Argh, I mixed up two of my ideas. Let me try again here:Redlin5 said:The thing is even one month of inaction in a thread leads it off of page 20 in the forums index. When it passes page 20 reviving the thread more or less becomes necromancy. In my eyes and some mods eyes anyway. So I think the cool down period needs to be a lot faster. I don't know how one would code that into the site.
But yes, you are right, the cooldown time is too long. Seems I went overboard on the side of caution, so let me propose a newer version: 3 days - Down one notch. 1 ½ week - Down to zero.Hjalmar said:If the thread is left alone for two weeks or so the thread temp is lowered one notch, and if it stays on that track for an additional month the temp will be lowered to grade 1 again. If no one posts in the thread in month and a half, the temp will lowered to zero, effectively making it "dead," if you will.
If the thread cools down anyway while getting fresh posts the thermometer would be lowered accordingly, manually.
Well, that is a reason why I wouldn't want users fiddling with it. And yes, I did know about mods having a tough schedule.The other thing is that the mods do have lives outside of the Escapist (shocking, I know!) and tackling the report queue on a bad day here must be a nightmare as it is. They aren't paid to do this and some are taking university classes IRL. Adding to their duties might lead to the report queue getting less attention and that means things will slide past them for longer before they catch up. I don't have doubts about the work ethic of our mods, I just think adding to their duties is asking a lot of them. I honestly think having it user powered would be the way to go but I don't know the right way to go about it.
I like the idea but I think it'll need a lot of work before implementation. I foresee people using it to target OPs they don't like by spamming the gauge mechanism or whatever. I have little faith in people not abusing things for the sake of trolling.
Maybe tomorrow, you did get me thinking about some other things that requires some more thought.But that's my thought on the matter. I suggest you talk to Mods and Staff if you want to draft a serious proposal about it.