I remember Columbine...
I was 14 at the time, and an avid gamer with both my PC and my original Playstation. Granted I always preferred, and still do, RPG's over shooters and action games but when the two killers and their obsession with Doom came up the first thing that came to mind was this...
Why are they obsessed with Doom? It's an antique, a product of a bygone age that has come and gone. Why not any of the newer titles, Quake 2, Half Life, Unreal... all of these were both better AND more violent than Doom, in all of its incarnations in that generation.
Clearly Doom held an appeal outside of its violence to those two. Recalling what was said about them, I'm guessing it was probably the Satanic Elements of the title that appealed to them, as the pair fashioned themselves as Satanists if I recall correctly. Even then technically Quake 1 was set in Hell, why not that?
It never really made much sense, but it still makes me wonder whether or not the violent behavior is about Videogames... or whether it's about obsession.
Take the recent Halo 3 kid or that poor kid who died over Call of Duty 4. Halo 3 was outdated when he killed his mother over it...so why Halo 3? Why not Gears of War, or Call of Duty... I think the kid had built himself a nice little pedestal to Halo in his mind, an obsession that could easily be replaced with anything, Music, Body Modification, A Girl... anything and when deprived of said obsession who is to say that he wouldn't have the same goddamn reaction?
It's a sad, scapegoating world we live in, everyone just wants someone to blame. But then again, Cognative Dissonance (the statement "Mistakes were made but not by me" sums it up) is a core aspect of the human experience. One that isn't ever likely to go away, so we just need to deal with the fallout I guess.