Sparrow said:
Jumplion said:
Urgh. Seriously, how much of this isn't fanboy talk?
I get the fact the QTE's span into a big, huge sprawling storyline... but they're still all QTE's. And therefore, I can't consider this a game.
Fanboy? Really now? You're just going to claim fanboyism so you don't have to justify anything? At least put up a counter argument instead of going "FANBOY" and run to the bushes.
All I've posted is my opinion, nothing more nothing less. I disagree with you, so I provide an opinion on your opinion. It's sad how a veteran user of the Escapist (I assume by your join date and post count) is using the "fanboy!" argument.
I don't really get why this can't be a "game". Guitar Hero is nothing but QTE's, though they mask it up pretty well I admit. It's a lot like how Disney critics claimed that "animation can't be a movie, nobody wants to sit for an hour to watch cartoons!" (sorry, doing a report on Walt Disney, popped to mind). Who says what can and can't be a game?
You have your opinion, I have mine, but at least have the decency not to belittle my opinion by saying I'm a "fanboy".
bartholen said:
OKay, seriously. Heavy Rain is either going to be revolutionizing or the biggest failure of the decade, and it's only 2010. Who really wants to press a button, watch 20 seconds of animation, press another button, watch 10 seconds another animation etc.?
And when David Cage said Heavy Rain is "not porn"... blah. If he wanted to make a cinematic experience, he should at least had some decent camera work in the bit where the woman dries herself with the towel. That booby-shot was absolutely gratuituous.
*NOTE: All links
NSFW*
Gratuitous? No sir, that is hardly gratuitous, these [http://l.yimg.com/jh/content/p/6/828015/dead-or-alive-xtreme-2-review-20061113061115288_screen001.jpg] are [http://www.ps3vault.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/04/deadoralive.jpg] gratuitious [http://www.wallpaperez.net/wallpaper/games/Dead-or-Alive-4-DOA-girls-810.jpg] boobies [http://www.everyday-gamer.net/images/ivy_soul_calibur_iv.jpg] giggity [http://static.gamesradar.com/images/mb/GamesRadar/us/Other/Features/2008/Sexy%20fan%20art/Soul%20Calibur/Soul_Calibur_4_Cassandra_by_Jayun--article_image.jpg].
Guess what,
breasts are natural. Problem is most breasts in games are held up by invisible iron-bras, enforced steel implants, and jiggle around more than a giggling school-girl on crack. In this scene, you don't even have to do anything. You could just walk in and out of the bathroom and the scene would probably proceed. You don't need to take a shower or undress, the boobs are never in your face, and you never have to see them. If they were shoved in your face or if the showering was forced upon you to see "LOOK, BOOBIES!" then yes, it would be gratuitous. But really, if we're comparing something like this [http://static.gamesradar.com/images/mb//GamesRadar/us/Games/D/Devil%20May%20Cry%204/Everything%20Else/ART/Finished/lady_obs--screenshot_large.jpg] to what is basically showing breasts like this [http://www.crystalinks.com/venusadonis.jpg] then we really need to grow up. (not comparing Art to Heavy Rain, that remains to be seen, but hopefully you get my point)