Is Microsoft Nervous About Spielberg and Halo?

Andy Chalk

One Flag, One Fleet, One Cat
Nov 12, 2002
45,698
1
0
Is Microsoft Nervous About Spielberg and Halo?


Steven Spielberg's quest for the Halo [http://halo.xbox.com/] movie rights may find itself up against a very large and rather unexpected obstacle: nervous executives at Microsoft.

The tale of Halo's ongoing journey to the big screen is a long and twisted one, fraught with pitfalls and essentially at a dead-end since DreamWorks [http://www.amazon.com/Lord-Rings-Picture-Trilogy-Widescreen/dp/B0001VL0K2/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1286392217&sr=8-3] may be anxious to get its hands on the moribund franchise, the rumor is that Microsoft may not be entirely thrilled with the idea.

DreamWorks' focus on the game's novels, described by the Universal Pictures [http://nymag.com/daily/entertainment/2010/10/the_new_halo_video_game_is_a_h.html] has already blown $12 million on screenwriting and producing fees, and should its legal department come calling to recoup that money, DreamWorks can claim it is working on an entirely different Halo project.

But perhaps even more importantly, sticking to the books rather than opting for an original script demonstrates a commitment to the canon that could help keep publicly supported [http://www.microsoft.com] the film project, one source claims the company would rather see things left well enough alone.

"It's a gigantic waste of time, because [Microsoft] doesn't want anything to happen in any other media that could screw up a multi-billion dollar franchise," the source said. "Somebody has to be in control of a movie; it's a director's medium. But they're completely averse to that. Because if Steven Spielberg fucks it up, what's your recourse? So the rule is, 'First, do no harm.'"

It may sound ludicrous at first blush, but think about it: What happens if the videogame movie curse holds true and Spielberg drops the ball? It's not like you can run out and get some higher-priced talent to clean up the mess. And while videogames are far more front-and-center in the mainstream consciousness now than they were a decade ago, a bad film could still sour the taste of the franchise for the public at large. Is it just a coincidence that the in one day [http://www.amazon.com/Wing-Commander-Prophecy-Pc/dp/B00002EPYI/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=videogames&qid=1286392902&sr=1-1] that most major motion pictures do in their entire theatrical run - Microsoft might be thinking that the best Halo movie is the one that never gets made.


Permalink
 

Onyx Oblivion

Borderlands Addict. Again.
Sep 9, 2008
17,032
0
0
Hey, Speilberg's Boom Blox game was awesome.

Maybe his Halo movie can be awesome.
 

Dyp100

New member
Jul 14, 2009
898
0
0
Damnit, why can't we go back to Jackson and his young padawan!? That would have been awesome...

I personally never really liked Spielberg's films, I'm anxious and excited about a Halo movie at the same time.
 

Littaly

New member
Jun 26, 2008
1,810
0
0
You know what else doesn't bode well for Halo... The original developer who brought in all those fans and money stops working on the franchise.

I'd say that right now, a Halo movie is the lesser concern when it comes to not ruining the good name of Halo.
 

Thaius

New member
Mar 5, 2008
3,862
0
0
If MIscrosoft screws up our chance to get a Halo movie made by Steven Frickin' Spielberg, I will hate them forever. And if they proceed to hand Halo off to some random developer that completely destroys the franchise, and we never got a movie because they wanted to destroy it themselves, I will detest everything about them until the end of time.
 

Amnestic

High Priest of Haruhi
Aug 22, 2008
8,946
0
0
"It's a gigantic waste of time, because [Microsoft] doesn't want anything to happen in any other media that could screw up a multi-billion dollar franchise,"
So all those books, comics, Halo Legends (which in itself was a collection of short movies) and whatnot, those are fine, but a feature-length movie is a big no-no? You've got one of the most accomplished directors in the world interested in making a movie for your franchise and you're thinking it might be better to leave well enough alone? Good lord. I'm not saying he's perfect, but you'd think with all of the good stuff he's got under his belt they'd have a little faith in his abilities by now.
 

Harold Donchee

New member
Jul 6, 2009
333
0
0
psrdirector said:
I really hope a halo movie comes out and kills that franchise, been hilarious.
It won't. A bad movie won't turn off the people that like the game. They'll just be pissed off at Speilberg or whoever ends up directing it. It may turn away people who have never played it, but if you haven't played a Halo game by now you're not going to.
 

C95J

I plan to live forever.
Apr 10, 2010
3,491
0
0
I think a Halo movie would be good.

But a Halo movie made by SPIELBERG! Now THAT would be awesome!
 

Blind Sight

New member
May 16, 2010
1,658
0
0
The Wing Commander series was already pretty much a movie, hell, they had better actors then the actual film (Malcolm McDowell is far better then Freddy Prince Jr.). Other game franchises have continued after their terrible movies, does no one remember Super Mario Bros? Microsoft must be pretty desperate to try and defend their IP, especially after they've milked it for so long.

SteinFaust said:
I prefer Neil Blompkamp.

that is what I have to say about this article.
District 10 before Halo, I want District 10 so bad.
 

Nouw

New member
Mar 18, 2009
15,615
0
0
Let's hope his legacy lives up again. I'd rather have Peter Jackson so he can film it in NZ.
 

Loonerinoes

New member
Apr 9, 2009
889
0
0
Really, it entirely depends on what route such a movie would take.

One of the biggest mistakes that I've seen repeated in just about EVERY goddamed movie adaptation of a videogame is this notion that the movie HAS to deal with a truly epic or important part of the game. Resident Evil movies just HAVE to include Jill Valentine and have to take place in Raccoon City or AvP movie HAD to talk about the founder of Weyland-Yutani corp. in only a by-the-way fashion.

Why not have just one videogame movie that for once does not try to ape on the hype from the videogame characters or events and instead tries to cover a less well-known or merely hinted at parts that the games could not delve into? For example, with the new Mass Effect movie I think it'd be a horrendous idea really to have it revolve around Commander Shepard and the fight against the Reapers, almost exactly like in the game. For starters, some might not see him as a 'him' at all, because they preffered Jennifer Hale's voice! But if it dealt with say...the First Contact war a bit more indepth, or the Jump Zero incidents...that might genuinely catch my attention because you only hear about these things in the videogame, but never see them happen.

TLDR, it'd help videogame movies if they didn't try to work off the existant hype, because they'll always fall short of measuring up in that respect, but would instead try to complement the universe they are based upon. Why make a movie about the fall of Reach if you already have a videogame where you can experience that fall yourself? Why not instead make a Halo movie about say...first contact with the aliens and what led to this all-out war and how it happened? That'd interest most far more I think...
 

Lyinar

New member
Sep 17, 2010
11
0
0
Of course, how many Mortal Kombat games got released after the hilariously awful second movie? At least three to my knowledge.

And Street Fighter came back from the ravages of the movie's lack of quality (hey, at least it provided Raul Julia one last paycheck for his family...).

Unfortunately, I can't see Good Spielburg (who gave us the first three Indiana Jones movies, Saving Private Ryan, Jaws, Jurassic Park, and ET) working on a Halo movie, so we'll be stuck with Bad Spielburg, the one who gave us movies such as The Lost World and AI, who edited the guns out of ET, and who collaborated with Good Spielburg on Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.
 

Buizel91

Autobot
Aug 25, 2008
5,265
0
0
Harold Donchee said:
psrdirector said:
I really hope a halo movie comes out and kills that franchise, been hilarious.
It won't. A bad movie won't turn off the people that like the game. They'll just be pissed off at Speilberg or whoever ends up directing it. It may turn away people who have never played it, but if you haven't played a Halo game by now you're not going to.
Yeh, a bit like Transformers, we all still love it, we just hate Michael Bay.
 

Anarchemitis

New member
Dec 23, 2007
9,102
0
0
They're afraid that he'll make a good ending that ties it all off with no hope or need or possibility of a sequel.
Doomed if you succeed, doomed if you fail is Microsoft's presumption, I guess.
 

Timmons

New member
Mar 23, 2010
100
0
0
Loonerinoes said:
Really, it entirely depends on what route such a movie would take.

One of the biggest mistakes that I've seen repeated in just about EVERY goddamed movie adaptation of a videogame is this notion that the movie HAS to deal with a truly epic or important part of the game. Resident Evil movies just HAVE to include Jill Valentine and have to take place in Raccoon City or AvP movie HAD to talk about the founder of Weyland-Yutani corp. in only a by-the-way fashion.

Why not have just one videogame movie that for once does not try to ape on the hype from the videogame characters or events and instead tries to cover a less well-known or merely hinted at parts that the games could not delve into? For example, with the new Mass Effect movie I think it'd be a horrendous idea really to have it revolve around Commander Shepard and the fight against the Reapers, almost exactly like in the game. For starters, some might not see him as a 'him' at all, because they preffered Jennifer Hale's voice! But if it dealt with say...the First Contact war a bit more indepth, or the Jump Zero incidents...that might genuinely catch my attention because you only hear about these things in the videogame, but never see them happen.

TLDR, it'd help videogame movies if they didn't try to work off the existant hype, because they'll always fall short of measuring up in that respect, but would instead try to complement the universe they are based upon. Why make a movie about the fall of Reach if you already have a videogame where you can experience that fall yourself? Why not instead make a Halo movie about say...first contact with the aliens and what led to this all-out war and how it happened? That'd interest most far more I think...
YES... having a Film about first contact with the coventant, or previous forms of it would be way more interesting than master chief spraying his way through hordes of enemies. Things that are fun in games just aren't fun in films. I think they should finally introduce the forerunners... though that may ruin the mystery of them. :/
Lets be realistic, the story won't be very interesting, but the effects and the action will be preetty saweet
 

Mausenheimmer

New member
Feb 11, 2008
96
0
0
There's a big difference between the damage/good a minor dvd release like Halo Legends and a major theatrical release involving Spielberg can do to a brand. Personally, I feel that if Spielberg is willing to put his name behind it, then you have to seriously consider it.

But I see where Microsoft is coming from. Worst case scenario is that it goes the way of Wing Commander and can not recover from an awful film (which is possible but unlikely based off of the Transformers debacle as mentioned earlier). Best case scenario is that it makes a lot of money and gets more people interested in the brand. But there are diminishing marginal returns on that benefit because Halo is already one of the most well-known games out there. If someone hasn't played Halo by now, it's not because they haven't heard of it.
 

Amnestic

High Priest of Haruhi
Aug 22, 2008
8,946
0
0
If we're not satisfied with the direct Halo: Legends link, then let's toss out Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within; a film so awful it was described as a "box office bomb". How are FF games doing now? No worse. In fact, it released shortly (as in, months) before FFX - one of the highest selling FF games ever - got released.

Even a feature-length film which was awful didn't stop the games sales.