Jimmy Donnellan said:
Shaming me for aggregating a Chive post is beautifully ironic considering how much those guys steal without giving any credit whatsoever: http://imgur.com/a/lvqZk
And so we're clear, I never claimed to have written the whole thing or the basis, just the opening copy and the removal of some other games that didn't warrant being included on the list.
Content aggregation is a huge part of modern journalism. The Escapist do it:
http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/139742-John-Wick-Movie-Franchise-Lionsgate-Keanu-Reeves (source: Variety)
http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/139835-PS4-Outsells-Xbox-One-Again-in-January-2015 (source: VG247)
http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/139833-Hasbro-Unveils-Star-Wars-Themed-Furby (source: Mashable)
Those were just three from the homepage.
Wow, I'm really upset that they didn't provide adequate sources and actually add text and interpretation throughout the article as they wrote it
...
Oh wait, they did.
Aggregating entertainment news stories on an entertainment site makes sense. The difference is they added to it, not just take out the middle six entries, slap their name on the top, and not even bother to add any form of interpretation or impression.
That's what separates "modern journalism" from a shitty tumblr.
You also don't see Escapist writers crawling through GI or IGN forums plugging stolen articles that they claim to have written.
By putting your name on top of the article, and not sourcing, you did claim to have written the whole thing - if I republish a book without the middle chapters, I still stole it, even if I didn't explicitly say "I made this."
Seriously, they teach how to properly write an article with cited sources in middle school.
EDIT: Also, in regards to your comment about the Chive, stealing from a thief doesn't make it less stolen.