My boyfriend and I recently sat down to watch Durarara! It is just awesome. With most anime, we are leery or watch it purely for the cute anime girls and humor. We have a couple episodes left, but it has so far had us in its grasp for the last week. It is funny, it has very memorable characters, has quality music, and has a ton of heart. We will be watching Baccano, next. I haven't watched an anime this good since Cowboy Bebop, I think.
A couple months or so ago, we watched Air Gear. It was honestly quite funny and fun, but ended horribly. It kind of left you stunned in that fashion, but the rest was pretty cool with surprising characters.
OF course, we are watching Korra and Young Justice every week. Some people have been giving Korra a large amount of flack, but we are enjoying the thing to pieces. Pieces! It feels like a breath of fresh air with some of the crap that's on the tv these days.
I force my boyfriend to watch the Avengers cartoon. It's not horrible, but it's not the greatest. It's a fun thing to put on while you are occupied a bit with something else.
We're fans of paranormal, fantasy, and horror, so we've been watching 'Lost Girl' on Scifi. It's not bad. It is pretty sexy, and decently accurate in its depictions of the Fae. During some of the sex scenes, we both had our mouths on the floor with how graphic Scifi was actually being. It's like Supernatural, but with a girl duo, a little more compelling, and honestly much better chemistry between the two girls.