It's a Studio Ghibli double feature--let's review Kiki's Delivery Service and My Neighbor Totoro!

RentCavalier

New member
Dec 17, 2007
334
0
0
Ah, Hayao Miyazaki. The reigning champion of Japanese animation, and probably one of the finest storytellers in the world, Hayao Miyazaki is and always has been amongst my favorite animators. I've slowly made my way through his filmography, and have taken the opportunity to watch some of his older films--one I haven't seen since the wee twilight days of my childhood, and a classic I'd never seen at all. So, let's waste no more time and dive into the double-review!
---

My Neighbor Totoro is a strange movie. Chock full of nostalgia for an era I've never experienced, with a soft, optimistic view on childhood innocence and the pursuit of imagination, dreams and spirituality, My Neighbor Totoro is very different from children's movies today. Despite--or maybe because of--this, My Neighbor Totoro is like a blast of fresh air, a heartwarming, simplistic and very endearing story that manages to combine child-like innocence with gorgeous visuals and an excellent soundtrack.

Totoro is the story of two sisters, Satsuki and Mei, who along with their scatterminded, professor father have moved out to the country to settle in an ancient, run-down, possibly haunted house. They never explicitly state why they are moving, but it has something do to with their mother, who is hospitalized with a potentially deadly disease, which is also never fully explained.

As Satsuki and Mei explore their new house, we see just how exciting, grand and scary an old house can be to an 8-and-4-year-old. And this house isn't the same as most houses--strange shapes shift in dark places, acorns drop out of the ceiling, and the whole house creaks and sways in seasonal storms. Neighbors warn that the house may be haunted, which tickles the girls pink. As the littlest girl, Mei, explores the sprawling ground, she discovers a strange tunnel that leads to the base of an enormous camphor tree--inside of which she discovers a secret grotto wherein sleeps the titular Totoro.

Totoro is 2/3s adorable and 1/3 terrifying. A simply gargantuan tanuki creature--kind of like a magic racoon--Totoro is named by Mei based off some children's book she has about trolls. Totoro isn't a troll, but rather a forest spirit who inhabits the tree and spreads seeds across the land to grow more trees. He and Mei bond, somehow, and eventually Satsuki meets him as well, setting into motion the film's magical elements and leading to its heartrending climax.

Like every Miyazaki movie, this film looks amazing. Post-war Japan is vividly portrayed as a land in flux, where the old world and the new world are meeting, but not mixing. Old shrines dot the roadside, and the people give thanks and reverence to old gods who have since-been forgotten. Looking at modern Japan and then watching this movie only serves to accentuate the dichotomy. The world of Totoro resembles nothing of what we have come to imagine the Land of the Rising Sun to be, and in a way it pines for this old world, of spirits and ghosts and childlike wonder.

It is a good movie, though it hasn't aged that well. Some of the childish antics of the protagonists can be grating to an older viewer, the animation isn't as crisp or clean as modern animated films, and the minimalistic, low-key pacing of the story could bore our ADD, internet-obsessed children of today. Still, this movie has one of the most realistic depictions of young children I've ever seen in an animated feature, and it takes great care to illustrate just how terrifying and awe-inspiring the world can seem from the eyes of a small child. It teaches us to slow down, to appreciate what we have, to dream and wonder and not lose our imaginations. It shows us that we should respect the past, be it in the form of an old house, a giant tree, or the loveable old granny down the lane.

That's not a bad lesson, if you ask me. Now, if you excuse me, I've got to slam my head into my desk until I get that damned catchy theme song out of my head. Here it is in more manageable Japanese, rather than the dreadful English version the movie comes with.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UcaTKIpLpkU
 

RentCavalier

New member
Dec 17, 2007
334
0
0
Alright, alright, one down, I've got a shiny new concussion andsdjlajkhsdkajgsdafkajsdcsj Kiki's Delivery Service!
---

Ah, the one Miyazaki film everyone saw--except me. Until a few days, I'd somehow managed to willfully avoid watching this movie, partially because I wasn't that interested in the premise and partially because it looked like a rather girly movie with an inexplicable obsession with panty shots. Still, let it not be said that I won't try new things and I'm glad I did, because Kiki's Delivery Service is a fantastic film--superior, I'd say, to Totoro, though it suffers from a bit of a rushed pacing.

The story is simple--a young witch-in-trainng, Kiki, must leave home when she turns 13 to live away for a year and develop her powers. Though her parents are sad to see her go, they support her desire to strike out on her own and discover her own potential. With nothing but her broom, her talking black cat Jiji, and a bag of supplies, Kiki takes to the skies in search of her destiny.

She eventually settles in a big seaside city in some undisclosed part of Europe (like a weird mix of Southern France and Greece, with some Munich thrown in for good measure). Though her initial reception is less-than-warm, and she nearly gets run over by cars a bunch of times, she manages to find a kindly baker who lets her stay in her upstairs apartment. Finding that her only marketable skill is her ability to fly, Kiki sets up a delivery service, and...delivers things.

That's basically it. The entire story is the slow growth of Kiki, from a scared, insulated child to a strong-willed young woman, and she undergoes various trials and tribulations, encounters various characters who teach her something valuable, and even falls in love. The tale is endlessly charming--you can't help but like Kiki, who tries her hardest no matter how tough things get, but is too naive to withstand the harsh pressures of big city life. Her journey of self-discovery is punctuated by great humor, plenty of exciting flight sequences, and gorgeous visuals.

The film has an all-star cast, featuring a teenage Kirsten Dunst as the voice of Kiki, Janene Garofalo as a painter woman she befriends, and the late, great Phil Hartman as Jiji, her talking black cat. As charming as the tale is and as interesting as the cast and characters are, I have to admit the movie paces itself oddly. The major conflict of the story doesn't come in until the last twenty minutes, and the story ends abruptly, opting to show off the longer conclusive stills over the ending credits.

Still, I can't really hold that against the movie--after all, better to be short and sweet than overstay your welcome, and Kiki doesn't overstay her welcome. This movie is a triumph--it has something for everyone. Charming characters for kids, a coming-of-age story for adults, and lots of humor for all ages. Yes, it's kinda sorta basically the Japanese version of "Sabrina, the Teenage Witch" but I wouldn't hold that against it, would you?
 

Casual Shinji

Should've gone before we left.
Legacy
Jul 18, 2009
20,441
5,267
118
RentCavalier said:
It is a good movie, though it hasn't aged that well. Some of the childish antics of the protagonists can be grating to an older viewer, the animation isn't as crisp or clean as modern animated films, and the minimalistic, low-key pacing of the story could bore our ADD, internet-obsessed children of today.
This right here is why I LOVE this movie.

The kids act like kids and not like child actors. Mei is probably the most accurate representation of a child in a movie ever. And the low-key pacing only enhances the rural charm of the movie. This was always the difference between American kid's cartoons (Thundercats, Mask etc) and Japanese kid's cartoons like, Maple Town and The Moomins: American cartoons always needed to have as much shit going on as possible in order to keep kids distracted for a half hour while Japanese cartoons took their time to tell a story as if it was a story book.

RentCavalier said:
As charming as the tale is and as interesting as the cast and characters are, I have to admit the movie paces itself oddly. The major conflict of the story doesn't come in until the last twenty minutes, and the story ends abruptly, opting to show off the longer conclusive stills over the ending credits.
This is something inherit to almost every Miyizaki movie. Everytime you go watch a new one you have to tell your brain that you're not going to see the usual 3-act movie.
 

Azure Sky

New member
Dec 17, 2009
877
0
0
In my opinion, Kiki's seemed to end well before it should have as the story was only just getting started.

As for me, my two favorite movies of all time are Ghibli's original two:
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind
Laputa: Castle in the Sky

To think I am as old as Laputa, and Nausicaa is older still. o_O
Those are some fine examples of things that age well.
 

RentCavalier

New member
Dec 17, 2007
334
0
0
Silent Lycoris said:
In my opinion, Kiki's seemed to end well before it should have as the story was only just getting started.

As for me, my two favorite movies of all time are Ghibli's original two:
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind
Laputa: Castle in the Sky

To think I am as old as Laputa, and Nausicaa is older still. o_O
Those are some fine examples of things that age well.
I love, love, LOVE Castle in the Sky. Absolutely love it. It is in my top 3, next to Spirited Away and Mononoke. It's probably tied with Howl's Moving Castle, but I'd have to put Castle in the Sky higher just because of how damned epic it gets.
 

Azure Sky

New member
Dec 17, 2009
877
0
0
RentCavalier said:
Silent Lycoris said:
In my opinion, Kiki's seemed to end well before it should have as the story was only just getting started.

As for me, my two favorite movies of all time are Ghibli's original two:
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind
Laputa: Castle in the Sky

To think I am as old as Laputa, and Nausicaa is older still. o_O
Those are some fine examples of things that age well.
I love, love, LOVE Castle in the Sky. Absolutely love it. It is in my top 3, next to Spirited Away and Mononoke. It's probably tied with Howl's Moving Castle, but I'd have to put Castle in the Sky higher just because of how damned epic it gets.
That's one thing I don't get, why does everyone put spirited away so high up, they have done better. o_O

I know it won an Oscar, but meh.
 

Anarchemitis

New member
Dec 23, 2007
9,102
0
0
Spirited Away and Mononoke are my favorites.
Miyazaki is a man for the ages alongside Hitchcock, Spielburg, Disney and Capra.
 

pigeon_of_doom

Vice-Captain Hammer
Feb 9, 2008
1,171
0
0
Vodka Dude said:
More than most things are better in an original form as apposed to something made up for future releases.

No?
I dunno about that, I mean, the people responsible for the recent localisations for the Ghbili films tend to be talented people who care about the material. Neil Gaiman with Mononoke, John Lasseter with Ponyo, sure, it may not be the same as the original but it could well be of equal or even better quality. Ok, so there may be some irritating voice actors used in order to draw in a certain audience (like Noah Cyrus and one of the Jonases for Ponyo) but original Japanese language voice track can also have annoying voice actors.

It's important to note that dubbing animated films already has a fundamental disconnection between the screen presence and the voice actor, it's not like dubbing a live-action film. The screen character and the voice actor are split anyway, so while differences in the language may pose some syncing issues, it's not quite the heresy of, say, overdubbing Mifune's parts in Seven Samurai.

With well produced localisations of animated films, I don't think the original language track can claim any superiority if the localisation is achieved competently.
 

pigeon_of_doom

Vice-Captain Hammer
Feb 9, 2008
1,171
0
0
Vodka Dude said:
We agree to disagree then. Miyazaki is the exception since Disney owns the western releases dub.

None of the Ghibli, (none of them) are more enjoyable to me in dubbed Hollywood voice overs.
I prefer watching the films with the original dubs too (although Billy Crystal as Calcifer was terrific in Howl's Moving Castle). I was just saying that, while it usually is the case that an original dub is less grating (although often our ability to judge it is extremely limited if we don't understand the language, and the sense of its superiority could be something of an illusion) it only tends to work like that in practise because of the business practises of those in animation who can afford competent localisations usually want it to be marketable towards a western younger audience too.


And I had no idea Keaton voiced Porco Rosso! Might actually have to watch the dub of that film now. I liked the other Batman in Howl's... though. Thought Bale did a good job.
 

PunkRex

New member
Feb 19, 2010
2,533
0
0
I have not seen every Studio Ghibli film, but im split on most of their movies. Princess Mononoke, Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind and Spirited Away seemed to have a real half arsed ending in my oppinion but I liked Kiki's Delivery Service and My Neighbor Totoro, The Cat Returns was great and Howl's Moving Castle was awesome. Calcifer was one of the most enjoyable characters in Anime for me.
 

RentCavalier

New member
Dec 17, 2007
334
0
0
pigeon_of_doom said:
Vodka Dude said:
We agree to disagree then. Miyazaki is the exception since Disney owns the western releases dub.

None of the Ghibli, (none of them) are more enjoyable to me in dubbed Hollywood voice overs.
I prefer watching the films with the original dubs too (although Billy Crystal as Calcifer was terrific in Howl's Moving Castle). I was just saying that, while it usually is the case that an original dub is less grating (although often our ability to judge it is extremely limited if we don't understand the language, and the sense of its superiority could be something of an illusion) it only tends to work like that in practise because of the business practises of those in animation who can afford competent localisations usually want it to be marketable towards a western younger audience too.


And I had no idea Keaton voiced Porco Rosso! Might actually have to watch the dub of that film now. I liked the other Batman in Howl's... though. Thought Bale did a good job.
I guess arguing about the dubs is better than the utterly retarded debate about whether Castle in the Sky should or should not have a soundtrack (it should).

But for the record, I've only seen the Hollywood dubs, and I have absolutely no problem with them, because Princess Mononoke had Billy Bob fucking Thorton playing a sleazy con-artist of a monk and that owns hardcore. I mean, sorry purists, but what's the problem with having talent voicing your cartoons? Considering half the VA's out there are the same three-vocal cartoon-network anime rejects, I can't really fault Ghibli for wanting to get some real actors doing the voice ACTING.
 

pigeon_of_doom

Vice-Captain Hammer
Feb 9, 2008
1,171
0
0
RentCavalier said:
I guess arguing about the dubs is better than the utterly retarded debate about whether Castle in the Sky should or should not have a soundtrack (it should).

But for the record, I've only seen the Hollywood dubs, and I have absolutely no problem with them, because Princess Mononoke had Billy Bob fucking Thorton playing a sleazy con-artist of a monk and that owns hardcore. I mean, sorry purists, but what's the problem with having talent voicing your cartoons? Considering half the VA's out there are the same three-vocal cartoon-network anime rejects, I can't really fault Ghibli for wanting to get some real actors doing the voice ACTING.
I always thought the Laputa debate concerned having the original soundtrack extended for the commercial Western release, as apparently us lot get disorientated without constant musical cues to guide emotional responses. I think the idea was to rerecord an extended soundtrack, never to remove it completely, which would have been completely moronic. I'm not entirely comfortable with changing the soundtrack to that extent anyway, but as the original composer reworked the music I don't have a problem with that, more the general reluctance to allow quiet ambient moments. I mean, Wall-E did brilliantly with a quiet opening.

I don't have a huge problem with the Hollywood dubs, as Disney tend to make decent choices (with the occasional inspired one) for the VAs. I don't like the attempt to Hollywoodise the film overall though. Kiki's Delivery Service in particularly apparently had a lot of redundant extra dialogue added merely to cover up moments of silence, and even restored Jiji's ability to talk, which is pretty unforgivable (Jiji was meant to be the immature part of Kiki, so her being incapable of communicating with it by the end was a wonderful, if slightly saddening touch).