How disappointing - I can't exactly say I was extremely excited about this, but I was hoping it would be good while not holding my breath. It's great that Lloyd is back (Have you seen him? I'm amazed he can walk on his own anymore, he looks so old and worn out!) but that's hardly enough of a draw. What I was hoping most for was some clever time-travel puzzles, but it sounds like that's not the case, at least yet. I guess I wait and see, as suggested.
What it seems like to me, though, is that Telltale is sloughing off the dead skin from their old projects and piling it up in a bin marked "Some other stuff we can make some money off of", and the pickings are getting thinner by the day. Sam and Max was fantastic, clever, well designed, and usually full of unique, bizarre puzzles. The Strong Bad games were still pretty good, not quite as good and it took a while to pick up, but they got good. I only played one Wallace and Gromit game, and it was good, but sadly it wasn't as challenging as I hoped and I got a little bored with it. Then Monkey Island... a huge disappointment, I wanted so much for it to be good, I even pre-ordered it, and I really can't bring myself to play all the games. This seems like they're just reaching now, and I'm sad.