samaugsch said:
Here's something I want to ask all of you Star Wars nerds: What if instead of Starkiller, Darth Vader showed up? How would the fight have turned out then? Would they have given Vader a run for his money or would he have killed them just as easily as Starkiller did?
Vader would have won, easily. You just have to look at the Cloud City scene in The Empire Strikes Back to see how one-sided a Han vs Vader fight would be. A better question might be: would fans have a more positive reaction to these DLCs if it was Vader instead of Starkiller.
Personally I'd say yes. Vader is an established character, whereas Starkiller is... well I found the first TFU quite engaging, but Starkiller has just become more and more dislikeable and now he's just Kratos with a lightsabre. As much as I like Kratos, and at the risk of sounding like someone who'd put Jedi under religion on a census form, that's not what the Star Wars universe should be about. Anger, hatred and vengeance are meant to be bad things, and tossing in an ending where our hero shows restraint and mercy doesn't really ring true after he's spent the entire game slaughtering everything in sight in pursuit of his personal vendetta.
So it's no wonder that there's a negative reaction when this ghastly character - even a what if version - is seen cutting a swathe through the much loved characters of the original trilogy with all the superficial showiness of the prequel trilogy, plus added GoW style sadism.
Presumably the next DLC will feature a Dagobah level in which Starkiller will stomp Yoda into the mud in an overly long QTE. That seems to be all they have left to do really.