I mean sure, but that's entirely your fault for thinking A. A company is a person, B. That companies have morals, and C. Companies do or should share your morals.
That's not entirely correct. (B) I use a green energy supplier -- there's an ethical commitment there, that encourages me to use that company; (B) Fairtrade is a thing. Many companies don't have morals, absolutely, and they profit handsomely all the same (Amazon, Sports Direct, any number of fast fashion brands that pretend they have ethical supply chains), but some do, and I preferentially use those brands. Yeah, there's greenwashing and pinkwashing all over the place, and I can't devote every second of the day to tracking the supply chain of every purchase I make, but some companies do have morals. (C) They absolutely should if they want my business (which, as noted, they don't need because there's enough people who can't/won't go elsewhere). (A) This is murky in this specific case
because indie devs really are the company; like this Cawthorn guy is the face of FNAF in the same way that Schafer is the face of Double Fine, and a lot of the apparent values of a company come from those figureheads.
Also for fucks sake before FNaF Scott made children bible games that reinforced "Christian values", and an entire 2 hour animation on the "Pilgrim's Progress" a fucking batshit insane story written by a Puritan preacher on what it takes to get to Heaven. The dude wasn't hiding his political or religious views at all.
I actually didn't know anything about the guy, and I've never played any FNAF games, so while it's obvious to some, it wouldn't be to me. I can't actively research every purchase I make, I can only deal in what is generally publicly known (accepting that in this case it might have been, but I definitely was unaware).
Its the equivalent of getting mad at Smith and Wesson because you just learned they make guns. It's kinda their brand.
You say that, but you also say there's no actively anti-LGBT content in FNAF. It can't be both (unless Smith and Wesson also make bouncy castles or something?).