Mr.Pandah said:
Man...you guys should ask for some more formal reviews of games from us. I'd totally sign up for that =D I know theres guest review, but that happens so rarely...
The Guest Reviews happen rarely for the following reasons.
One: not many things submitted are up to our standards for publication. I generally work with those authors to give them some pointers on how to tune up their work.
Two: Someone asks to review a retro game. We don't cover retro games, unless they're being re-released, as with the X-Com bundle on Steam. We even stretched it to include Jade Empire, as it's an Xbox Original.
Three: Someone asks to review a game we're reviewing in-house, such as Killzone 2. While we're not necessarily opposed to having more than one review up for a game, with so many games out there to cover, it seems kind of silly to double up.
Four: Someone asks to review a game, gets the go-ahead, and never delivers. This happens far more often than you might think. People have lives, responsibilities, and obligations, and coming through with a review ends up getting pushed down their priority list.