Harmonix Employees Posted Positive Rock Band 4 Amazon Reviews

Lizzy Finnegan

New member
Mar 11, 2015
1,650
0
0
Harmonix Employees Posted Positive Rock Band 4 Amazon Reviews



A number of positive Amazon reviews for Rock Band 4 were submitted by Harmonix employees.

Rock Band 4 developer Harmonix has confirmed that a number of Amazon [http://www.amazon.com/Rock-Band-Band-Box-Bundle/product-reviews/B00Z9HS664/ref=cm_cr_pr_btm_link_next_4?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1&sortBy=bySubmissionDateDescending&reviewerType=all_reviews&formatType=all_formats&pageNumber=4] user reviews for the game were posted by Harmonix employees.

The reviews, which all ranked the game five stars, were first pointed out by Destructoid [https://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/3pojjj/harmonix_employees_have_been_posting_rave_reviews/] finding more - with one claiming to be a "new fan."

A statement provided to The Escapist by a Harmonix spokesperson reads:

"Harmonix has clarified its internal policy about posting reviews of our own products on retail sites, and we've asked that existing reviews be edited to identify Harmonix employees or be removed entirely. While we believe the reviews posted by a few employees were sincere and without ill intentions, as a studio we don't believe these are appropriate actions. We appreciate the feedback from the community, and take our relationship with our fans seriously."

Several of the reviews that were spotted have been amended to reflect the correlation of the reviewer with Rock Band 4. Harmonix project manager Matthew Nordhaus clarified "I added this review half in jest (as you might be able to tell from the tone of the original). In hindsight, it's probably important that I note that I worked on the game and work for Harmonix. That being said, I'm confident that if I didn't I would still give the game five stars. It's a beautiful, peaceful, cooperative game, rare enough already in today's landscape, that I can play with my wife and kids. Music discovery, playing with your family and friends, and cooperation make Rock Band my favorite."

The Escapist's Joshua Vanderwall reviewed Rock Band 4 [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/video-games/editorials/reviews/14733-Rock-Band-4-Review-Harmonix-Rhythm-Music#&gid=gallery_4812&pid=1], writing "Like many, I've been a fan of Rock Band for years, and Rock Band 4 fills all of those gaming inclinations. The several minuscule issues coupled with the primary, yet still small concern of ambiguous song difficulties mean it's imperfect, but not by much," rating the game 4.5 out of 5 stars.

Permalink
 

Queen Michael

has read 4,010 manga books
Jun 9, 2009
10,400
0
0
A "new fan?" If I were in his shoes, I'd watch out for bosses asking why I wasn't a fan before.
 

ShakerSilver

Professional Procrastinator
Nov 13, 2009
885
0
0
This sort of thing happens quite a bit on sites like Metacritic. User reviews can be just as slanted and deceptive as professional reviews, especially considering just how open they are in nature.
 

BX3

New member
Mar 7, 2011
659
0
0
Disappointing to read. Harmonix is good enough in their development process where they don't really need to do this kinda thing.
 

Scarim Coral

Jumped the ship
Legacy
Apr 30, 2020
18,159
1
3
Country
UK
Yeah, game companies employee should stop making bias reviews wheather they were paid/ force to or not. They always get caught sooner or later.
 

Steve the Pocket

New member
Mar 30, 2009
1,649
0
0
Gee, it's a shame there isn't some kind of movement dedicated to stamping out unethical practices in regard to reviews of video games. Otherwise I'd expect them to be out in full force over stuff like this.
 

Lizzy Finnegan

New member
Mar 11, 2015
1,650
0
0
Steve the Pocket said:
Gee, it's a shame there isn't some kind of movement dedicated to stamping out unethical practices in regard to reviews of video games. Otherwise I'd expect them to be out in full force over stuff like this.
Well if you aren't a part of such a movement, you'd likely not see that reaction.
 

kris40k

New member
Feb 12, 2015
350
0
0
Steve the Pocket said:
Gee, it's a shame there isn't some kind of movement dedicated to stamping out unethical practices in regard to reviews of video games. Otherwise I'd expect them to be out in full force over stuff like this.
The people doing it got caught.
The game journalists (Escapist, Destructoid, at least) are actually reporting on it instead of hand-waving it away.
The company responded and is taking action to stop it.
Edited reviews are reflecting the employees standing for transparency, and showing the company's response had effect.

Hmm...yeah, I think we're good here.

People can feel free to talk shit about Harmonix about it though, but I see no reason for outrage. That's just me.
 

sonicneedslovetoo

New member
Jul 6, 2015
278
0
0
That is so ghetto, real companies pay other people to post positive reviews for them. I mean can't they even afford to do that?(Judging by the massive marketing campaign I've seen everywhere and am rapidly growing tired of for Rock Band 4, yes they can)
 

ffs-dontcare

New member
Aug 13, 2009
701
0
0
I'm glad the company admitted it and took steps to rectify the situation. I can't imagine wanting to give any game I worked on a high rating, though. It's hard for me to comprehend properly reviewing a game I spent a lot of time developing and testing, as opposed to looking at it from the perspective of an outsider who's just started playing it.

Steve the Pocket said:
Gee, it's a shame there isn't some kind of movement dedicated to stamping out unethical practices in regard to reviews of video games. Otherwise I'd expect them to be out in full force over stuff like this.
So, a company gets caught doing something bad, it gets reported on and then actioned, and you still thought it was a good idea to come in here and do your movement a disservice by trying to draw all the attention and glory to GG? Well done.
 

mysecondlife

New member
Feb 24, 2011
2,142
0
0
Comparing to EA employee's 5 star rating for Dragon Age 2 when the fans were going apeshit about its quality, this is really nothing.
 

Mr.Mattress

Level 2 Lumberjack
Jul 17, 2009
3,646
0
0
At least I can understand why: Their company needs this game to succeed or they will be bankrupt. They've sunk so much time and money into this one game that if it doesn't do well, they all loose a job. If I was an Employee at Harmonix, I too would post a Positive Review of the Game under the Pretense of being a regular fan of the series.

Doesn't make it any less despicable or desperate, I'm just saying I understand why they'd do this. It seems like Harmonix accepted responsibility and fixed the reviews, though, so that's good.
 

FirstNameLastName

Premium Fraud
Nov 6, 2014
1,080
0
0
ffs-dontcare said:
Steve the Pocket said:
Gee, it's a shame there isn't some kind of movement dedicated to stamping out unethical practices in regard to reviews of video games. Otherwise I'd expect them to be out in full force over stuff like this.
So, a company gets caught doing something bad, it gets reported on and then actioned, and you still thought it was a good idea to come in here and do your movement a disservice by trying to draw all the attention and glory to GG? Well done.
I don't think it was intended as a complement toward GG, but rather, as a stale jab at GamerGate for their supposed silence on the subject. Either way, it's a rather stupid point to make. Why would GG be out in "full force" to combat a problem that was apparently fixed as soon as it was identified? It's a bit too late to combat a problem when the first thing you hear about it is that it's been fixed. Beside which, it's not like GG is in favour of this. I don't think anyone is in favour of this, so I don't really see what any movement could possibly do to stop anonymous people on the internet from posting shitty reviews.
 

jdogtwodolla

phbbhbbhpbhphbhpbttttt......
Feb 12, 2009
732
0
0
Coincidentally, I read in the paper that Amazon is going to be suing a large amount of people who post illegitimate positive product reviews.

Yes, I read the paper still.
 

ffs-dontcare

New member
Aug 13, 2009
701
0
0
FirstNameLastName said:
ffs-dontcare said:
Steve the Pocket said:
Gee, it's a shame there isn't some kind of movement dedicated to stamping out unethical practices in regard to reviews of video games. Otherwise I'd expect them to be out in full force over stuff like this.
So, a company gets caught doing something bad, it gets reported on and then actioned, and you still thought it was a good idea to come in here and do your movement a disservice by trying to draw all the attention and glory to GG? Well done.
I don't think it was intended as a complement toward GG, but rather, as a stale jab at GamerGate for their supposed silence on the subject. Either way, it's a rather stupid point to make. Why would GG be out in "full force" to combat a problem that was apparently fixed as soon as it was identified? It's a bit too late to combat a problem when the first thing you hear about it is that it's been fixed. Beside which, it's not like GG is in favour of this. I don't think anyone is in favour of this, so I don't really see what any movement could possibly do to stop anonymous people on the internet from posting shitty reviews.
You make a very good point. It was rather hard for me to tell whether or not he was making a jab or a compliment toward GG in the first place. But this isn't the first time I've seen those sort of comments made on this kind of subject.
 

Frezzato

New member
Oct 17, 2012
2,448
0
0
BX3 said:
Disappointing to read. Harmonix is good enough in their development process where they don't really need to do this kinda thing.
Too true! I always thought the timing in Rock Band games was far superior to any Guitar Hero title. Felt more intuitive.
 

BX3

New member
Mar 7, 2011
659
0
0
Frezzato said:
BX3 said:
Disappointing to read. Harmonix is good enough in their development process where they don't really need to do this kinda thing.
Too true! I always thought the timing in Rock Band games was far superior to any Guitar Hero title. Felt more intuitive.
I always felt the UI was a lot more easy on the eyes as well. I mean, I know that GH has been going for the "fuck yeah, rock and roll!" color scheme and style since its inception, but something about the cool blue base with those rigid colored notes that crack apart when you hit them lends to a smoother and better feeling experience IMO.

The artstyle of the avatars are preferable as well, but that's neither here nor there.
 

Lizzy Finnegan

New member
Mar 11, 2015
1,650
0
0
Oh look. I wonder if EA will sue them now for stealing their ideas.

My god, you would seriously think people would be above this bullshit by now, do they have a bonus at stake if they don't get a certain amount of positive reviews, how desperate can they get.