This Obsession With Difficulty is a Little Absurd

Drago-Morph

New member
Mar 28, 2010
284
0
0
Seriously, I just don't get it. Why are people ragging on modern games for not actively hating the player? I mean, I understand Spunk-Gargle-Wee-Wee-Games that are pretty much you on a tour of set pieces with no way to loose are too easy to the point of not being fun. I get that.

No, I'm talking about other games that people seem to criticize for being too "easy". What specifically made me agitated enough to try and get a discussion going so I could understand this phenomenon was a point made in a video I saw abut Skyrim having been made too easy. Specifically, it was heckled because quest-vital characters couldn't die and there was no way to truly fail the (hundreds of hours long) game. I mean . . . really? I just don't get it. It's preposterous.

I don't know, maybe this opinion isn't as widespread as it seems. Maybe it's just a really vocal minority that keeps shouting for the game disc to snap in half and rape your mother if you accidentally step on a tap. If that's the case, then feel free to discuss why this has become such a visible issue as of late and your own thoughts on the subject. However, if there's really a significant chunk of people out there who want to bring back the "good ol' days", I'd really like to hear why. It just doesn't make sense to me.

EDIT: Whoops, meant to post this in Gaming Discussion. My bad. Mods, feel free to move it to your heart's content.
 

geK0

New member
Jun 24, 2011
1,846
0
0
Some people just like to have a challenge.

Personally, I don't like something that's so hard that it's virtually unbeatable, but at the same time, I relly don't like just breezing through a game.
 

Keoul

New member
Apr 4, 2010
1,579
0
0
Iunno I feel a little cheated when the game is too easy...
Imagine skyrim but every monster died in one hit, how would that be fun?
There has to be a challenge, at least some difficulty for you to have fun, I think Yahtzee mentioned it in his minecraft video, it's looking back at what you accomplished and all the hard work you put in that makes the game memorable.
When I look back I don't really care about my experience in skyrim, it was fun sure but not very memorable, Rayman origins however is a game I will never forget because of the land of the livid dead.
It was ridiculously hard but because of that I will never forget that experience of beating it.

I personally see the difficulty scales as things used to introduce people to gaming, for example deus ex might have been your first video game but you wouldn't quit and get frustrated because there was an easy mode available so you can learn the ropes. Difficulty just shows how familiar you are with games.
 

Nomanslander

New member
Feb 21, 2009
2,963
0
0
danon said:
People are liking what i'm not liking thread #357385943.
Pretty much what I thought reading this.

I mean... I sorta feel like playing a game with pirates right now, would you also have a problem with me wanting that?
 

DementedSheep

New member
Jan 8, 2010
2,654
0
0
Because some people actually like a challenge, a large part of their enjoyment of a game is derived for that challenge and few modern game are providing that for them? or like that their actions in a game have some weight and come with the possibility of failure? Its not that hard to understand. A game being too easy makes it really boring. Sure you can make up for it somewhat with story and atmosphere but it wold be better to both be engaging in gameplay and everything else.

I enjoy a challenge but I'm really not a difficulty nut myself. Most modern games are fine for me.
 

TehCookie

New member
Sep 16, 2008
3,919
0
0
Why do people like difficulty? Because they like a challenge, when you finally achieve something after struggling it makes the victory that much more sweet and some people find that fun. You didn't hear the fans before since they had their games to enjoy. Now companies are trying to appeal to more people by making games easier so no matter how terrible a player is they can reach the end so the fans who want a challenge are mad they're not getting their games. Even moreso when it comes to series getting easier.
 

Drago-Morph

New member
Mar 28, 2010
284
0
0
Nomanslander said:
danon said:
People are liking what i'm not liking thread #357385943.
Pretty much what I thought reading this.

I mean... I sorta feel like playing a game with pirates right now, would you also have a problem with me wanting that?
What, are you kidding me? You really know how to misread a thread. "I am confused by your obsession to have a masochistic level of difficulty in games and don't understand why you bash games and players who don't agree" does not equate to "I don't want you to play as a pirate". I mean, for Christ's sake. I don't have a problem with people wanting challenge. And yeah, I do feel a little insulted when I'm, y'know, insulted by players who seem to think they're better because they like games that knock their teeth out if they reload. But above that I just don't get it and I'd like to know what the whole craze is about. So, no, I don't care if you want to have a heart attack playing a crazy frustrating game, or if you want to play a game as a pirate. I just want to know why you want to play these games and why you take such issue with players who don't enjoy that.

Seriously, look a bit more closely at the opening post before you decide to bash it.
 

krazykidd

New member
Mar 22, 2008
6,099
0
0
TehCookie said:
Why do people like difficulty? Because they like a challenge, when you finally achieve something after struggling it makes the victory that much more sweet and some people find that fun. You didn't hear the fans before since they had their games to enjoy. Now companies are trying to appeal to more people by making games easier so no matter how terrible a player is they can reach the end so the fans who want a challenge are mad they're not getting their games. Even moreso when it comes to series getting easier.
This . Anything easy isn't worth doing . And i like me a challenge . I like to feel like i achieved something , no matter how insignificate it is to other people . I want to feel like i was presented with a challenge , and overcame it . It's the difference between a baby walking while holding their parents hands and a baby taking his first steps alone .
 

Drago-Morph

New member
Mar 28, 2010
284
0
0
krazykidd said:
TehCookie said:
Why do people like difficulty? Because they like a challenge, when you finally achieve something after struggling it makes the victory that much more sweet and some people find that fun. You didn't hear the fans before since they had their games to enjoy. Now companies are trying to appeal to more people by making games easier so no matter how terrible a player is they can reach the end so the fans who want a challenge are mad they're not getting their games. Even moreso when it comes to series getting easier.
This . Anything easy isn't worth doing . And i like me a challenge . I like to feel like i achieved something , no matter how insignificate it is to other people . I want to feel like i was presented with a challenge , and overcame it . It's the difference between a baby walking while holding their parents hands and a baby taking his first steps alone .
Oh, I understand that perfectly. I love me some challenge, even if it's pretty ridiculous (Halo 2 solo Legendary is still one of my favorite gaming experiences of all time). I just don't get the reverence of insane difficulty.
 

Fleetfiend

New member
Jun 1, 2011
479
0
0
I do understand why people enjoy a challenge, and most of the time I'm one of those people. However, there are some games that I DON'T play for a challenge, and I won't put it on a higher difficulty.

What gets me twitching is when I hear "wow, you're playing on easy? You freaking casual." Largely because I am less casual of a gamer than 80% of the people that say that to me, which is partially shown by my desire to play a game for the story/relaxation/just plain enjoyment rather than to challenge myself alone.

Viva Pinata, for example, is not really a challenging game. However, just because I love it, I have been labelled as a "casual gamer." Which I like to think I'm not.
 

Fleetfiend

New member
Jun 1, 2011
479
0
0
Drago-Morph said:
Oh, I understand that perfectly. I love me some challenge, even if it's pretty ridiculous (Halo 2 solo Legendary is still one of my favorite gaming experiences of all time). I just don't get the reverence of insane difficulty.
It probably has a lot to do with people wanting to be able to do something that not many other people can do. So, people want to go out of their way to seem like a better gamer by sometimes playing crazy-hard games just to prove they can, and continue to want harder games to push themselves further when other catch up, etc. etc.
 

Nomanslander

New member
Feb 21, 2009
2,963
0
0
Drago-Morph said:
Nomanslander said:
danon said:
People are liking what i'm not liking thread #357385943.
Pretty much what I thought reading this.

I mean... I sorta feel like playing a game with pirates right now, would you also have a problem with me wanting that?
-I don't have a problem with people wanting challenge.

-I just want to know why you want to play these games

and

-why you take such issue with players who don't enjoy that.
-Okay, then there is no problem then.

-Well, different strokes for different folks. I can't exactly explain something to you when it's based on one's taste and preference. I don't understand why some people like racing games, but if I did, I might find myself enjoying it also. If you really want to know. I'd say play it that way, and see what enjoyment you might get out of it, if any. That's the best anyone can do trying to gain an understand someone else's reasons beyond imagining it. =/

-What makes you think I take issue if I don't see you approving something I like? And how do you imagine that I might be belittling you because of it?

Now I know, sometimes, people might get paranoid that there's someone out there criticizing them of what ever they do or don't do. And maybe you've had someone on these forums actually do that to you in a thread. But I'm not, and I don't think a lot of people that enjoy hard games are doing it either.

You're presuming too much, and if there's a real problem here, that's what I would point at. And, in the end, you can't allow yourself to care too much what other people think, anyways. From my experience, it does more harm than good.

=/
 

Drago-Morph

New member
Mar 28, 2010
284
0
0
Nomanslander said:
Drago-Morph said:
Nomanslander said:
danon said:
People are liking what i'm not liking thread #357385943.
Pretty much what I thought reading this.

I mean... I sorta feel like playing a game with pirates right now, would you also have a problem with me wanting that?
-I don't have a problem with people wanting challenge.

-I just want to know why you want to play these games

and

-why you take such issue with players who don't enjoy that.
-Okay, then there is no problem then.

-Well, different strokes for different folks. I can't exactly explain something to you when it's based on one's taste and preference. I don't understand why some people like racing games, but if I did, I might find myself enjoying it also. If you really want to know. I'd say play it that way, and see what enjoyment you might get out of it, if any. That's the best anyone can do trying to gain an understand someone else's reasons beyond imagining it. =/

-What makes you think I take issue if I don't see you approving something I like? And how do you imagine that I might be belittling you because of it?

Now I know, sometimes, people might get paranoid that there's someone out there criticizing them of what ever they do or don't do. And maybe you've had someone on these forums actually do that to you in a thread. But I'm not, and I don't think a lot of people that enjoy hard games are doing it either.

You're presuming too much, and if there's a real problem here, that's what I would point at. And, in the end, you can't allow yourself to care too much what other people think, anyways. From my experience, it does more harm than good.

=/
I'm sorry, I didn't mean you specifically. I meant "you" as in the stand-in for the type of gamer I'm describing. I almost added that to my post, but I felt I had a nice little rant going and didn't want to screw it up.

So, yeah, didn't mean that as a personal attack.
 

Smooth Operator

New member
Oct 5, 2010
8,162
0
0
Well there are two things:
- no challenge -> no payoff, greater challenge -> greater payoff
- and your sort of challenge is not my sort of challenge
 

Nomanslander

New member
Feb 21, 2009
2,963
0
0
Drago-Morph said:
I'm sorry, I didn't mean you specifically. I meant "you" as in the stand-in for the type of gamer I'm describing. I almost added that to my post, but I felt I had a nice little rant going and didn't want to screw it up.

So, yeah, didn't mean that as a personal attack.
No worries, I didn't take it a personal attack either.
 

Dr.Panties

New member
Dec 30, 2010
256
0
0
So much hyperbole in that OP. The fact is that most modern game design panders to the lazy, or to those with limited attention spans. Automation, handholding, quest markers, qte's- most of it is bullshit, designed to disempower the player, to strip control for the sake of "accessibility" and increased sales.

Where is the gratification, the satisfaction, in a game that plays itself? Sure, there are exceptions, such as games that focus on artistic aesthetic (Journey), or social interaction, but refined mechanics, challenge, and replayability are ultimately the defining aspects of a game for me. I couldn't give two sloppy turds about story or character development. I want a game to force me to improve my skills, and be satisfying in the process. It's not about a game "hating me". It's about me beating the game at its best.

This is where I derive my satisfaction as a gamer, from persisting, adapting and overcoming the toughest stuff it can throw at me. For me, a good game caters to this preference, and it is just that- a personal preference. I don't do this to perpetuate a superiority complex. I do this because I am passionate about my hobby, and appreciate the most minuscule aspects thereof. I do this for myself. I don't care what you enjoy, and won't belittle you in any way, because you also appreciate my chosen hobby on some level, and that's a good thing. Nor do you have the right to call me "absurd" or "preposterous" for the ways in which I derive my personal gaming satisfaction.

This is why "hardcore gamer" is one of the most maligned terms out there right now. If you use it to posture, to boost your own pointless little ego, you're a "poser". A "wanker". A "tryhard". A "tool". You're not a "hardcore gamer". "Hardcore gamers" do it for themselves.
 

Esotera

New member
May 5, 2011
3,400
0
0
I think anyone who complains that Skyrim is too easy and doesn't have enough of a challenge should play it on hardcore mode, where they have to snap the disc in half if they die. That way there is a real fear of not being able to complete the game and they spend all their time on that.

OT: Leave ridiculous difficulty to the past. Having an easily playable difficulty is a good thing, and being able to set it allows people who aren't otherwise good at video games learn how to play, and seasoned veterans to have a bit of a challenge.
 

Dr.Panties

New member
Dec 30, 2010
256
0
0
Esotera said:
I think anyone who complains that Skyrim is too easy and doesn't have enough of a challenge should play it on hardcore mode, where they have to snap the disc in half if they die. That way there is a real fear of not being able to complete the game and they spend all their time on that.

OT: Leave ridiculous difficulty to the past. Having an easily playable difficulty is a good thing, and being able to set it allows people who aren't otherwise good at video games learn how to play, and seasoned veterans to have a bit of a challenge.
See, half of this is bullshit. Relegating "ridiculous difficulty to the past" is exclusive (bad). Having the option to set difficulty, and having a game designed to function well at any difficulty setting, is inclusive (good). Seriously, the majority of this backlash against "hardcore gamers" should actually be aimed at the puerile egotists that misappropriate the term.
 

Tom_green_day

New member
Jan 5, 2013
1,384
0
0
I don't think that greater challenge is directly proportional to greater payoff. Take the original mass effect, if you manage to get past one incredibly hard fight (for me on ps3 anyway) then all you are rewarded with is more driving or walking round, compared with if you lower the difficulty setting then I find the combat is more fun.
Take Skyrim as you were using, I found the dungeons started to get harder as you leveled up, around level 50 I started dying to the inhabitants and later the bosses, but I didn't find that any more entertaining than running in and slaughtering them, and I got the same loot from both.
I think payoff comes from doing things your own way, like in Far Cry 3 taking over an outpost without being noticed. You aren't told how to do it, it's all up to you. In other games like CoD, GTA and like I said Mass Effect, there is only one way to do things and so there is no payoff for doing them.