I wanted to post a reply in my own thread, but have been strapped for time?.
Ok hear me out. Fandoms, ESPECIALLY online fandoms, by their nature can be and are pretty horrible. For every even-headed, content fan of any game or franchise out there, there exists a fan who takes their fixation to an obnoxious and unhealthy new level.
Ok... so these particular fanbases I wanted to talk about are:
Halo. I would say the Xbox Live userbase in general, but Call of Duty and Halo is where the worst of the userbase is concentrated at. I am aware that there are gamers playing online that are out to just have fun and meet good players and all, but that hope is almost always dashed the moment I log into a game and hear some 20 or 30 something manchild screaming obscenities, swears, and taunts over the microphone in order to assert some perceived alpha-male status. Nevermind about the players who insist that the "best" way to play the games and scoff at you for not playing like a "professional". Despite my personal gripes with Halo and CoD players that suck the fun out of playing the games, they're not as obnoxious as the below fanbases and at least tend to be more silent and agree more often with the single-player modes.
The Legend of Zelda. I would say Nintendo fans of MANY of the franchises they've produced can be dickish in general, but these strike me as what may possibly be the worst. Why? Because the worst fans seemingly make demands to Nintendo like spoiled, bratty children and demand that the next Zelda game would be exactly as they ask for, only to accentuate the negative and go back and complain that it either isn't like their beloved Ocarina of Time, or too much like Ocarina of Time, or just too samish as the other Zelda games. Nevermind that there's never been a truly bad Zelda game (No! The CDi games DO NOT COUNT!) or that the franchise has stood tall for 25 years as of now with memorable experiences and innovations. These fans exist to complain...
On the flipside of this coin; three words: "Eight point Eight". Woe betide any game reviewer that DARES to give a hyped Zelda game a "low" review score. *COUGH* Gamespot twice *COUGH*. Any reviewer that does opens an insane backlash of hyper-defensive Zelda fans that feel they should defend their game. Hell, anyone who says anything negative about a Zelda game, (Especially Ocarine of Time) would be meet with derision and wrath from Zelda fanboys.
Final Fantasy. Once again... I would say the entire company has a rather obnoxious fanbase but this one in particular is what takes the cake. I've never seen games that get people this passionate and this vocal about their displeasure. I'm still just flabbergasted as to how it is hard to find individuals who want to talk about any of the older games without being taken by weepy-eyed nostalgia or the recent games without exaggerating the negative and declaring that they're not "true" Final Fantasy games. Deciding what a "true" Final Fantasy game is actually harder than it sounds because each installment (Minus the spin-offs and sequels to pre-existing installments, but even then...) is very different from their predecessors, starring a different cast, a different setting, a normally self-contained story, and usually a different combat system. It's hard to find a fan that has played them all and liked them all...
But once again... why so much emotion? To my knowledge, there haven't beeen that many truly bad Final Fantasy games, and even the ones that a person will dislike has something good in them... (Though ALL Final Fantasy games have GREAT music!... You should never argue with that)
Sonic the Hedgehog. Yes. EVERYONE saw this coming. It's common knowledge right now that Sonic's fanbase is absolutely wretched. This article sums up everything you guys need to know about Sonic?s ?fanbase? and their tendencies towards incessant and histrionic whining over EVERY. GODDAMN. INDIVIDUAL. CHANGE! (AHEM Green Eyes)
http://gamebabble.wordpress.com/2010/02/22/sonic-and-the-worst-fandom-ever/
I do realize that it is a vocal minority?but it is the loudest goddamn vocal minority I?ve ever seen! Webcomics, blogs, YouTube videos, and even gaming reviewers and journalists are not safe from this minority. It?s like it?s not cool at all to say you?re a Sonic fan?
There is a fandom that I think is worse than Sonic?s? I?ll get to that soon enough.