Dungeons and Dragons Online is cool. If you're willing to pay just once and then never pay for it again, Guild Wars and its expansions are great. Other than that, most of them really aren't that great. I can think of a few that are good, but they've been mentioned.
Wait, why would you arm a Pastamancer with ranged weapons? Why not go with a staff of some sort that increases your spell power?Xandus117 said:Kingdom of Loathing.
IT IS AWESOME ON SO MANY LEVELS.
It's also the only RPG where you get to play as a Pasta Mage who fights Demon Seals in a Pokemon Temple with Dual Fire Pistols.