Poll: Smith or Tennant? (Or Eccleston)
- Thread starter King Toasty
- Start date
Recommended Videos
Meowmeow meow, mrrrr!*Jedamethis said:
[I hope I can sneak into the TARDIS and travel to that planet where all these cat people live and find myelf a handsome tomcat]
-----------
*Oh, great! Now I can make a website about myself and how tiny & cute I am and become famous!
And I will finally become the ruler of the world because nobody would suspect a little kitten of such a evil plan!!**
**Yes, cat language is very effective. You don't need many "meow" to say a lot and one "meow" can mean a lot, it depends on the pronunciation!
Definitely David Tennant.
Tennant I felt was appropriately weepy, thought it isn't like he was that way every single episode. I believe he was like that in about 12 or so of the 47 episodes he was in. He was a little crazy, but the crazy was balanced.
Matt Smith was the craziest of all in his first season, he is mellowing out in this season which is a very smart move. Example from the first season: In "The Lodger", he exploded at a teammate before the start of the soccer game because the guy said that they were going to kill the competition, like the guy actually actually had murderous intent. The other Doctors would have known it was a figure of speech.
Also the final episodes, he was way too over the top crazy for the situation. If you ask me, they should put in some kind of story bit about how because Tennant's Doctor "didn't want to go", the regeneration some how was slightly off and that is why Smith's Doctor is as crazy as he is.
Eccleston was forced out basically because Russel T. Davies rubbed him the wrong way and vice-versa.Phishfood said:
Tennant I felt was appropriately weepy, thought it isn't like he was that way every single episode. I believe he was like that in about 12 or so of the 47 episodes he was in. He was a little crazy, but the crazy was balanced.
Matt Smith was the craziest of all in his first season, he is mellowing out in this season which is a very smart move. Example from the first season: In "The Lodger", he exploded at a teammate before the start of the soccer game because the guy said that they were going to kill the competition, like the guy actually actually had murderous intent. The other Doctors would have known it was a figure of speech.
Also the final episodes, he was way too over the top crazy for the situation. If you ask me, they should put in some kind of story bit about how because Tennant's Doctor "didn't want to go", the regeneration some how was slightly off and that is why Smith's Doctor is as crazy as he is.
David Tennant was probably the best of the three, but you gotta love Christopher Eccleston for starting it. I think he would've been better if he'd stuck around for a while. I also think the writing has gotten better since Moffat took over (not that I'm saying Davies was bad, but Moffat is incredible), which has made Matt Smith's Doctor a strong one.
In short, I can't decide. They're all good.
In short, I can't decide. They're all good.
I quite like Christopher Eccleston as the Doctor, I thought his normal seriousness really added to when he had a full on comedy moment with his massive cheesy grin :-D
David Tennant wasn't bad, but to be honest I think he overdid a lot of the acting and I found him to be a bit of a smug prick at times.
I find Matt Smith to be really good as the Doctor for the opposite reasons as Christopher Eccleston. He spends most of the time joking around and having a laugh, but when he goes serious, you can almost imagine the "evil monsters" shaking in their boots.
My order of preference is:
1 - Matt Smith
2 - Christopher Eccleston
6 - David Tennant
David Tennant wasn't bad, but to be honest I think he overdid a lot of the acting and I found him to be a bit of a smug prick at times.
I find Matt Smith to be really good as the Doctor for the opposite reasons as Christopher Eccleston. He spends most of the time joking around and having a laugh, but when he goes serious, you can almost imagine the "evil monsters" shaking in their boots.
My order of preference is:
1 - Matt Smith
2 - Christopher Eccleston
6 - David Tennant
Awww, cute little kitty. *pets*Lilitu said:
You mean Planet Catboy, or it's sister planet, Catgirl Lovers?
D: Noooooo!
*looks away for a second*
Awwww, what a cute kitty you are.
Chris was great and really helped relaunch DW didn't have enough time too really connect with though,Tennant loved him was great smart,excited,and bouncy with his age and pain just benith the surface his best bit has too be the docters rage truley he felt like an angry god.
Smith...He seems like a nice guy and I truly want too like him but I just hate his docter especially (Spoiler His so called rage on demon's run seriously Tennant could look angryier and more pained in his sleep spoiler)
Smith...He seems like a nice guy and I truly want too like him but I just hate his docter especially (Spoiler His so called rage on demon's run seriously Tennant could look angryier and more pained in his sleep spoiler)
Matt Smith, but its a real shame the writting for this season has been rubbish (for the most part) hes such a great actor but hes been given shit to work with
David Tennant by far, though Matt smith is catching up in my book. Eccleston was good but it wasn't til the second season with David that I really started to get into the show. The tenth doctor was the epitome of awesome. Christopher kind of turned me off with the constant being rude thing (though I understand why). But none of them were "bad" in my book.
