Jack and Calumon said:
Take your favourite franchise, series, film, game or TV show. Now go read a fanfic in which they all have sex with each other, even if they had no emotions or didn't even meet. Even read a Slash-Fic, a fiction where two characters meet in other franchises and then have sex, anything.
Okay, I'm not going to look for a fanfic where Ghost and McTavish get it on, thank you very much.
However, with that said, the only reason this very... jarringly out of character. And sometimes very in-detail, and, therefore, horrifying.
Nothing like that here. Han Solo and Chewie actually can die, that's one. They don't get horrifically murdered in bloody detail or torn to shreds, that's two.
Really, is this scene going to, in any way, change your perception of the characters? Of course, not. In fact, it's a different timeline - they might as well not be themselves. I don't see how this is supposed to matter one bit, even if you will remember the situation.
If it evokes sadness, they succeeded. If you believe they should've given the characters a far more deserving send-off even in this pseudo-side story, that's absolutely fine. However, this in no way makes it "the biggest, dirtiest and stupidest bomb".
Jack and Calumon said:
Calumon: Arguing makes me sad... : (
Yeah. Not particularly fond of it, too. Except when it's about politics.
With that said, I think it's unfair that LucasArts are being reprimanded for getting somewhat creative because seeing familiar characters get killed in some fanfic-equivealent upsets them.
P.S. No, I'm not going to look for the MW2 slash fics. However, I would be interested to know if those actually existed.
Not going to check that. NSFS (not safe for soul).