Warhammer 40,000: The Horus Heresy - The Solar War (3/5)
Before anyone asks, no, I have not read the preceeding 50+ books, only a handful. Read this because it was on the shelf.
Anyway, I'm really mixed about this book. There's stuff I like, there's stuff I don't like, and while that's true of practically every work in existence, the problem is that the stuff I don't like is what the book spends the most time on, and vice versa. Specifically:
-The book is part of the Siege of Terra sub-series within the Horus Heresy series (in turn a sub-series of 40K), and the first installment of the Siege series. It covers the events from the entry of the Traitor Legions and accompanying forces into the Sol system, and ends with said Legions gaining orbital supremacy over Terra (to quote a line, "on the 13th of Secundus, the bombardment began"). In essence, it's close to 400 pages of what's essentially one big space battle taking place across almost the entire Sol system. Which means, at least to me, a lot of it is as boring as fuck. Yeah, shock of all shocks, I'm not generally that fond of reading action scenes in books, and I'm even less fond of writing them. There's exceptions, of course, but the fine edge the book has to toe is to keep the action large enough that it fits the setting (millions of people dying by the second, entire moons of gas giants destroyed, etc.), it also has to keep the stakes real, and it doesn't always do that. There's only so much carnage I can read before my eyes glaze over.
-There's certainly exceptions to the above gripe, granted. For instance, the strategy that the Traitor legions use plays out well enough - attack conventionally at first, then use a ritual that opens a warp rift above Terra, so that the bulk of their forces can get to Earth instantly rather than passing through the Sol system and its warp gates. Something that's made clear is that the Imperium is still (more or less) fighting a war that they expect to be conducted under the laws of physics as they understand them, but with Chaos, that ain't happening. In other examples, it does a decent job of conveying how much life sucks for your average joe, even on Terra (your homeworld's shit, the Imperium is a tyranny, you're going to die horribly and be among millions to do so), and mention how space battles seen from a distance appear like motes of light, but like I said, these are exceptions. If you want a better example of the Sol system being a battleground, I'd strongly recommend the Second Formic War series (where's book 3, damn it?) - both series/books have a solid grasp of space combat, but the action is so over the top here, it hinders investment, whereas in the Enderverse, the smaller scale allows things to be more intimiate.
-Getting onto the stuff I like, as I mentioned earlier, it's fairly incidental to the main focus. Something the book does well is, even if it's by exposition and/or proxy, is flesh out the cultures of the Sol system. This is, after all, the 31st millennium, with humanity reunited after 5000 years of Long Night, and where FTL travel wasn't achieved until around the 15th millennium IIRC. Ergo, the planets of Sol have had time to build up individual cultures, and while most of those elements are seen through the lenses of military/action, it does a good job of conveying size and scale. Within 40K, Mars is fairly well known as being the seat of the Mechanicum for instance, but we get similar treatment for the outer planets as well, not to mention the gene-cults of Luna. Again, it's not as fleshed out as, say, the Expanse (with the cultures of Earth, Mars, and the Belt being distinct, down to their inhabitants' physiology), but it's appreciated all the same. In a different work, there'd be time to fully flesh things out, it could be the focus, but again, Siege of Terra. It's on the cover that you're here for a war story.
So, yeah. Book's okay. Just not really my cup of tea.