and just play the damn thing, since it is so unanimously and consistently described as having all the best kinds of horror elements.

Great review.
 

Evilsanta

New member
Apr 12, 2010
1,933
0
0
Glad to hear that someone actully could play this. Though I will never touch this one as I can't stand gore and the other elements that are present in Saya.

Good review.
 

Catchy Slogan

New member
Jun 17, 2009
1,931
0
0
Hmm, I just happened to be listening to sick sick sick by QoTSA whilst reading this, it kinda went well with the descriptions.
 

Gigano

Whose Eyes Are Those Eyes?
Oct 15, 2009
2,281
0
0
Sober Thal said:
What's the game play like?
It's a visual novel [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_novel], so conventionally it's more about reading the story and making key decisions which branch the storyline(s). With background stills, a variety of character sprites, sound effect/music and often voice acting and (very) limited animation as well to add to the immersion, rather than ordinary gameplay.

Their form somewhat resemble early text games like Zork coupled with point and click adventure games like Myst; In more modern terms I'd describe them as sort of a love child between Heavy Rain and Powerpoint (which I suppose really don't sell them and their many qualities too well, but there's a reason I'm not in marketing).

Also, what system is this... never mind, I'll use google for real info.
It's for PC. Doubt there's any ports of it for consoles, as an all ages version would essentially be meaningless.
 

Hurray Forums

New member
Jun 4, 2008
397
0
0
Imperator_DK said:
... I suppose I'll have to familiarize myself really well with the skip button and just play the damn thing, since it is so unanimously and consistently described as having all the best kinds of horror elements.

Great review.
Yes, there's a skip button.

poiumty said:
Visuals look nice, too, so that'll be a change of pace.
FredTheUndead said:
I have yet to play Saya personally (actually if I were to pick up a Nitro+ title it would probably be Chaos;Head or Demonbane first, unless you count Fate Zero), but the art is fucking fantastic.
I enjoyed the art style as well for the most part, and it does make great use of contrast but I did have one HUGE complaint with it. The main character's perception is completely screwed up beyond all belief which is pretty much a free ticket to go nuts with the art when seeing things from his perspective but instead everything always looks pretty much the exact same, if you've seen one background in Saya No Uta you've seen all of them. I was really expecting better when I heard the premise.
 

FredTheUndead

New member
Aug 13, 2010
303
0
0
Sober Thal said:
So.....

What's the game play like?

Is that too much to ask of a review?!?

Also, what system is this... never mind, I'll use google for real info.
He clearly stated it was a visual novel.
 

Hiphophippo

New member
Nov 5, 2009
3,509
0
0
A friend of mine actually told me about this not long ago. I'm not all that into the anime aesthetic nor am I into sex games, but he maintains that I'll enjoy this as I LOVE real horror. I'm willing to put up with the look of the game, and he says the sex isn't gratuitous so I may have to check it out. I don't mind this style of game at all. Hell, I love it. Hotel Dusk and games like it are some of my favorite games.
 

Gigano

Whose Eyes Are Those Eyes?
Oct 15, 2009
2,281
0
0
Hiphophippo said:
A friend of mine actually told me about this not long ago. I'm not all that into the anime aesthetic nor am I into sex games, but he maintains that I'll enjoy this as I LOVE real horror. I'm willing to put up with the look of the game, and he says the sex isn't gratuitous so I may have to check it out. I don't mind this style of game at all. Hell, I love it. Hotel Dusk and games like it are some of my favorite games.
It's certainly one of the best horror stories I've ever encountered (in any type of medium, that is), and scenes featuring sex makes up a very small percentage of it; the game is perhaps 4-6 hours long, with less than 15 minutes featuring sex. But the scenes are quite explicit (despite the requisite censorship) and of course very disturbing considering their subject matter and what the game is going for with them.

They can however be skipped through, which I for one recommend if you aren't fairly hardened to such things. Or have just eaten.
 

Hiphophippo

New member
Nov 5, 2009
3,509
0
0
Imperator_DK said:
They can however be skipped through, which I for one recommend if you aren't fairly hardened to such things. Or have just eaten.
Oh, no see...this is the "internet". I've been here long enough to become pretty well desensitized to everything in the entire world.
 

Lunareclipse123

New member
Aug 14, 2007
23
0
0
Sober Thal said:
What's the game play like?
It plays almost exactly the same as reading a book. There's a total of two choices you make which change the plot, so the interactive elements of this game are minimal. That said, it plays like reading a really really good book, so don't discount it for that. I really liked this game, especially the horrifying moment when you realise what is in fact *actually* going on.

@Hiphophippo, judging that your forum avatar is a Yellow Sign, I think you'd love it.
 

Gigano

Whose Eyes Are Those Eyes?
Oct 15, 2009
2,281
0
0
Hiphophippo said:
...
Oh, no see...this is the "internet". I've been here long enough to become pretty well desensitized to everything in the entire world.
Then I can only wholeheartedly recommend it.

...Though being desensitized to everything in this world might not necessarily be enough for the world of Saya. Its unrelentingly dark descent into depravity will get under your skin, though that immersive quality is of course really one of its greatest strengths.
 

Hurray Forums

New member
Jun 4, 2008
397
0
0
Thanks various peoples for explaining how a visual novel works. I'm so used to playing them that I forgot that most people don't and as such it would need to be explained X_X
Hiphophippo said:
A friend of mine actually told me about this not long ago. I'm not all that into the anime aesthetic nor am I into sex games, but he maintains that I'll enjoy this as I LOVE real horror. I'm willing to put up with the look of the game, and he says the sex isn't gratuitous so I may have to check it out. I don't mind this style of game at all. Hell, I love it. Hotel Dusk and games like it are some of my favorite games.
Yeah, this definitely is not a sex game. It's a horror game that includes sex as part of the horror. I kinda do and kinda don't agree with your friend on whether or not it's gratuitous. On the one hand, they are all "justified" in the narrative, on the other hand they're not terribly necessary and feel somewhat shoe-horned in as an excuse to disgust people. It works extremely well though so I didn't really mind.

Imperator_DK said:
They can however be skipped through, which I for one recommend if you aren't fairly hardened to such things. Or have just eaten.
You would still be able to understand the story if you skipped them, however if you're going to skip the disturbing parts of Saya No Uta there's not really any point to playing it. It would be like skipping the parts of an FPS where you shoot things.
 

Gigano

Whose Eyes Are Those Eyes?
Oct 15, 2009
2,281
0
0
Hurray Forums said:
...
Imperator_DK said:
They can however be skipped through, which I for one recommend if you aren't fairly hardened to such things. Or have just eaten.
You would still be able to understand the story if you skipped them, however if you're going to skip the disturbing parts of Saya No Uta there's not really any point to playing it. It would be like skipping the parts of an FPS where you shoot things.
True, but the sex scenes and how they're set up appeared needlessly explicit to me, and they do provide a different kind of "horrible" than mere horror elements, one I'm less eager to pursue.

For a game that - among other things - does implied horror so incredibly well, having such (in direction, setup, and angles almost porno)graphic and disgusting sex scenes didn't feel necessary. Not that they really hurt the story, they got the point of the total dissolution of all conventional ethics across quite well, but I wish they would've done so in a less explicit way that wouldn't turn away a fair few horror fans, and leave some of the rest with a bad taste in their mouths (not to mention potential legal troubles in more puritanically paranoid states).

Overall, they aren't much of a problem I suppose, not even to me. Just slight speckles on an otherwise flawless Bloodstone.