Demons souls definitely has a massive learning curve once you get the hang of the game its not actually too hard. I suppose your experience with the game depends on what your used to, I generally play games for the story so when I started playing Demons souls I died a fair amount and there were some times where I just couldn't progress and the repeated deaths were very frustrating. On the other hand if you play every game on the maximum difficulty setting and are in it mostly for the challenge then I can see DS being a very different experience not too much different from previously played games. The main reason I would avoid DS for a new gamer is because it dosen't really allow any leeway with the controls, if your a little slow on the dodge or block your dead, Unlike say Devil may cry where on the lower settings at least the game is fairly forgiving. I recently got my girlfriend back into gaming through a combination of Okami Skyrim and portal two. Okami she loved for the art style and the combat is quite forgiving most of the time, Skyrim has an epic setting, is playable in 3rd person (which she does all the time) and on easy most enemies wont kill you outright, Portal 2 coop is great for learning more about 1st person as you play together and there are few limits on time etc. She tried Demons souls and even after becoming pretty good at skyrim okami etc was repeatedly killed on the first level due to the unforgiving nature of the game, she hasn't played it since.ExiusXavarus said:That's why I've got it in the challenges category. Although to be honest, I don't understand what everyone's problem is because neither Demon's Souls nor Dark Souls are nearly as difficult as everyone says they are. They certainly aren't easy by any means, but they aren't as controller smashingly infuriating as they're being held up as. I would indefinitely recommend Dark Souls to anyone who loves a good challenge. And the Elder Scrolls(or possibly Deus Ex: Human Revolution) are the ONLY games I would recommend that are in first person. And in Elder Scrolls you can switch to third person if you so desire.(I play in third person when I'm exploring, switch to first person when I engage in combat)Sam Warrior said:I personally would never ever introduce someone to gaming with demons souls or dark souls (though haven't played that one) being as there the sort of game which scares off experienced gamers with the difficulty at times. Unless the person to be introduced is a glutton for punishment and loves being killed I would definitely avoid those two to start with. Maybe introduce those once they were getting better at 3rd person adventure/ RPG games to show how hard/rewarding gaming can be. I just cant imagine anyone being able to get into games after having that as their first experience of it, the game is fantastic but amazingly frustrating sometimes. I agree with pretty much all your other recommendations though the Prince of persia series and DA:O are both good choices for introductions. I would be inclined to avoid first person games as a lot of people seem to have real problems with spacial awareness when they cant see their character.ExiusXavarus said:Do they like challenges? Dark Souls, Demon's Souls, Devil May Cry and Dragon's Dogma would be good choices.
If they like lots of action: (see challenging games list), Sly Cooper, Prince of Persia and Lollipop Chainsaw would all be splendid choices.
Fantasy settings? Elder Scrolls series, Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon's Dogma, White Knight Chronicles and anything in the Tales of Series would be awesome choices.
If they're major music lovers then I would recommend Guitar Hero, Band Hero, Rockband and DJ hero as pretty solid choices.
Choose something easier, more casual, first. If it's too easy for them, pick something more challenging. Too hard? Something a little bit easier with a bite would be desirable. I would first ask them what kind of setting they like. Cyberpunk, Steampunk, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, War, Medieval, that kinda stuff.