I really liked dishonored and think prey 2017 is one of the best game of the last decade but I just can't get excited for deathloop. The basic premise does nothing for me, I really dislike time travel story because there's always a millions things that you should be able to do with time travel that you never can (ie go back 1 hour before a big event to stop it rather than months/years) and the 1 day plot also just feel arbitrary. I'll play it eventually and it's good to know that it plays well but... nah just can't get excited.
Yeah it's hard to implement time travel in any medium and have it hold up well. I think, from a video game perspective, the original Prince of Persia: Sands of Time did it great, especially with how everything was resolved. But, yeah, it can be very messy.
I'm curious enough knowing it's single player to check it out, as I really enjoyed the Dishonored series, as it really gave you a lot of variety on how to proceed. Including a style of challenge that at first seems like it will be hard, but really ends up being super easy. I like how the different powers you got, governed your playstyle.
I think these devs dial into a style of gameplay that I personally really enjoy, so I'm on board for it.