Johnny Novgorod said:
Actually, I tried option #3 last night as I was trying to help another user on the Advice Forum. Nothing was wrong with my PS3, I just did it out of curiosity. There were no changes I could see after it finished. Only my wallpaper went back to the default background. Oh right, again, I have the slim model, not the fatty or the super slim.
Now option 4 on the other hand covers these changes:
Rebuild Database - Deletes messages, playlists, changes made on [Information] screens, trimming information for pictures in [Photo], video thumbnails, video playback history and video resume information.
This operation may take a long time depending on the type and number of data items.
The thing is, everything listed under 4 is pretty unimportant, but surely there must be too many changes than they can list online, so I wouldn't risk it. I've read that people sometimes use option 4 for performance issues, but mainly with video stored on the HDD. I would only do option 4 as a last resort.
I really do believe it has to be a disc defect. Even if it is a super slim defect, you're only having problems with that disc, so in my mind it has to be the disc. Also, when you take into account the number of people who have a super slim PS3 that
also bought the Ultimate Rapture Edition and have that problem,
then consider who would actually bother to list a problem like that online (especially Amazon where sometimes fanboys lurk in wait), I would say that the defects are out there, but they're not super common.
If they refuse to give your money back, I would insist on an exchange at the very least, but experience has shown me that once in a while some games just ship broken.