I love Gears and I love Warhammer. Yes, the people that troll the internet saying that Warhammer is a ripoff are incredibly annoying, but I do see where the reviewer is coming from. So what if the button layouts and controls are similar. Why try to create a new control setup when you have a setup from a proven franchise. It's just logical. Though, I will say that I would rather play Warhammer for the crazy insane melee system.