The Little Mermaid III: Ariel's Beginning (7/10)
You read that right. LM3 just about manages to be a "good" film, which means that by my reckoning, it's better than the two preceeding it. Not that I liked either of those two, as my reviews show, but I really wasn't expecting this.
The story starts a decade before the main story, where Triton's wife is killed by a human pirate ship (yes, killed, there's no ambiguity), with Ariel being about 4 years old at this point. Because of this, he bans music in Atlantica. Cut forward ten years later, and everyone, not just Ariel and her sisters, are miserable, and Triton's still deep in depression.
To be clear, the whole "no music allowed" thing is fairly silly, even if it does make sense in context to a point (since Triton's wife was trying to save a music box when the ship killed her). Also, I'm not going to claim that this is an in-depth look at depression. However, I will give the movie some credit for handling the subject the way it does when it comes to Triton, since everything from his animation to his voice acting conveys the idea that this is a man who's dead inside, consumed with grief. Similarly, while none of Ariel's sisters have characterization that goes beyond "the strict one," "the funny one," "the vain one," etc., I will give the movie some credit for providing characterization at all - enough to elicit a few sniggers from me at times. This might be me being biaised (in case you're wondering, the reason I'm watching LM stuff right now is because one of my writing projects is a LM story), but there's some moments between Ariel and Attina (Triton's eldest daughter) that do at least touch on 'the feels,' with Attina being forced to look after her sisters, while Ariel morosely comments that as the youngest daughter, she knew her mother the least out of all of them.
Also, Marina (the girls' governess) is a hoot, and so is her dugong assistant. 'Nuff said.
Anyway, because this is still a movie about music being banned, Ariel ends up meeting Flounder (who incidentally is a better character here than the original movie), one thing leads to another, and she ends up in an underground (undersea?) music gig, where shock of all shocks, Sebastian is the main singer, despite him otherwise toeing the line on Triton's "no music allowed" edict. I should comment at this point that despite this film's focus on the whole music angle, there isn't a single song from said film that I can remember. Despite my gripes with the first film, all of its songs were solid, and I can at least remember the songs of the second, even if they were generic as a stunned mullet. But quality of the songs aside, the animation is good (surprisingly good for a direct-to-DVD film), Ariel brings her sisters into the club, but they're found out, and thus confined to the palace, which causes a rift between her and the rest of them, exemplified in this exchange:
Ariel: "I just wanted us to be happy."
Attina: "Look around you, Ariel. No-one is happy."
Not exactly Shakespeare, but I'll actually take this over Ariel's "I'm going to pursue a man I barely know and leave my whole world behind and risk everything in the process." Actually, that does tie in with why I like this movie more, namely that I find the core conflict more engaging than the first film (familial loss, depression). Odd that Ariel, who's two years younger here than in LM1, is a more mature individual than in the first film.
Anyway, Ariel, having reached breaking point, springs Sebastian, Flounder, and the other captured members of the music club, and they head out beyond the borders to be free to perform music. And by that, that means entering the undersea equivalent of a desert (presumably this means further out into open sea, where biodiversity is much lower). Marina sends her electric eels after them because...reasons (there is a reason, I just can't remember what it is), and Sebastian reveals that he's taken them to where the music box of Ariel's mother is located. The idea being that if Ariel can play it in front of her father, his heart will soften. On the way back, they're attacked by Marina's eels, and while they defeat them, Ariel is injured. Seeing this, and with the music box playing, Triton's heart is softened. Music is allowed to return, Sebastian is made court composer, and Ariel and her father dance for the first time in ten years.
So, that's LM3, and yes, I stand by my belief that this is a superior film to the first one. While there's a lot of generic, even silly elements, this is compounded by the fact that this is actually the funniest LM film, yet despite the comedy, I think the core premise is actually the most engaging. While it's hardly an in-depth (deep? Undersea?) look at depression and family loss, it does pull off these elements reasonably well. As silly as the whole music ban is on the surface, considering where it's coming from, it does make Triton's actions understandable in the context of his grief. And again, Ariel's a far more likable protagonist here than the borderline ditz she was in the first film. Controversial opinion, I'm sure, but it's mine all the same.
Anyway, DisneyToon rankings are below:
5) Peter Pan: Return to Neverland
4) The Little Mermaid II: Return to the Sea
3) The Little Mermaid III: Ariel’s Beginning
2) Aladdin: The Return of Jaffar
1) The Lion King II: Simba’s Pride