I think the reason they have never explicitly stated these policies before, is that prior to this PSN was really not the central communications hub. Remember PSN's one big flaw was that it did not have a centralized global voice chat. That was left to in game implementation. They just provided a path to facilitate it more or less. With the deeper integration they have had to clarify and expand their policies. If you look into it, it is probably not much different then those put up by most MMO's and by XBL. It just seems more intrusive and shocking because they have the capabilities to log voice chat as well as text chat. But really in the overall scheme of things they amount to the same thing.Raziel said:This doesn't trouble me, all that stuff is public information anyway, except the text messages. And even then its still on Sony's private system. I'm honestly surprised they don't already do this. I've always assumed they did.
To me this sounds a lot more like the base for some attempt to clean up online behavior. Which I am all in favor of. I play limited amounts online, not because of anything sony does, but because of the crap players do. If just one of the real jacka... I've had to play with gets banned with this info I'm more than willing to agree to these terms.
As I said above. So long as they are not using this to build marketing data, it is fine appropriate, and probably completely ethical. Ethics does support them policing their space to provide a safe welcoming environment for all and preventing harassment, exploitation and illegality. And as an example of what happens when such social networking providers fail to police said space or screw it up, just look at what has happened over at YouTube this week with the comenting changes. It was badly implemented and the site is over run with ASCII art penises. Privacy is the last thing you want to give gamers on the internet...