Does my point remotely resemble anything from which your rhetorical question should logically flow?TechNoFear said:So we should have stopped the automobile industry because it put saddliers/stables and horse breeders out of business?JDKJ said:But if you were the owner-operator of a recording studio, or a CD manufacturing plant, or a mom 'n' pop record store, etc., etc., forced to shutter your business because of the death of sales in recorded music, then an alternative in live music performance isn't much of an alternative.
Independent musicians can still make money if they never get a dollar from record sales (and it is now much easier to overcome their biggest problem, obscurity, than ever before).
Independent software engineers don't get paid if their software does not sell.
My point was made to illustrate the fact that for some facets of the recorded music industry, there is no viable alternate revenue stream once they fall victim to the effect of piracy.