epsilon246 said:
I am Jack said:
Okay... let's not get ahead of ourselves.
A while back i tried to make it through the first book. everybody had told me it was a complete trashing of the vampire mythos (and it tottaly was). I got about 60 pages into that gorram thing and i could already feel my brain rotting
first off.
Seduction has ALWAYS been a part of Vampire lore. this is why vampires are so closly tied to sex .Most of the darker vampire stuff involves a vampire charming a girl taking her home and getting busy before sucking her blood and killing(or turing her)
So vampires being charming, ladys men was around way before Myers vommited all over it
and
reworking mythos is what keeps It so intresting. Vampires have been reworked in alot of ways(probably more then any other Mythological crature)
Let's Say you are putting a vampire in the book you are writting
is your vampire undead, or still alive. does he turn to into one bat, or alot of bats, or no bats at all. does he slowly die slowly in the sun, or does he burn up instantly. hell some even just simply become weaker in the son.
Why do they suck blood. do they have some sort of anemic condition where they lack iron, or are they actually just sucking the "life force"
I could go on and on
want me to run through the checklist of things that may or may not kill/harm your vampire(if anything).
I guess my point is we can't hate on her for trying to change vampires. all though myers was a dead shitty end. could you imagine how bored we would all be of vampires if they were still like dracula.
Now onto what we can hate. her boring ploting, her boring, flat, static characters. Her terrible detailing... Etc. I hate these books just as much as any of you. this book especially has made other lonely female authors start rushing out more of the same. I really wish they were not in exsitence
She then kills all that by making them sparkle, vampires don't need to be hurt by the sun but there is one key aspect of the mythos in all iterations they are creatures of the night and they detest the sun (especially aparent if they aren't vulnerable to it). Vampire mythos may be wide and varied, but this doesn't even come close. Never mind her attempting and failing miserably to justify the sparkles with science, which is my major bugbear with the series. I'm not going to go into detail but by trying (and failing) to apply science to one aspect of a supernatural creature you have to apply it to the rest of the aspects which becomes even more screwy. btw didn't intend to rant just kinda happened
I agree with everything you said really. Like i said i think her reworking was a "dead shitty end"
Mythos changes alot but. there is only so many changes you can make to a fish before it is no longer a fish
overall vampires have two strong characteristics that is the core.
A overwhelming urge for blood
and detest for the sun(for whatever reason)
and thank you for bringing up the whole science thing. I always loved when science is thrown into mythos. when people started doing this, the most notable change to vampire lore, specificly was instead of the vampire sucking your blood to give you the condition you had to drink it's blood. WHich if you go science route, Makes a hell of alot more sence. another notable change was that two things, holy water and crosses are now all but useless in vampire lore. even the more magic based stuff has scraped this because at then end of the day that particular part. MAKES NO SENCE.
less sence then sucking blood for a "life force"
(but like you said it's an all in or go home thing. If you use science once. use it everywhere. another thing myers failed at)
and that leads back to my point. some time stuff gets scraped because it makes no sence, and a cross, and holy water) no longer makes sence in this far less catholic(percentage wise)and far more science based westren culture. and some stuff gets added because it makes sence.A vampire lacking iron, makes tons of sence. Pale skin, desire for blood ect ect.
people are at myers throat because she "changed vampires". thats a bit to brod. yes hate her for turning vampires into "mopey solor powerd disco balls" but dont hate her for attempting to change because thats how mythos stays intresting