100 Classic Book Collection

Recommended Videos

Galletea

Inexplicably Awesome
Sep 27, 2008
2,877
0
0
A few days after Christmas, I braved the hoards of shoppers, the icy temperatures and the equally icy temperament of the shop assistants. Why would I subject myself to this? After all, I detest shopping. My reasoning was that a new cartridge for the DS had been released, and I decided that I must have it. You will notice that I said 'cartridge' and not 'game'. This is because the thing that I yearned for was in fact not a game, but is entitled 100 Classic Book Collection.

This release is a collaboration of Nintendo and Harper-Collins and does exactly what it claims to. It is a collection of 100 books by the most renowned authors. So of course, if the thought of reading a Dickens or Austen has you trembling with horror, then perhaps this is not for you.

100 Classic Book Collection is presented and packaged very neatly and has a number of useful and interesting features. Firstly there is the way in which the books are presented, lined up on a bookshelf for your perusal, in alphabetical order. You simply tap the book you want and begin to read, or look at the information it gives you on the author and the book itself.

If you have trouble deciding what to read, there is a quiz that asks various multiple choice questions about your lifestyle and somehow then decides what books you might like (although what my preference of coffee over tea, or choice of pet has to do with my reading preferences is yet for me to ascertain). Whether the questions make sense or not is irrelevant, as you own all 100 books anyway and it is a good way of choosing what you want to read.

The settings allow you to set music or sound to your reading if that is your wont, the choices range from tranquil music to a the simulated rhythm and bustle of a train, so if you usually read on your commute, you can recreate that effect anywhere. More useful settings allow you to alter the layout for whether you are right or left handed, and there is an option to make the text larger.

This brings us to the actual reading part. The DS is used on its side, and the text is displayed on both screens as in a book. Tapping one side of the screen will turn the page, with a page turning sound (a nice touch I hope you will agree) and tapping the other side will turn the page back again. Tapping the bottom of the screen brings up a scroll bar so you can find a particular page, and tapping at the top brings up a list of options. One of these options is the bookmark option. There are three bookmarks that you can use, place one of these and next time you switch on, you can resume reading immediately. It is also possible to change how you turn your pages, (I personally favour setting a shoulder button to turn the page as it is nearer to where I have my thumb when reading) which is helpful, as not everyone holds a book in the same manner. Once you have read a book, you are then asked to give it a score out of ten and choose a word from the list to describe it. These rankings can then be updated via wi-fi to give you an idea how the book is rated by others.



Graphically, there is not much to tell. The font is easy to read and a perfect size for the DS screens. The book spines are bright and based on the Harper Collins hardback editions, however this makes it a little difficult to read the name on the spine, while you are scrolling through the collection. This collection (as I can not really call it a game) works very well on the DS lite, the screens make reading easy and the adjustable light make it much easier on the eyes.

So then, what are the negatives? What could possibly be bad about this trove of literature? Well the first thing is unfortunately the selection of classics on offer. 100 books it may be but in this 100 lies 22 Shakespeare plays and 12 Dickens novels. I have no qualms with Dickens, but Shakespeare is not among the things I like to read. Don't get me wrong, I love the plays, but reading them is a chore. My personal preferences aside, I would have to have seen a little more variation in the choices. That being said, there is a wonderful selection here: From Austen and the Brontës through Dickens and Dumas to Shakespeare, Sir Walter Scott and Oscar Wilde, to name but a few.

The text size only comes in small or big, there is no middle ground. There are only 3 bookmarks, the music is hardly inspiring, the quiz makes no sense, and it wants you to describe a book in one word. There are a number of little things that could be improved to make this a more enjoyable experience but as I'm sure you can see, I'm being pedantic. As I said, it does exactly what it says on the box. It is a collection of 100 classic books, what more do you want a book to do?

The recommended retail price on this is £19.99. That is twenty pounds for 100 books. You could probably buy a DS lite and this and still not have been able to afford that many books. Of course not every book in here is going to be to everyone's tastes, but if you like literature, this is an indispensable addition to any book collection, and fantastic value for money at that.
 

Fightgarr

Concept Artist
Dec 3, 2008
2,913
0
0
Its a strange concept, and I'm not exactly sure who the target audience is. I would prefer to just read an actual book, but I guess bringing some of the thicker books on the subway can be a bit cumbersome.

I wouldn't get it myself, but I'm glad that it came out because of its encouragement of reading habits.
 

ThaBenMan

Mandalorian Buddha
Mar 6, 2008
3,682
0
0
Nice review. That's a pretty cool idea, another of those neat applications that make the DS more than just a handheld "game" device. If I had a DS I would probably buy it - I would like to be more "well-read", having not read many of the classics, and this would be a lot easier and cheaper than buying the actual books I think.
 

pigeon_of_doom

Vice-Captain Hammer
Feb 9, 2008
1,171
0
0
And with an install base that pisses on the Kindles, could this be a new long term buisness venture on Nintendos part? I'd be interested to see if Nintendo take this any further, although I can't see this being a huge seller.
 

Galletea

Inexplicably Awesome
Sep 27, 2008
2,877
0
0
pigeon_of_doom said:
And with an install base that pisses on the Kindles, could this be a new long term buisness venture on Nintendos part? I'd be interested to see if Nintendo take this any further, although I can't see this being a huge seller.
Me either really, especially as it is a Europe only release I believe. I imagine thar's to do with the different publishing houses being reluctant to lose potential profits.

However, I really hope that it sells well enough to make another. Perhaps a modern classics collection. There is a lot of Shakespeare for me to get through. But then again, I've read 3 books so far, I still have a fair way to go.
 

pigeon_of_doom

Vice-Captain Hammer
Feb 9, 2008
1,171
0
0
galletea said:
However, I really hope that it sells well enough to make another. Perhaps a modern classics collection. There is a lot of Shakespeare for me to get through. But then again, I've read 3 books so far, I still have a fair way to go.
I think the reason they went with the "Classics" angle is that anything modern would be copyrighted. Couldn't see a modern classics collection with the same number of titles being available for twice the price of this. Stupid draconian copyright laws.

Are there many notes in this? You mentioned information given on the author and the book itself but I usually need a reasonable amount. Especially with Shakespeare and other classics, annotations would be preferable but not practical I suppose. I don't have a DS so I won't be getting it, just curious as it seems they could be onto something here.

Good luck with the Shakespeare. Especially without annotations.
 

Fineldar

New member
Jun 8, 2008
214
0
0
Wow, I had never heard of this. It makes me want a DS, I could carry 100 books around in my pocket without incredibly small type and thin pages.

How much did it cost?
 

vede

New member
Dec 4, 2007
859
0
0
Hmm, that'd probably be pretty cool if I had a DS, and if it weren't just classic literature. I dislike most classic literature, and it's not much help that I'm required to read it because some old guy at the head of the English department of the US education system thinks that I should.

I think that they could do this a lot more and with many different books if this venture goes well. It'd be cool if they could actually get books from different cultures and countries and release them to the rest of the world. Perhaps an "American Stories" and a "Chinese Stories" and "Russian Stories" and so on. That could help to get more people interested in other cultures around the world and such.

Wow, I'm going pretty far with this...
 

Galletea

Inexplicably Awesome
Sep 27, 2008
2,877
0
0
pigeon_of_doom said:
I think the reason they went with the "Classics" angle is that anything modern would be copyrighted. Couldn't see a modern classics collection with the same number of titles being available for twice the price of this. Stupid draconian copyright laws.

Are there many notes in this? You mentioned information given on the author and the book itself but I usually need a reasonable amount. Especially with Shakespeare and other classics, annotations would be preferable but not practical I suppose. I don't have a DS so I won't be getting it, just curious as it seems they could be onto something here.

Good luck with the Shakespeare. Especially without annotations.
Yeah, the copyright thing was my theory too, I can dream though. And there are no notes so I'm going to have to use my intellect to decipher Shakespearean English.
 

Trivun

Stabat mater dolorosa
Dec 13, 2008
9,830
0
0
I think it's quite ambitious and interesting and I've got no problem with the concept (I myself am reading the Merchant of Venice on the internet to prepare for a drama audition on Friday), but I think for the DS it's pretty pointless. I have a library near me plus 4 more on and near my university campus, so I can always go there to read these books, and likely most people will have some sort of library near them where they can read for free. Also, none of the books in the collection are protected by copyright which is why Nintendo and Harper Collins were able to include them all. Therefore they are available for free on the internet in the exact same way as the Merchant of Venice is for me. Overall it's a good idea, but I personally wouldn't waste money on a collection of books that I can find anywhere completely free, especially when I would only be interested in about half anyway.
 

Galletea

Inexplicably Awesome
Sep 27, 2008
2,877
0
0
Trivun said:
I think it's quite ambitious and interesting and I've got no problem with the concept (I myself am reading the Merchant of Venice on the internet to prepare for a drama audition on Friday), but I think for the DS it's pretty pointless. I have a library near me plus 4 more on and near my university campus, so I can always go there to read these books, and likely most people will have some sort of library near them where they can read for free. Also, none of the books in the collection are protected by copyright which is why Nintendo and Harper Collins were able to include them all. Therefore they are available for free on the internet in the exact same way as the Merchant of Venice is for me. Overall it's a good idea, but I personally wouldn't waste money on a collection of books that I can find anywhere completely free, especially when I would only be interested in about half anyway.
This is a good point. However I personally feel that having these books on the DS is a very good way of making them more accessible to people. I could go to a library and get these books, but then I have a time limit on when I can read them. I'm happy to pay the low price asked for this, just so I can have it at my convenience. The fact that it is even more portable than a book is a bonus for me.
 

Fignutz

New member
Jan 18, 2009
62
0
0
Good review, a very interesting find! If I still had my DS I would've definitely picked this cartridge up.
 

Shivari

New member
Jun 17, 2008
706
0
0
Thank you for bringing this to my attention, I'll probably be picking this up once I finish the books I'm reading for school right now.
 

Galletea

Inexplicably Awesome
Sep 27, 2008
2,877
0
0
Xiado said:
I may actually pick this up. Admittedly, I probably have read a few of them, and the ones that had to be translated likely don't have great translations.
They are all the Harper Collins editions, so the translations are in fact very good, and yes you probably have read a few of them, but if you read six books of it, you've already had your money's worth.
 

Whiskyjakk

New member
Apr 10, 2008
223
0
0
The only problem I can see with this is that since they aren't copyrighted most of them can be found at Project Gutenberg or elsewhere on the Internet. True this means you can only read them when you're sitting at the computer but I prefer a physical copy of a book for travel and you can get one of those for free from any library or (often) very cheap from secondhand book shops.
 

Corpse XxX

New member
Jan 19, 2009
1,632
0
0
Good Review..
This is an interesting idea, and a fresh way to bring books to the younger generation.
Also great to have on trips and journeys this..
Maybe they should have thought about including movies also, just like a tiny hand held tv, but with catridges containing up to for instance 1-5 films.
Ideas are endless

But as long as there is only shakespeare and similar, it would not be my cup of tea.
I really enjoy the adventures written by Clive Cussler..
 

MiloP

New member
Jan 23, 2009
441
0
0
Could you imagine the Achievements for this if it were on the 360? :D

Smashing review, you seemed to say a lot of things about a game that I would find distinctly hard to review, but you know your clutching at straws for things to say when your opener is 'It's very nicely packaged."

Still good though.
 

Galletea

Inexplicably Awesome
Sep 27, 2008
2,877
0
0
MiloP said:
Could you imagine the Achievements for this if it were on the 360? :D

Smashing review, you seemed to say a lot of things about a game that I would find distinctly hard to review, but you know your clutching at straws for things to say when your opener is 'It's very nicely packaged."

Still good though.
It was a figure of speech regarding presentation, but thanks all the same.
 

MiloP

New member
Jan 23, 2009
441
0
0
galletea said:
MiloP said:
Could you imagine the Achievements for this if it were on the 360? :D

Smashing review, you seemed to say a lot of things about a game that I would find distinctly hard to review, but you know your clutching at straws for things to say when your opener is 'It's very nicely packaged."

Still good though.
It was a figure of speech regarding presentation, but thanks all the same.
Oh, fair enough then. Just read my praise again but this time stop at 'Smashing review'. :D