dscross said:
Yoshi178 said:
But Zelda: BOTW was 2017's GOTY. Not Horizon.
And Zelda BOTW is definitely not coming to PC anytime soon
Are these games markedly different gameplay-wise other the brand awareness with Zelda (other than the fact link can climb up everything)? I haven't played BOTW, only watched someone else on a Switch, but, just superficially without playing it, it seems HZD is more interesting because it has a fully fleshed out and compelling story. I was happy to complete HZD based on the mystery of solving what the world was alone. It doesn't seem like I'd get that with BOTW.
BotW was more focused on melee combat to HZD being more or less pure range.
My overall assessement of BotW was that they obviously wanted to shake up the formula... but I'm not sure they had any concrete idea how to do so. You've the insane collectathons that would make Ubisoft blush, the most engaging part is combat but thats busted up by the weird durability stuff. Then a nutty crafting system from a survival game tossed on, and the permanent upgrades you get resemble MMO structure (as does most of the world, right down to recoloring enemies rather then having a full roster). Along with the intermittently dotted puzzles which feel like they were salvaged out of some discarded puzzle game (granted, this was the main place in which it seemed somewhat true to Zelda, puzzles are hardly abnormal, just the odd physics powers gave off that impression).
HZD on its hand, seemed to be aspiring to open world single player Monster Hunter. I wouldn't say they entirely nailed the strengths of that either. And the open world definitely lacked a certain element of random encounters or interactions between machines (which did exist in the lore and few cutscenes, but generally not dynamically in the world). I'd give it the story strength of BotW, but combat in HZD could get a tad clinical once you learned how to beat a robot, it was a pretty rinse-repeat process for all similar robots. And keeping at range usually kept you out of any viscerally threatening situation.