Yes, I'm sure this is a complete surprise, I'm sure Tim is totally shocked... either that or this was the plan from the start...
Ohh, look at Notch, becomming rich on a game before it's even released. If people will pay for a game that isn't finished yet, I wonder if they'd pay for a game that isn't even started yet. Even better, I wonder if they'd pay for the idea of a game that isn't started yet. Hell, if people will pay for a toothbrush with a tongue scraper, then they'll pay for anything. Tim owns you now, owns you all!.
I didn't like the Kickstarter idea when the Mojang documentary came up, and I don't like it now. It's not some glorious savior for indi developers, it's a way to get you to pay for something that doesn't exist, for something that might not ever exist. Tim Shafers company is not indipendant, Mojang is not indipendant, the major factor here is the massive amount of funding they have, whether it's kickstarter, a legally binding promise, or grandma's jewelry.
I'm all for supporting someone making a game because people want it, rather than because it might make a profit - I'm completely against the idea that it's simply not enough to buy the bloody game when it's finished, we have to sponsor and mollycoddle developers these days to finish the job they started. It's getting pathetic, and it's not even a good genre for a kickstarter project. Contributers are supposed to get access to alphas, developer forum etc etc etc, all of which would just ruin the game - it's an adventure game, how much of it will be spoiled because the back doors have to be left open. I'd be happier contributing to an adventure game where absolutely nothing was divulged. Instead, your expected to pay for an adventure game before it's finished, so you can debug it and QA it, get sick of the damn game before it's even finished, and then have a warm glow at the end of it. You'd get more from Double Fine if you just ignored it totally and bought the game like a normal consumer buying from a normal developer.
Sorry Tim, sorry Fantims, sorry kickstarter, but snap the fuck out of it - wipe away the dollar signs and consider the can of worms someone just opened. Is this kickstarter horseshit going to happen with more games? - are we really expected to pay for a game to perhaps be made! - WTF? - that's not a new and inventive market strategy, that's downright consumer rape.