Sacman's Sac-tastic Anime Review: Serial Experiments Lain

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
For my first attempt at reviewing an anime series, and for my 1000th post that I hit 2 months ago, I figured I would give my favorite show of all time, Serial Experiments Lain, a try. Criticisms are appreciated but remember my English isn?t the best, despite living in the U.S. for 16 years. So let?s get started.



Photoshop FTW!!!


Serial Experiments Lain (SEL for short) is a 13 episode cyberpunk/physiological thriller from 1998 that to my knowledge was only circulated once on the cable channel IFC, in America anyway. The series focuses on the title character Lain who, after the suicide of a classmate, get?s pulled into the wired, which is the collective of all communication systems into a single entity(so yeah it's the internet), where she discovers her importance in the wired and her role in the plans of, the lead designer of Internet Protocol 7, Masami Erie.
[HEADING=1]Story:[/HEADING]
The story is damn good. Unfortunately, however, it?s hard to discuss the plot without giving away spoilers or plot twists. The overarching plot is very complex and fairly difficult to understand, if you don?t pay attention. It?s not that the show is poorly written, just the opposite in fact the story is very well written its back story and intricate details are all fleshed out with exposition, most of the time, being superbly woven into the narrative. The Thing is the show doesn?t reiterate everything the viewer should already know. The story is truly something that needs some viewer input to understand but thankfully it never falls into that habit of not telling you important plot details and letting abstract pretentious symbolism do all the storytelling.

Of course being cyberpunk/psychological thriller it has symbolism, usually stemming from themes dealing with things like social isolation, mental sickness, collectivity, human nature, the role technology in society both in a technical and philosophical sense, the existence of god, and everything else Morpheus was talking about in the beginning of the Matrix. To SEL?s credit it finds a good balance to fit the symbolism in the story. The themes never affect the storytelling but always seem to be omnipresent.

[HEADING=1]Characters:[/HEADING]

As far as characters go there isn?t much to say. Other than Lain and the main Villain, Masami Eiri, there aren?t very many interesting characters. It?s also almost impossible to talk about Lain or the Eiri without giving away spoilers? so consider this a spoiler warning?




Lain is the most intriguing character in the show because she knows so little about herself, other than lies, opening a lot of room for character development and by the end of the show our understanding of just who or what Lain is has been skewed and twisted to the point of absurdity. You see, Lain is described by several people as many different things: Homunculus, software, The One (due to a spotty English dub) but she is never given a clear description we?re only given pieces and sometimes lies that we have to put together ourselves. Despite not having a clear description she is well characterized, very well developed, likeable and ultimately relatable.



Eiri was the lead designer of Internet Protocol 7, The Internet Protocol is a protocol used for communicating data across a packet-switched internetwork using the Internet Protocol Suite, also referred to as TCP/IP, But was fired by Tachibana Labs after he embedded his consciousness into the protocol in an attempt to control it and ultimately break down the barrier between the real world and the wired to usher humanity into the next stage of evolution and be herald as a god. Masami Eiri is a great villain because he has a presence before he even makes an appearance or even gets a name because there are several times when people on the wired say things like, ?There is a god here.? Giving the feeling like there is someone running the show from behind closed curtains that no one wants to acknowledge but other than that he?s a pretty standard villain you know motivated by a god complex, wants to take over the world ect.
As far as the rest of the characters go some of the side cast get to develop a decent amount in the latter half of the show but for the most part the supporting cast is forgettable I mean other thanKarl [http://img295.imageshack.us/img295/7784/motivator5a0a7307d2c45e.jpg].


[HEADING=1]Presentation:[/HEADING]


Now the first thing most people will notice is the great opening song, which is sung completely in English. The opening is the single Duvet by the British band BÔA. The song is very good, though the singer?s natural voice does give an interesting contrast to the heavy Cyberpunk themes of the show.


The next thing people will notice is that the animation is total shite on a crusty role. The low budget really shows in the animation. It?s choppy and inconsistent especially when faces get a close up then you can sit there and count the frames. On the other hand the colorful and atypical art style does a lot to distract from the bad animation. SEL has a very unique and phantasmagorical style and, due to the use of color, texture, shadows, lighting, and dynamic angles, the show really feels very surreal, almost like a dream. The art direction uses everything I learned in art class to its fullest potential to create a solid atmosphere with some truly surreal imagery while still staying true to the cyberpunk themes that are featured in the show.



The soundtrack is very nice. It contains a varied set list containing everything from jazz and blues to alternative and punk inspired guitar riffs. With such a varied soundtrack you might be unsurprised to hear then that the soundtrack is predominately featured, in which case prepare to be surprised because it isn?t. SEL uses very little music beyond the occasional night club scene or montage. Though to its credit SEL uses familiar sounds that go with the cyberpunk themes, like a computer booting up or a the humming of a generator, to help immerse the viewer into the world effectively.



[HEADING=1]In Conclusion:[/HEADING]
In spite of the bad animation Lain was easy to relate to and made up for the lack of a memorable supporting cast, the art style was unique and memorable, the soundtrack was varied and had some very good tracks, and the complexity of the story is really what made the show for me.
Serial Experiments Lain's atmosphere, themes, imagery, characters and story make it utterly unique in every sense of the word.
Serial Experiments Lain definitely is not for everyone but despite having niche appeal Serial Experiments lain is a shining example of what a truly intelligent and low budget show can be and definitely deserves a watch. Thankfully, if $70-$200 is a little more than you can afford, Funimation picked up the rights to Serial Experiments Lain and are planning to release another box set in 2011.
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
EDIT: double post teehee...
EDIT: so no need to rush it... someone will post soon...
EDIT: a little criticism would be nice... just saying I would like someones input...
 

Steppin Razor

New member
Dec 15, 2009
6,868
0
0
Pretty good review overall. Nice overview of a series that happens to be one of my favourites.

The One (due to a spotty English dub)
I only ever watched it subbed. Were there any other dodgy translations on the dub?
 

Casual Shinji

Should've gone before we left.
Legacy
Jul 18, 2009
20,455
5,278
118
I actually saw this show for the first time at a film festival in 1998.

It's a difficult show to sit through, that's for sure. And that electrical hum that you hear whenever Lain is walking outside always put me to sleep.

Good review.
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Alpha1089 said:
Pretty good review overall. Nice overview of a series that happens to be one of my favourites.

The One (due to a spotty English dub)
I only ever watched it subbed. Were there any other dodgy translations on the dub?
The Dub wasn't bad. I mean the voice acting was good but whoever wrote the first two episodes probably didn't have human contact for a good 20 years. The dialogue wasn't wrong in a technical sense but it felt dated...
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Furburt said:
Pretty well written, there. I sadly know nothing much about anime, so I can't offer my opinion on the show, but the review was easily readable and concise. Might want to leave using numerical scores though, it's better to just infer it in your writing. Otherwise, very good.
Yeah I regret using the number score afterward but it was pretty much just how much I enjoyed the show on a level from 1-10...
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Furburt said:
Sacman said:
Furburt said:
Pretty well written, there. I sadly know nothing much about anime, so I can't offer my opinion on the show, but the review was easily readable and concise. Might want to leave using numerical scores though, it's better to just infer it in your writing. Otherwise, very good.
Yeah I regret using the number score afterward but it was pretty much just how much I enjoyed the show on a level from 1-10...
Which is fine, and there's nothig really wrong in itself with the numerical score system, it's just that occasionally people write the review for the score, rather than the other way around. Two good rules of thumb are A. If you can read the review and guess the numerical score it gets without seeing it, just from how the reviewer describes it. Otherwise, it can seem jarring, and B. Don't give 10/10 unless it really is absolutely perfect in every way. Numerical scores are usually based more on the quality of the whatever than they are on how much the reviewer personally enjoyed it, or at least they should be. So if you give this 10/10, then that means that this is a perfect anime in pretty much every way, which some might dispute, and so on.

It's a bit of a minefield if handled incorrectly, and it's usually better to just skip it and finish it off with a concluding paragraph.
Yeah I think I'll get to Editing...
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Furburt said:
Sacman said:
Yeah I think I'll get to Editing...
Don't worry about it too much, I'm probably just nitpicking again. It was a very good review.
Thanks. I spent a lot of time trying to fix up the layout. at first it was like a wall of text than pictures were covering text for some reason...
 

Pink_Pirate

New member
Jul 11, 2009
414
0
0
hay dude, pretty nice review... i've seen Lain so im quite impressed you managed to give a fair and concise review without revealing almost anything about the plot. Thats also the only problem i can think of. Its nitpicking, probably, but you dont really reveal enough to get anyone interested in the show. All we know is that its good, and that you really like it, but you give very little insight into the selling point of the show, the plot. Something hard to do witout spoilers tough, so still pretty well done.
oh and also, saying most people wont like it because its to deep and complex is a big nono, it implies that you are calling people who dont like the show unsophisticated and dumb, something im sure you didint mean to imply.
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Pink_Pirate said:
hay dude, pretty nice review... i've seen Lain so im quite impressed you managed to give a fair and concise review without revealing almost anything about the plot. Thats also the only problem i can think of. Its nitpicking, probably, but you dont really reveal enough to get anyone interested in the show. All we know is that its good, and that you really like it, but you give very little insight into the selling point of the show, the plot. Something hard to do witout spoilers tough, so still pretty well done.
oh and also, saying most people wont like it because its to deep and complex is a big nono, it implies that you are calling people who dont like the show unsophisticated and dumb, something im sure you didint mean to imply.
Yeah I had a lot of trouble trying to talk about the story without giving away spoilers so I just decided to talk about the quality of the writing and the integration of the themes in the show but yeah I think it could have been better. The part where I said, "Due to the complexity of the story and the deep themes found in the series I can just about guarantee most people won't like it." I was really just trying to imply that the show has niche appeal but I guess that came out wrong...
 

Julianking93

New member
May 16, 2009
14,715
0
0
Nice review.

I've never even heard of this anime before but I like how I was still able to read and comprehend your review despite not knowing what it's about.
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Julianking93 said:
Nice review.

I've never even heard of this anime before but I like how I was still able to read and comprehend your review despite not knowing what it's about.
Thank you. Yeah I should have done a better job explaining the story but the plot twists in the latter half of the show really only left room for a vague description without spoilers...
 

Pink_Pirate

New member
Jul 11, 2009
414
0
0
Sacman said:
Pink_Pirate said:
hay dude, pretty nice review... i've seen Lain so im quite impressed you managed to give a fair and concise review without revealing almost anything about the plot. Thats also the only problem i can think of. Its nitpicking, probably, but you dont really reveal enough to get anyone interested in the show. All we know is that its good, and that you really like it, but you give very little insight into the selling point of the show, the plot. Something hard to do witout spoilers tough, so still pretty well done.
oh and also, saying most people wont like it because its to deep and complex is a big nono, it implies that you are calling people who dont like the show unsophisticated and dumb, something im sure you didint mean to imply.
Yeah I had a lot of trouble trying to talk about the story without giving away spoilers so I just decided to talk about the quality of the writing and the integration of the themes in the show but yeah I think it could have been better. The part where I said, "Due to the complexity of the story and the deep themes found in the series I can just about guarantee most people won't like it." I was really just trying to imply that the show has niche appeal but I guess that came out wrong...
yeah its fine, i doubt anybody here on the escapist would take offence to that, im just saying the wording could be taken the wrong way :p. personally i wouldnt say it the depth and complexity that gives the show its niche appeal, its more cuz its really fucking weird and just down right disturbing lol.
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Pink_Pirate said:
Sacman said:
Pink_Pirate said:
hay dude, pretty nice review... i've seen Lain so im quite impressed you managed to give a fair and concise review without revealing almost anything about the plot. Thats also the only problem i can think of. Its nitpicking, probably, but you dont really reveal enough to get anyone interested in the show. All we know is that its good, and that you really like it, but you give very little insight into the selling point of the show, the plot. Something hard to do witout spoilers tough, so still pretty well done.
oh and also, saying most people wont like it because its to deep and complex is a big nono, it implies that you are calling people who dont like the show unsophisticated and dumb, something im sure you didint mean to imply.
Yeah I had a lot of trouble trying to talk about the story without giving away spoilers so I just decided to talk about the quality of the writing and the integration of the themes in the show but yeah I think it could have been better. The part where I said, "Due to the complexity of the story and the deep themes found in the series I can just about guarantee most people won't like it." I was really just trying to imply that the show has niche appeal but I guess that came out wrong...
yeah its fine, i doubt anybody here on the escapist would take offence to that, im just saying the wording could be taken the wrong way :p. personally i wouldnt say it the depth and complexity that gives the show its niche appeal, its more cuz its really fucking weird and just down right disturbing lol.
But what would the show be if it wasn't weird and disturbing? a whole lot of computer jargon and confusion that's what... with a nice soundtrack... :^{D
 

Jack_Uzi

New member
Mar 18, 2009
1,414
0
0
Good review! Only noticed it when you gave me the link to it because of the comment I made on your avatar. I think this show was a bit daring in some ways because it is very different than all the other anime I've seen and still remains very good.
I think I figured most of this serie out, but I am not quite sure if the intention of this show corresponds to my thought about it.
I just have to love their view on how we are all connected in a spiritual way, I think so too.
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Jack_Uzi said:
Good review! Only noticed it when you gave me the link to it because of the comment I made on your avatar. I think this show was a bit daring in some ways because it is very different than all the other anime I've seen and still remains very good.
I think I figured most of this serie out, but I am not quite sure if the intention of this show corresponds to my thought about it.
I just have to love their view on how we are all connected in a spiritual way, I think so too.
Thank you. You'll figure it out it took me several watches to understand what I do now but when it comes down to it it's mostly about your own interpretation of the show.
If you liked it I'm working on another for Xam'd Lost Memories that I'll have up in a bit.