Babylon 5 isn’t really a series you can condense down that much in my opinion. You can not watch a few episodes of Season 1 - I think you can cut it from 22 episodes to like 16 if you’re brutal - but after that there’s just too much in the margins to do the same without compromising the meat of the story.
I actually watched the first of these.
It's interesting, I enjoyed it. I'm gonna continue.
The roughest part was the transition from the scenes in The Gathering to the main season because of the character changes.
What he chose to include and highlight:
- The Narn / Centauri conflict, and bringing Morden into it. He basically smushed the conflicts over Ragesh 3 and Quadrant 37 together. It was cool to experience as a story, but also some visual elements get noticed (like why is Londo holding a black box when Morden confronts him for the first time? The edit can't explain that, but the fan knows what it's for, but in the long run it doesn't matter).
- Ivanova's dad and reckoning- it felt like it was most of the "episode."
- Thalia, including Kosh's "negotiation" (this one actually surprised me for reasons I don't wanna go into to avoid spoiling for our friend watching the series).
What he chose to leave out:
- The Minbari. I mean, Delenn is in it, but barely, and of no consequence.
- Dr. Franklin, Lennier, Lyta Alexander- they're just not in it (even though the doctor and original 2nd in command are in a scene in order to set up Kosh).
- Adira (so I'll be curious how that will play out given what happens in season 3)
- Anything around SInclair's background mystery, but I know there is a whole separate "episode" what covers all that.
I expected the first one to be the roughest, mostly because of The Gathering. But I look forward to the rest, mostly because I think he's making a point to include some of the most memorable moments even if they're not most important to the plot (i.e., every scene with Rabbi Kaslov and G'Kar singing about fishies to his supper).
> I liked how they explained or lamp shaded some of the cliches of the genre, such as why does the commander of the place have to go on the dangerous missions all the time? His friend thinks he's a former war hero with a possible death wish. Ok, fair enough.
*nods vigorously*
Even fans hate that episode ("Infection") and I don't, because it's an early episode, it has some great guest actors, is still fun, and yes that scene with Garibaldi and Sinclair.
Fans generally agree that season 2 is leaps ahead and frankly I disagree- I think it's as spotty as season 1. But I hold season 1 in much higher regard than most, for whatever that's worth. I think season 1 is a gem- the mystery of the end of the Minbari war via Delenn, the dynamics of the Psi-Corps / Ivanova / Thalia/ Bester, and most importantly the Narrn / Centauri conflict as leveraged through G'Kar and Londo, which is IMO the best portrayal of space-countries at war I've ever seen in TV, and that must include this first season which is both aftermath and prelude.
I also wanna shout out to guest stars.
- Theodore Bikel, portraying Rabbi Koslov. Bikel is one of the leading lights of Jewish-American thespianism. He is the actor that portrayed Tevya the Dairyman- main character of
Fiddler on the Roof-- more than anyone in history, starting as a stage actor in Mandatory Palestine. He was a leader of a major acting trade union, played countless roles across genres including in counterculture stuff like a Frank Zappa movie, and even in genre stuff like playing Worf's adoptive dad in Star Trek: TNG.
A lot of B5 is kind of reaction to Trek- as great as Trek is, there are gaps or prejudices that allowed other things to fill in when it portrays a future of humans in space. While Trek was good about showing diversity, it didn't show continuity. In B5, you will see African names and humans having different religions and clothes. Seeing a rabbi in space leading a shiva with Hebrew prayers was rather shocking to me. I also loved how he and Sinclair got along, and that Sinclair's background as a Jesuit student gives him an inherent appreciation for thoughtful religious leaders (I would have loved to see him get on with Brother Theo).
- Walter Koenig. I mean... Bester, by the guy what played Chekov, holy crap, how cool?!