Blackout62 said:
Fat_Hippo said:
Don Reba said:
- I have to ask my mom?
- I asked your mom last night. She said, "yeah baby, don't stop."
That would have better suited Phil's character.
This is the dissonance almost any piece of media featuring kids in the "10 to 16 years old" bracket has to endure, because to have those kids talking the way they really do would be far too cringe-inducing. If the dialogue in say, Harry Potter, had been anywhere near the real thing, the sheer amount of dick and "your mom" jokes made between Harry and Ron would have anyone tossing the book out within minutes.
And that's exactly what made Super 8 brilliant.
True, Super 8's best moments were definitely when it was being funny and telling the down to earth story of these kids making a movie, telling dumb jokes and dealing with their problems...but the dramatic parts were merely okay, and kinda pulled the movie down a bit for me, though I still liked it.
It seems like it's very difficult to mix "realistic" teenagers with drama that doesn't fall flat, so you either go full hog "inappropriate" (Superbad, for example) or you create the version of what parents wish teenagers were like (Harry Potter, Percy Jackson etc.). I'm not saying it's impossible, mind you, I just haven't seen anything which managed to pull of the correct tone (or tonal shifts, really) necessary for this kind of movie.