Ways that Oblivion is superior to Skyrim
- Thread starter Epona
- Start date
Recommended Videos
Well no, it could still be the fault of the programmers or the engine not working well with the PS3. It would be the fault of the PS3 if other games on other engines programmed by other people has the same problem. Does it?Irony said:
It's not a problem that is consistent on the PS3. My save file is closing in on 9MB and I have no problems with the game. I haven't got a clue why some have issues on PS3 and some don't. I'd like to know though. So all you wise people out there, please explain...Crono1973 said:
We can't, ask Bethesda to explain. After 4 games with this problem, I am beginning to think they don't know how to fix it. With so many multi-platform games on the market, do other games not made by Bethesda or not made on the gamebryo engine have these problems?Jack Rascal said:
Well considering that Oblivion has ass looking armour, ass looking character models, pansy looking orcs, no children ANYWHERE(creepy as fuck, seriously, people in oblivion must have reproduced via cell division...), no facial hair(why oh why couldn't i ever give my nord character a beard?) without a mod for it, a story line that i still have yet to complete even once in the 8 times I TRIED to play through it but got so damn bored I found myself washing dishes and didn't remember getting up from my desk, oh and if your reticul area right in the center of your screen wasn't over an enemy your big solid warhammer would clip THROUGH enemies as if you'd mised them completely doing no damage, that and thea acrobatics and athletics skills leting my heavy armour wearing, beardless nord character run so fast I never bothered with a horse, and jump over houses, once I got it high enough.
I guess I do find the far better looking armour, far better looking character models, orcish looking orcs, the existence of an obvious visual difference in people's offspring, the fact that people in skyrim have apparently not been mutated out of the ability to grow facial hair, the fact that the story line isn't just a bunch of samey fetch quests followed by playing babysitter a bunch, and faffing about in hell closing a lot of doors kinda better, and the fact that your weapons CONNECT with enemies unless you do truly miss them is kinda nice as well, athletics and acrobatics aren't around to break my character and turn him into something resembling an overcaffeinated birdsquirrel is nice too, combat got kinda hard in oblivion when every time I so much as twitched to avoid a power attack I ended up in another town.
Also, daggers, you CAN kill people with them propperly now... in oblivion it always felt like you were trying to kill them with a spoon most of the time, after all just having my character with his darkl brotherhood issued armour and a high enough sneak skill with the right perks lets me sneak up behind people and slit their fucking throats now, like a real assasin would, not just kinda poke them 50-60 times till they give up or kill me in the process... cuz with all things said and done, if you have a dagger, and high sneak skill and the gloves the dark brotherhood give you, your backstab type sneak attacks do 30x damage, as opposed to barely any... and daggers also have a much higher base damage than they did in oblivion I find...
And dual wielding magic thusly allowing you to have more than one spell equipped at once
or dual cast the same one for more power, allowing you to have a ward up and cast lightning at someone simultainiously is just fun.
But yeah weak gameplay, horrible story, and ass looking people, aside I can really see so much about oblivion that is better! *sarcasm so heavy that it could sink a boat*
I guess I do find the far better looking armour, far better looking character models, orcish looking orcs, the existence of an obvious visual difference in people's offspring, the fact that people in skyrim have apparently not been mutated out of the ability to grow facial hair, the fact that the story line isn't just a bunch of samey fetch quests followed by playing babysitter a bunch, and faffing about in hell closing a lot of doors kinda better, and the fact that your weapons CONNECT with enemies unless you do truly miss them is kinda nice as well, athletics and acrobatics aren't around to break my character and turn him into something resembling an overcaffeinated birdsquirrel is nice too, combat got kinda hard in oblivion when every time I so much as twitched to avoid a power attack I ended up in another town.
Also, daggers, you CAN kill people with them propperly now... in oblivion it always felt like you were trying to kill them with a spoon most of the time, after all just having my character with his darkl brotherhood issued armour and a high enough sneak skill with the right perks lets me sneak up behind people and slit their fucking throats now, like a real assasin would, not just kinda poke them 50-60 times till they give up or kill me in the process... cuz with all things said and done, if you have a dagger, and high sneak skill and the gloves the dark brotherhood give you, your backstab type sneak attacks do 30x damage, as opposed to barely any... and daggers also have a much higher base damage than they did in oblivion I find...
And dual wielding magic thusly allowing you to have more than one spell equipped at once
or dual cast the same one for more power, allowing you to have a ward up and cast lightning at someone simultainiously is just fun.
But yeah weak gameplay, horrible story, and ass looking people, aside I can really see so much about oblivion that is better! *sarcasm so heavy that it could sink a boat*
The absence of open lock and chameleon annoy me, but for me almost everything else in Skyrim is superior including the UI
I loved Oblivion with all my heart it was my second favorite game of all time. I loved every aspect of it, and not even the sucky animations and roboty NPCs turned me off one bit. It's become third though, cause Skyrim blew my socks of with amazement. I had very high expectations for Skyrim, and I can honestly say I was positively surprized.
Skyrim is not a numbers game though. If your into a game for the numbers, this is not the game for you. It's about the amazing stories in an equally amazing world, with a large variety of quests, engaging and thrilling combat and a simple-to-use interface and control setup that enabled two non-gamer friends of mine to pick up a controller and have fun after only a few minutes. Even my uncle had a go and managed to fight his way trough the tutorial without getting killed, and he as NO gaming experience beyond the occasional game he has with his son and daugther on their Wii.
I think maybe some people do not like that Skyrim has become more "available", and interesting to many more people. In my opinion they truly did take The Elder Scrolls to a new and interesting level, and I think that's just great. I cannot wait for the next one.
Just look at the magic of Oblivion... Then look at Skyrims... Better, play some Oblivion, then play some Skyrim just after. The improvement really is massive. I can't talk for console users though, I play my games on PC.
Skyrim is not a numbers game though. If your into a game for the numbers, this is not the game for you. It's about the amazing stories in an equally amazing world, with a large variety of quests, engaging and thrilling combat and a simple-to-use interface and control setup that enabled two non-gamer friends of mine to pick up a controller and have fun after only a few minutes. Even my uncle had a go and managed to fight his way trough the tutorial without getting killed, and he as NO gaming experience beyond the occasional game he has with his son and daugther on their Wii.
I think maybe some people do not like that Skyrim has become more "available", and interesting to many more people. In my opinion they truly did take The Elder Scrolls to a new and interesting level, and I think that's just great. I cannot wait for the next one.
What a painfull boring way to see a game world, by the numbers. No wonder some people do not care for the visuals Oo.Crono1973 said:
This I can't understand. What could possibly be more "realistic fantasy" than flipping dragons! They are the deity of fantasy! Big machineguns would draw in the kids... Dragons draw in fantasy geeks, big and small, and I think thats wonderful. Skyrim has made the stunning world of The Elder Scrolls series seem more available to the general public, and only the "CoD sucks BECAUSE it's popular" people are the only people that could possibly be viewing this as a bad thing... The game is still packed with variety of content, the stories are as good if not better than the Oblivion ones, the world feels more alive and fluent, combat is pure awesome as a close combat, magic or bow user, leveling and skills are far easier to comprehend and keep track of for new and old players alike. Oblivions "touch of realism" combat-wise always came from adjusting the dificulty slider to suit you... The inclusion of dragons, the simpler but frankly better UI and stunning visuals has taken nothing from what previous TES games had in terms of story and intrigue, and I personally think it's by far the best TES game made all in all.Enverex said:
Just look at the magic of Oblivion... Then look at Skyrims... Better, play some Oblivion, then play some Skyrim just after. The improvement really is massive. I can't talk for console users though, I play my games on PC.
The following text is an opinion and nothing more.Crono1973 said:
I feel Skyrim was vastly superior and lived up to everything it claimed to do.
-Have already felt far more immersed then I did in Oblivion
-Getting rid of Major/Minor skills was a great idea. Having your character mould into what class you want them based on how you play versus making a preset I thought was brilliant.
-Perk tree rather then 4 upgrades to a skill ar 25-50-75-100 is much nicer.
-Finishing moves are awesome
-Smithing was an excellent and interesting thing to add
-Sneak and being an assassin character works now and is tons of fun. Playing as one as I never could in oblivion, quite literally slitting everyones throats never gets old.
-By UI I'm going to take a guess you mean Updated Interface? If I am assuming correctly, my opinion on the interface is while I agree it's dumb you can't see yourself equiping things, it shows what your equipping in great detail rather then a symbol and a name beside it. Besides, I also play in third person so I don't really care too much. And I can always snap to third person and look at myself if I so desire.
-As well, everything is sorted much better, the favourites menu works great, and I find myself grabbing and equipping much faster then I did in Oblivion with getting rid of the clusterfuck of menu pages.
-Fighting looks and feels much better. the cutting animations and the whole screen swaying as you swing a 2 handed sword feels far more real and the blood that splatters everywhere when you land a hit is greatly satisfying.
-There are more then like, 3 voice actors now. Everyone sounds pretty awesome.
-On that note, I enjoy the camera not zooming in on their expressionless face.
-Khajits actually look like cat people now. Not humans with face paint.
-The amount of things to do is overwhelming. Quests are endless don't feel quite as repetative. Still are to a degree, not as much though.
-Fixing dungeons so that they all look quite different and have a start and a finish is a nice touch.
-I am going to have to mention that the dragons are awesome. Having them swoop down over you without warning and knowing your in for a fight is exciting.
-The terrain looks different in lots of places with having snowy mountain paths, tundra, swamps and forests to explore instead of a giant green meadow to aimlessly walk around in. Although I will credit Oblivion on doing a fantastic job with Shivering Isles.
-I disagree with the character creator being worse. It's not better, but it's not worse. I do enjoy having scars, war paint and multicolored eyes though.
-Making the stamina bar actually have a huge signifigance was a nice idea as well.
-Sprinting.
-Having sustained destruction spells instead of just projectiles.
-Magic is also much more effective, even at beginner levels. I liked the healing spell still
being able to heal me plenty even at level 20.
-It's pretty trivial but getting married was an interesting thing to throw in.
-
You can become a Werewolf as an alternative to vampireism.
The game is still not without its flaws though.
-Being a 360 player I get a lot of textures not loading completley.
-I do think they should have kept acrobatics because I liked having dodge manuevers.
-They should have kept spell creation
-No fighting colluseum that I have found yet.
-Vendors still suck and never have new things for you to buy. They are always a tier behind what you have when you go to see them.
I don't really care about dragons in Skyrim. Sure, they were fun the first few times, but imo they can get really annoying sometimes.
Both games had their good points and bad points. I prefer Skyrim personally though.
Both games had their good points and bad points. I prefer Skyrim personally though.
Yeah, the way the game handles Smithing EXP is really weird. It's not fun having to grind like all of those daggers simply to level up, as it really isn't feasible to max the level up by playing it normally.Fawxy said:
For some reason I could just never get into Oblivion. I would just quit after a half an hour every time I tried. However, with Skyrim, I have the same feeling I had with Fallout 3. I just can't put the game down.
For me it comes down to one simple factor. Skyrim engaged me and I actually found myself enjoying the combat. Oblivion did neither of those things for me. Also I actually felt like a real legendary hero in Skyrim while in Oblivion I felt my role could have been taken by any good adventurer. Oh and when I levelled up the fact that I could kill earlier monsters easier actually made me feel like I was getting stronger while in Oblivion I felt like some average mook who constantly got his ass kicked. I really don't mind the dumbing down so much because it simplifies a lot of things that I thought were a bit too complex in Oblivion. At the end of the day I just have more fun with Skyrim.
I feel the same. The thing about Skyrim is it makes you feel like you're fulfilling you destiny while Oblivion is more like helping someone else to fulfil their destiny.Joel Dawson said:
The only thing I can give Oblivion over Skyrim is no giant spiders. Apart from that I'm not really sure.
However as an arachnophobia the lack of spiders is a big plus in Oblivions book for me.
captcha: Sausage-peg. kshobi
However as an arachnophobia the lack of spiders is a big plus in Oblivions book for me.
captcha: Sausage-peg. kshobi
Skyrim's Guild quests aren't nearly as long or good as Oblivion's. The Dark Brotherhood in particular is a lot less interesting, and the College of Winterhold in particular is a lot shorter.
In fact, Skyrim's quests in general are just unappealing. They're nearly all fetch quests, and always send you to the opposite side of the country. The "Radiant" quests in particular are deathly dull.
Only Skyrim's main quest is better than Oblivion's...and it's shorter also. Although admittedly, a lot of Oblivion's MQ length came from stupid stuff like touring Cyrodiil's cities closing horrible Oblivion gates or picking up components for Martin's portal spell, so maybe that's a good thing.
There is also the sorely missed spellmaking, but I'm sure that's been mentioned several times throughout this thread.
That being said, Skyrim has much better combat, much better aesthetic, and MUCH better overworld and dungeons, so overall I'd probably name it the superior game. But its quests suck.
In fact, Skyrim's quests in general are just unappealing. They're nearly all fetch quests, and always send you to the opposite side of the country. The "Radiant" quests in particular are deathly dull.
Only Skyrim's main quest is better than Oblivion's...and it's shorter also. Although admittedly, a lot of Oblivion's MQ length came from stupid stuff like touring Cyrodiil's cities closing horrible Oblivion gates or picking up components for Martin's portal spell, so maybe that's a good thing.
There is also the sorely missed spellmaking, but I'm sure that's been mentioned several times throughout this thread.
That being said, Skyrim has much better combat, much better aesthetic, and MUCH better overworld and dungeons, so overall I'd probably name it the superior game. But its quests suck.
Boy, what an intelligent and well thought-out response. I guess I have no - OH WAIT! I preemptively responded to that already.Crono1973 said:
"Sure, I could hotkey it (360) but that's a spot that could be used for my chameleon spell which doesn't make much sense considering I could just use invisibility."
360 had eight hotkeys. My battlemage needed all of them for different things.
No, I didn't drop off keys. There was no reason to aside from storage, and then you still have to figure out which keys you need.
What a delightful strawman on your part to undermine my ethos: I didn't store keys therefore I don't know enough about Oblivion. Yes, that's an adequate to response to every refute to you I made.
In response to your other comment, I'm on the 360 genius.
Oblivion is not superior to Skyrim, in any way save for having more Argonians/Khajit.
HA! Aren't I'm smart! I am a P.C. gmaer and was syked for skyrim, and after I saw the gameplay videos I KNEW the UI was going to be shit for P.C. and the game was pretty much designed for the xbox 360 so i decided to get the best out of the game and bought it for the 360 and I have to say that I have had no problems whatsoever and I like it a hell of alot more than oblivion And the only thing I didn't like was the 3D map.
