I just couldn't get into the first torchlight, I really really wanted to (it had been years since I played a crawler) but for whatever reason I just could not get excited about playing it.
I even modded the hell out of it to give me more pets/items/difficulty/monsters but it just didn't draw me in like I had hoped. Honestly I didn't even know the story, something about monsters or something.
Which was disappointing at the time but now I have Diablo 3 which scratches my itch.
Captch: higgledy-piggledy (what the hell?)
EDIT:
Soopy said:
Might be just the art style?
Different strokes for different folks I guess.
could be, I'd hate to think it was though. I'm not particularly picky about art or graphics in games.
I even enjoy colourful games like Katamari