So School Days...Manga, Anime or the the Game?

SweetShark

Shark Girls are my Waifus
Jan 9, 2012
5,147
0
0
Simple question: I want to experience the magic I heard with the name "School Days".
But which is better? The Game, The Manga or the Anime?
Thank you.
 

WindKnight

Quiet, Odd Sort.
Legacy
Jul 8, 2009
1,828
9
43
Cephiro
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Female
Aside from not getting involved in the whole thing at all, the most satisfying and 'true ending' way for most people is to play the game aiming for the Bad End where the protagonist gets killed.

Funnily enough, a lot of straight porn focussed VN's where the porn comes before all else tend to features protagonists you hope meet a bloody Bad End.
 

Samtemdo8_v1legacy

New member
Aug 2, 2015
7,915
0
0
Neither, go read the works of Oshimi Shuzo if you want to read those "Mind-fuck" type of Mangas.

Specifically Aku no Hana and BOKU WA MARI NO NAKA.
 

SweetShark

Shark Girls are my Waifus
Jan 9, 2012
5,147
0
0
Windknight said:
Aside from not getting involved in the whole thing at all, the most satisfying and 'true ending' way for most people is to play the game aiming for the Bad End where the protagonist gets killed.

Funnily enough, a lot of straight porn focussed VN's where the porn comes before all else tend to features protagonists you hope meet a bloody Bad End.
Yeah, I wanted to be surprised myself, but as soon as wrote in search the title, I saw a specific scene......spoilericif I must say, but for that reason I am curious now.
So I guess you suggest the game then?
 

Michel Henzel

Just call me God
May 13, 2014
344
0
0
Well if you are only a little bit of a Masochist then the Anime/Manga would do fine, a bit more of a Masochist then the game, if you are a really hardcore Masochist then all of it. And not just the first game, all the games.
 

CrimsonBlaze

New member
Aug 29, 2011
2,252
0
0
Samtemdo8 said:
Neither, go read the works of Oshimi Shuzo if you want to read those "Mind-fuck" type of Mangas.

Specifically Aku no Hana and BOKU WA MARI NO NAKA.
Well...

I've read all of Aku no Hana (The Flower of Evil, for me) and it seemed to tease at some much darker themes bordering on a more supernatural element that never really came into fruition. I will agree that there is one VERY SPECIFIC mind f*** moment, but after that, it's actually a very somber read. Still fantastic, don't get me wrong.

As for Boku Wa Mari No Naka, I've read the first few chapters and wasn't really impressed. I've read other gender bender/trap mangas that were more entertaining than this, but I could be wrong. It might get better for those who stick around.

Anyway, the manga for School Days was a real mind f***, as I was genuinely surprised by the absence of its notorious bloody Bad Ending and instead a much more darker ending that comes full circle.
 

Samtemdo8_v1legacy

New member
Aug 2, 2015
7,915
0
0
CrimsonBlaze said:
Samtemdo8 said:
Neither, go read the works of Oshimi Shuzo if you want to read those "Mind-fuck" type of Mangas.

Specifically Aku no Hana and BOKU WA MARI NO NAKA.
Well...

I've read all of Aku no Hana (The Flower of Evil, for me) and it seemed to tease at some much darker themes bordering on a more supernatural element that never really came into fruition. I will agree that there is one VERY SPECIFIC mind f*** moment, but after that, it's actually a very somber read. Still fantastic, don't get me wrong.

As for Boku Wa Mari No Naka, I've read the first few chapters and wasn't really impressed. I've read other gender bender/trap mangas that were more entertaining than this, but I could be wrong. It might get better for those who stick around.

Anyway, the manga for School Days was a real mind f***, as I was genuinely surprised by the absence of its notorious bloody Bad Ending and instead a much more darker ending that comes full circle.
I am also fascinated by the recent one called Happiness which pretty much deals with Vampires.

Also what was the very specific mind fuck moment in Aku no Hana (just added in spoilers) because I think I know what you are referring to but I need confirmation.
 

Fox12

AccursedT- see you space cowboy
Jun 6, 2013
4,828
0
0
Jesus... None. Are you a masochist? Even if you are, don't watch this series. I know I'm probably making you want to watch it more, but don't. You can save yourself. You can prevent the madness. Just don't. Lock this thread. Don't look into this again. School days is like a dumpster fire filled with used condoms. Just don't.

In all seriosness, the show isn't as dark as you may think. It's mostly frustrating and boring. The only reason people know about it is because of the last five minutes of the series. It's really not worth the wait, though. There are better shows out there.
 

CrimsonBlaze

New member
Aug 29, 2011
2,252
0
0
Samtemdo8 said:
CrimsonBlaze said:
Samtemdo8 said:
Neither, go read the works of Oshimi Shuzo if you want to read those "Mind-fuck" type of Mangas.

Specifically Aku no Hana and BOKU WA MARI NO NAKA.
Well...

I've read all of Aku no Hana (The Flower of Evil, for me) and it seemed to tease at some much darker themes bordering on a more supernatural element that never really came into fruition. I will agree that there is one VERY SPECIFIC mind f*** moment, but after that, it's actually a very somber read. Still fantastic, don't get me wrong.

As for Boku Wa Mari No Naka, I've read the first few chapters and wasn't really impressed. I've read other gender bender/trap mangas that were more entertaining than this, but I could be wrong. It might get better for those who stick around.

Anyway, the manga for School Days was a real mind f***, as I was genuinely surprised by the absence of its notorious bloody Bad Ending and instead a much more darker ending that comes full circle.
I am also fascinated by the recent one called Happiness which pretty much deals with Vampires.

Also what was the very specific mind fuck moment in Aku no Hana (just added in spoilers) because I think I know what you are referring to but I need confirmation.
Yes, Happiness is also a jewel. Some of the more recent chapters are more shock value than mind f***, but it was really disturbing when those chapters were first revealed.

I'm referring to the scene where the main male protagonist is raped by his female classmate that has a crush on him because she believed that he was interested in another girl, who is slightly disturbed.
 

WindKnight

Quiet, Odd Sort.
Legacy
Jul 8, 2009
1,828
9
43
Cephiro
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Female
Fox12 said:
Jesus... None. Are you a masochist? Even if you are, don't watch this series. I know I'm probably making you want to watch it more, but don't. You can save yourself. You can prevent the madness. Just don't. Lock this thread. Don't look into this again. School days is like a dumpster fire filled with used condoms. Just don't.

In all seriosness, the show isn't as dark as you may think. It's mostly frustrating and boring. The only reason people know about it is because of the last five minutes of the series. It's really not worth the wait, though. There are better shows out there.
I think that really sums up everything related to this franchise. I mean, I only really know about the whole thing because someone posted gifs of two of the gory 'Bad Ends' from the game (the one where the one girl kills herself, and the one where she kills the other girl) and gleaned just enough details to tell myself 'nope, not ever'.
 

Fox12

AccursedT- see you space cowboy
Jun 6, 2013
4,828
0
0
Windknight said:
Fox12 said:
Jesus... None. Are you a masochist? Even if you are, don't watch this series. I know I'm probably making you want to watch it more, but don't. You can save yourself. You can prevent the madness. Just don't. Lock this thread. Don't look into this again. School days is like a dumpster fire filled with used condoms. Just don't.

In all seriosness, the show isn't as dark as you may think. It's mostly frustrating and boring. The only reason people know about it is because of the last five minutes of the series. It's really not worth the wait, though. There are better shows out there.
I think that really sums up everything related to this franchise. I mean, I only really know about the whole thing because someone posted gifs of two of the gory 'Bad Ends' from the game (the one where the one girl kills herself, and the one where she kills the other girl) and gleaned just enough details to tell myself 'nope, not ever'.
It's probably the worst anime I've ever seen. My biggest pet peeve is when the whole conflict could be solved if the characters would just talk to one another. Instead they drag the plot on for ages, with nothing happening, as the characters become more unsympathetic with time. I think that the show was trying to deconstruct the harem genre, but it was so poorly done that it alienated any possible audience it had. I'll admit, though...

I actually got up and cheared when the protagonist died. I watched the scene about five times in a row. It was extremely cathartic. It still wasn't worth watching the show, but it felt good to see him die.
 

KyuubiNoKitsune-Hime

Lolita Style, The Best Style!
Jan 12, 2010
2,151
0
0
Michel Henzel said:
Well if you are only a little bit of a Masochist then the Anime/Manga would do fine, a bit more of a Masochist then the game, if you are a really hardcore Masochist then all of it. And not just the first game, all the games.
For the truly perversely masochistic, get a bit into the story, so you can know the protagonist, then switch to the Cross-Days spin off. P.S. This is a profoundly stupid thing to do, unless you're into forced feminization and gay rape.

Fox12 said:
In all seriosness, the show isn't as dark as you may think. It's mostly frustrating and boring. The only reason people know about it is because of the last five minutes of the series. It's really not worth the wait, though. There are better shows out there.
Basically this, the whole franchise(including cross-days) is just frustration, boredom, and disturbing twists involving a seriously emotionally screwed up cast. It's like how a true anti-social hikikomori sees socialization in school and the rest of real life, plus how they think sex works. It's really just unfun with an unsatisfying pay off.
 

Michel Henzel

Just call me God
May 13, 2014
344
0
0
KyuubiNoKitsune-Hime said:
Michel Henzel said:
Well if you are only a little bit of a Masochist then the Anime/Manga would do fine, a bit more of a Masochist then the game, if you are a really hardcore Masochist then all of it. And not just the first game, all the games.
For the truly perversely masochistic, get a bit into the story, so you can know the protagonist, then switch to the Cross-Days spin off. P.S. This is a profoundly stupid thing to do, unless you're into forced feminization and gay rape.
Yes you totally should, for the MC is such a "Amazing" person that you just must get to know inside and out (pun intended)