I don't know what's worse; what Doc Phil said or the fact you guys are approving.
Seriously. If he would have attacked WoW or GTA4 the same way he did with Farmville and that woman, you guys would all yell on how he is evil and should die in a fire but but since you don't appreciate this game (that I don't play either) it's all good and fun and you give the man a pat on the back. Seriously. So people can attack gaming as long as the "hardcore" crowd isn't concerned. Fucking. Double-standard. Bullshit.
It's a game. Like it or not, it's still a game, people play it, and they are gamers too. A different public, but still gamers. And more importantly, it's not like he attacked that game for its own specific flaws like a movie critic attacks a bad movie, he attacked the medium. He said: ""There aren't really any crops," Dr. Phil informed her. "That's just a little image on a screen. They're not going to die.""
Replace "crops" with anything else and the man could basically be talking about any game as a waste of time, be it Halo, Modern Warfare 2, Bioshock, Mario Galaxy, Portal or even freaking Passage.
That woman obliviously had a problem but like I said, if she'd been a WoW player and Doc Phil had said:""There aren't really any Elves," Dr. Phil informed her. "That's just a little image on a screen. They're not going to die."", you guys would be filling this topic with hate and not RESPECT +10.
Next time a story like this comes up and it's about a game you care about, don't act all righteously offended, because you just proved that most of you care only about their favourite games and not "Gaming" as a medium in general. Sure, Farmville isn't the deepest game around but it brings fun, yes, the same fun you have playing any other games, to a bunch of people. It's incredibly hypocrite to judge "casual" gamers and then be all offended when they judge you back. Try to be the bigger man.
Does Farmville suck? Certainly, as a game it sucks. But Doc Phil isn't being a smart gaming critic with his own Escapist Magazine column. It's as if someone was attacking someone who watches too many bad movies but does so in a way to attack all movies in general.